10 ms·
Even less data if you use uBlock Origin and possibly uMatrix (which is very high maintenance, but also reveals the utter insanity of the web). Without an adblo
by formerly_proven 6y ago
Even less data if you use uBlock Origin and possibly uMatrix (which is very high maintenance, but also reveals the utter insanity of the web).
Without an adblocker the internet is such a slow heap of trash that I'd never go back to not using one. This is also one of the main reasons I use my iPhone so little, since it doesn't really have any way to adblock.
- markn951 6y ago????????? https://apps.apple.com/us/app/wipr/id1030595027 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/wipr/id1030595027 Or like, any similar app. There's hundreds of them.
- nitrogen 6y agoThe only downside is that product managers who rely on third-party analytics to decide what platforms are relevant will never see Firefox+uBlock users as relevant. I've had to argue this at multiple companies; fortunately at some places multiple developers used uBlock so it wasn't as hard as making the case alone.
- godelski 6y ago> fortunately at some places multiple developers used uBlock so it wasn't as hard as making the case alone. Is adblocking not common? Every tech literate person I know uses an ad blocker. I'd say about 30-40% of millennials I know use them, most using ADB or uBlock Origin. Every time I see someone using a browser with ads I forget what a nightmare the internet is.
- cpeterso 6y agoThese sites claim the percentage of US web users using an ad blocker was 25% in 2016 and 27% in 2017: https://www.businessinsider.com/30-of-all-internet-users-will-ad-block-by-2018-2017-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/30-of-all-internet-users-wil... https://www.statista.com/topics/3201/ad-blocking/ https://www.statista.com/topics/3201/ad-blocking/
- kroltan 6y agoNot everywhere, I'd say it's common within specific crowds. At my company people are either don't know about them, or actually fundamentally disagree with their purpose. (No, it's not an AdTech company, before anyone asks)
- godelski 6y agoBut is it a software company? I can understand the disagreement, but with the state of things it is just atrocious. I'd be fine if things weren't so invasive and were clearly ads. Pop ups, pop unders, dark patterns to cause clicks, flashy images on text pages, malware injection, 10x page load times, etc are all reasons why I personally can't stand it. It just feels like they are trying to trick me into seeing their product instead of trying to generate real interest. Until then, I personally can't support it. I don't think most people minds ads, such as on TV, but everyone hates the ad that is 10x the volume of the show and that's how the internet feels to me currently.
- kelnos 6y ago> I don't think most people minds ads Is that true? I despise ads and the entire advertising industry. I would wear special glasses that would block billboards from my vision if they existed. I pay extra for the ad-free version of Hulu. When I'm at someone's house and they have cable and the TV is on, I find ad breaks incredibly jarring. Am I just an extreme outlier? It would make me sad for humanity if that was the case. Not minding blatant emotional manipulation in your face all day seems... not great.
- UI_at_80x24 6y ago>Am I just an extreme outlier? No. You are not alone. MOST people don't realize that there is an alternative.
- ACow_Adonis 6y agoI think it's more that they've been conditioned to accept ads. if you spend a significant time travelling through rather diverse countries, one of the first thing that hits you is different laws and norms around what can be advertised and where. moving through dictatorships and seeing elections is eye opening in its "weirdness". as a non American, visiting America and seeing laws, flags, billboards and medicine advertising is weird. anyway, my point is, if you haven't been brought up with it, you see it for what it is, and normal becomes what you experience every day. one you spend a few years ad free, it's incredibly hard to go back, it's really jarring, and you see advertising the same way you see plastered images of the dictator in absolutely random locations when you visit other countries (and there's a good reason for that, because they're fundamentally the same thing).
- zamadatix 6y agoOnly 30% of FF users have any add-ons at all. Only about 1/3 of those have adblock plus or unlock origin.
- llarsson 6y agoAlternatively, only 1/3 of Firefox users that also do not disable telemetry have any add-ons at all. More than a handful choose that browser for privacy, including keeping stuff private from Mozilla.
- newen 6y agoYeah, first thing I do when I install Firefox is disable telemetry and install uBlock.
- zamadatix 6y agoActually this debate came up so often they added a special telemetry coverage extension that ignored telemetry disabled status (to great uproar) on 1% of users and reported back the number of people with telemetry disabled. As expected "more than a handful" actually turned out to be "a vocal handful" out of the 200,000,000 MAU pool. Also those that disable telemetry after starting Firefox still sent telemetry. Mozilla only promises to delete it after 30 days not that they don't generate a number that says what % new installs in the last month disabled telemetry (though they don't publicly report this to my knowledge). So that leaves those with whitelist only firewalling or similar measures that I (hope?) we can all agree isn't going to swing these numbers at any interesting digit position.
