3 ms·
"US Americans" ?!
by davidw 16y ago
"US Americans" ?!
- bhousel 16y agoAs it's a guide for international students at NYU, I think that's implied.
- crasshopper 16y agoSure, as opposed to Central Americans, South Americans, Mexicans, or Canadians. There is no estadounidenses in English but "Americans" logically includes Alaskans through Argentinians.
- davidw 16y agoReminds me of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww I suppose it's technically correct, but it doesn't sound good at all. Especially since they already just used 'Americans' in the title. "People of the United States" or something like that also reads better. Sure, citizens of other countries in the Americas could also be called Americans, but in reality, if you're trying to actually communicate clearly with other people, rather than score political correctness points, you would not use that term for, say, a Canadian or a Brazilian, because there are already perfectly good, more specific terms for citizens of said countries. Likewise, if you were really trying to talk about the commonalities of everyone from Alaskans to Argentinians you'd presumably use something like "peoples of the Americas".
- crasshopper 16y ago"Americans" is more idiomatic. But - I bet NYU has_many Chilean, Canadian, Costa Rican grad students who would be annoyed at the implicit exclusion.
- davidw 16y agoBut the thing is titled "Getting to Know Americans", so why bother with an ugly sounding turn of words when you've already crossed that bridge? I didn't think that "US Americans" was even correct when I posted - it doesn't sound at all right to my ears. > Chilean, Canadian, Costa Rican grad students who would be annoyed at the implicit exclusion. Only the ones with a chip on their shoulder.
- crasshopper 16y agoI was about to lament that English lacks a short, euphonic, idiomatic word for "US-icans" / US citizens & residents / culturally US people / estadounidenses. But then I remembered we do have such a word. Yanks.
- davidw 16y ago"Yank" doesn't really work either, sorry. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yankee#In_other_English-speaking_countries http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yankee#In_other_English-speakin... You'll just have to live with the fact that English doesn't have a convenient word. Even here in Italy, "americano" is much more common than statunitense.
- mturmon 16y agoThe proportion of "US Americans" who would self-describe as a "Yank" must be vanishingly small. I think the first rule about names is that the named person should recognize the results.
- crasshopper 16y agoYou would think so, but Christ never thought of himself as Christ; Hindu is a name made up by outsiders; and Germany sounds nothing like Deutschland. Anyway I was just seeking compromise.
- rdouble 16y agoNobody says yanks besides australians. And they don't really do it that much.
- crasshopper 16y agoAussies + Brits say it.
- yardie 16y agoYes, US Americans, as opposed to US Mexicans, or Canada Americans, Brasil Americans, or Columbia Americans. See what I did there.
- davidw 16y ago"What you did there", besides beat a dead meme-horse was invent words that no one actually uses, as far as I can tell.
- bostonpete 16y ago> a dead meme-horse It's reassuring to know that meme-horses can die. I was afraid we were stuck with them forever...
- LargeWu 16y agoFrom my experience, there has never been any confusion about which country I am from when I tell a non US citizen that I am "American". I have also never, in actual conversation, heard somebody refer to the totality of western hemisphere landmasses as "America". It is always either North America or South America. The only exception I can think of in that regard is when discussing "The Americas" from the perspective of 15th and 16th century European exploration.
- walidghaleb 16y agoColombia, not Columbia