3 ms·
The discussion here is focusing on the highly editorialized made up title, but as a writer I am concerned at the attitude here: The biggest benefit of GPT-3 is
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
The discussion here is focusing on the highly editorialized made up title, but as a writer I am concerned at the attitude here:
The biggest benefit of GPT-3 is efficiency. All I need to write is a good title and intro. I could write five of them in an hour and publish them all in one day if I wanted to.
The author admits that fact checked stuff can't be written this way. So you can't really produce solid writing this way. Yet it is being proposed as the future of content creation.
As someone who does some content creation, I really dislike this idea that this is "efficient" and "can save money." Good writing is increasingly hard to find as is, in part because we don't pay writers what we used to pay them. Good writing involves research and understanding the topic. It's not just about putting pretty words together.
I don't think this is a good trend.
- rikroots 6y agoI disagree, in part. As a (wannabe-science-fiction) writer, I think GPT-3 has potential to be useful. In my case, I have plenty of stories I want to write, lots of ideas that I want to play with. The thing I struggle with is writing the first draft of a story - it turns out that I find writing the first draft of a story to be really, really boring work (even with the help of NaNoWriMo). My fingers are typing out the words for chapter 3 but my brain is already grappling with the obvious plot holes in chapter 28. This is where GPT-3 could really help: churning out words to fill the page with crap first draft copy. Feed the existing copy into the GPT-3 engine, alongside some prompts about the directions I want the story to go, themes I want it to tackle, etc. Receive back 2-3 drafts of the next thousand-15 hundred words. Then edit the heck out of those suggested words to bring the crap copy into line with my vision for the chapter. I like this idea because most of my storytelling work happens in the first and second revisions, not the initial draft. I'd be happy to call the results my work, not the work of some mindless ML bot. Proper writers will probably feel differently about the process.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThat's a different use case than the one I'm criticizing. The use case I'm objecting to is "You, as a writer, are no longer relevant. We are replacing you with a bot to save money."
- rikroots 6y agoI can see your point. And my initial reaction to the whole ML-as-writer thing was hands-up horror. Like everything, I think this new tech is going to impact in both good, and bad, ways. In my scenario, I expect there will be a lot of books written by ML algorithms, then published/sold to readers with inadequate (or no) additional author/editor input. My bet for the first fiction genre to take this approach is Romance Pulp - particularly Mills&Boon-style novels which have been written in line with a tight template for decades. And ML 'authors' in the literary fiction genre - it wouldn't surprise me if these already exist!
- DoreenMichele 6y agoTBF, the part I quoted is in line with your remarks. Perhaps quoting a different part of the article would have worked better. (Shrug)