- kelnos 6y agoAnecdotal, but I've pushed close friends who are reasonably technical to install an ad blocker. Without my urging, they wouldn't have had one at all. When I come across someone who doesn't adblock, it surprises me, but it really shouldn't, as it seems most people don't have an ad blocker.
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoI still don't use an ad blocker. I know all the arguments for ad blocking and I agree with many of them. I know what difference it makes in terms of performance and annoyance. But I just can't bring myself to indiscriminately block all ads, knowing how important they are as a funding source for the websites I use. There's only one thing that destroys privacy even more thoroughly than ad targeting: payment.
- rattray 6y agoOut of curiosity, do you mind sharing what sorts of websites you use that you feel this loyalty towards? News, community, educational, etc? Is it a small group of sites, or a wide variety?
- kbenson 6y agoNot GP, but I don't block youtube and I block most other stuff (because uBlock Origin blocks be default). Google is probably the most likely to track more info about me, but it's also obvious that the ads played factor into the money the content creators get, and I felt bad after a while of blocking their revenue stream. It's also got me really close to paying for YouTube red, which is the other option,and o e I wouldn't consider without the annoyance of ads.
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoIt's a wide variety of sites. Local news, tech news, science mags, other special interest sites, porn, discussion forums, Q&A sites, some social media. It's impossible to list them all. Essentially, it's the great variety of what's available on the open Web that I don't want to lose. I don't want everything to become one big app store with all its suffocating narrow-mindedness and oppressive control freakery.
- DominikD 6y agoI'm tech savvy (software developer for 15+ years) but I used to be a web journalist in my early days and I can appreciate the need of ads. So I wouldn't block ads until a year age or so. But I'm still very conscious of pages I visit, whether I want to give them eyeballs or not (POS at NYT are in the "not") and I exempt many pages from ad blocking.
- zamadatix 6y agoPercentage wise adblock users or Firefox users total to about 10% of users so it really depends on the target user demographic to say whether or not you need to specially account that those users aren't being reflected. Coding tools probably. Game for a social website probably not. Also depends on the financial model, if it's primarily ad based then the group of users you don't have good ad data for isn't something you should care about either.
- AlchemistCamp 6y agoI've run both Google Analytics and my own back-end analytics on the same site and found GA missing over 1/3 of my total non-bot traffic. Most of that traffic was Firefox.
- zamadatix 6y agoWould be curious which site that was and if it falls into the target demographic stuff mentioned. Also to note the above % for FF share isn't just from 3rd party analytics anyways, places like Wikimedia report similar numbers. Different services different amounts but again, target demographic usually and not by much unless it's extremely tech niche or something.
- AlchemistCamp 6y agoThe demographic is about 1/5 US, with sizable traffic from India, Brazil, Germany, Nigeria and Australia. It's mostly 18-45 and mostly male.
- Angeo34 6y agoWhile that number may be true you have to keep in mind that more than 50% of global FF users are based in DACH and by extension the rest of German speaking Europe (i.e. Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Switzerland).
- zamadatix 6y agoIgnoring that the DACH region only has ~100 million people and that if every last man woman and child were monthly FF users it still wouldn't be half of 210 million users... according to Mozilla's own stats at https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity regional MAU is: 10M Brazil 13M China 12M France 20M Germany 12M India 9M Indonesia 6M Italy 7M Poland 7M Russia 30M United States It's honestly a bit frustrating how even on HN everyone thinks they know who around the world uses something more than the actual public data on it. On one hand you have people insisting the data is missing huge swaths of people and on the other you have people insisting a region has over half the users when that would be less than half the users according to the very data the other person is trying to say is missing lots of people!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- viraptor 6y agoThat should be easy to prove with user agents from the web logs - show the analytics vs access log percentage difference.
- htwyford 6y ago> This is also one of the main reasons I use my iPhone so little, since it doesn't really have any way to adblock. You can block ads in Safari iOS with a Content Blocker. 1Blocker is pretty robust: https://1blocker.com/ https://1blocker.com/ Firefox for iOS also has Tracking Protection built in, which blocks most ads.
- danShumway 6y agoSafari's content blocker API isn't really comparable to something like Ublock Origin. It'll definitely help with the web if your goal is just to speed things up and make things look better, but if you're worried about privacy, iOS's browser is going to be less thorough than other platforms. It doesn't even support page-source rewrites, let alone protecting against more advanced anti-adblock techniques like CNAME cloaking. Funnily enough, this has come up a few times in the context of Chrome's manifest V3 changes, where people have asked why it matters since Safari already works pretty similarly to what Google is proposing. Ironically, the answer is that the similarity is exactly why we know it's a bad idea for Chrome to go in the same direction. Safari has less effective adblocking compared to where the rest of the industry is at. It's always going to be easier to bypass what is effectively a declarative DNS blocklist than it is to bypass a system that can run blocking logic per-request.
- hosteur 6y agodoes not seem to be open source. Why is it trustworthy of my entire browsing history?
- edlebert 6y agoSafari content blockers do not have access to your browsing history. It’s a declared list of patterns to block.
- evolve2k 6y agoYou’ll want to get ‘Firefox Focus’ and then set the ad tracking on for safari. Focus is designed to be a short use browser that deliberately minimises tracking, akin to fast access private browsing. That said you only need to get the app to turn on their tracking protection which blocks ads on Safari. https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/software/mozilla-is-adding-an-ad-blocker-to-firefox-focus-90/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/software/mozilla-is-ad...
- ThePowerOfFuet 6y agoYou can install Adblock and Firefox Focus, both of which install a content blocking module you can enable in Safari (you have to switch them on manually).
- djhworld 6y agoSetup a pihole and point your iPhone DNS settings to that. You can use wireguard to tunnel to it when you are outside of your home network
- aembleton 6y agoOr just use NextDNS: https://nextdns.io/ https://nextdns.io/ Not much setup or configuration needed.
- shandor 6y ago> very high maintenance Reading this, I was actually surprised to find that for some reason or other this has gotten a lot better for me during the 2+ years I've been using uMatrix. At first it's rather annoying to enable CDNs and stuff for the sites you frequent, but mostly I've started noticing that the sites that break for basically no good reason are the ones that a sane person probably shouldn't visit anyway. So maybe it is just that I've started steering clear of those sites. Also as a side note, uMatrix is awesome. Many times even on HN I'm surprised to find comments complaining about pop ups or something, and realize that uMatrix silently made my browsing actually tolerable.
- ffpip 6y agoI love uMatrix. It removes all annoyances like customer support popups, chat bots, basically anything other than the main domain. It is high maintainance, only if you visit many new sites every day. For a single site/domain, set it once and go. There are built in 'recipes' allowing YT embeds, twitter embeds, google capthas if a site wants it. Once you globally whitelist CDN's (cloudflare and others), it's enough. For popular sites (reddit, YT, twitter use the Recipes)
- shostack 6y agoWhat are these recipes? Video embeds and captchas are my biggest headaches with it now.
- tastefulness 6y agoRecipes are sets of rules needed to make a website work. If there is a recipe available for a page you are visiting you will be able to click on the puzzle icon in uMatrix and enable it.
- aembleton 6y agohttps://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix/wiki/Ruleset-recipes https://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix/wiki/Ruleset-recipes
- 6y ago
- chris_st 6y agoBig fan of NextDNS -- since I installed it on my iPhone, no ads. At all.
- abawany 6y agoYes, I switched to it fairly wholesale (1) when the paying plan became available. It is eye opening what all my devices look up in the course of their operation. 1: apps on my Windows, Android, iOS devices along with specifying it as the default nameserver in my routers.
- apeace 6y agoGet Firefox Focus for iOS. It integrates with Safari as an ad blocker. I’ve been using it for a couple years and love it.
- Xenoamorphous 6y agoI think it’d be more honest to simply not visit those ad ridden sites. My concern with ad blocker proliferation is that it invariably leads to paywalled content. Which I’m sure most HN users are ok with, thanks to their 6 figures jobs, but I think it’s a bad thing overall.
- yelloworangefog 6y agoI seem to remember reading something about a year ago about uBlock Origin being a security concern (like harvesting user data or something). Am I misremembering?
- gorhill 6y ago> Am I misremembering? Yes.
- yelloworangefog 6y agoAh, my bad...
- bredren 6y agoThere are two solutions I’ve used: 1. Content blockers for safari are sold in the App Store. Not bad. 2. A private Pinole instance on a vps. Just set your phone to connect to it. There are turnkey docker installs of this now. Neither are perfect / have quirks. I def recommend pinhole. I thought it would be a pain to set up, it wasn’t and it’s great.
- garren 6y agoPihole or NextDNS. The latter is nice because you can quickly toggle it on or off in the event that adblocking breaks something.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoWill #2 block ads in Apps as well as Safari? Games for my young kids have terrible ads and finding quality, ad free ads (even paid) is very hard to do. I really wish Apple Arcade would release some early-ed games.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bredren 6y agoNo, you need to route their traffic through a VPN running pihole. Presuming you have a decent set of rules it can block ads and shield the IPs of your kids devices.