4 ms·
>"I must confess, I actually lied earlier when I told you only one person noticed. Only one person reached out to me to ask if GPT-3 was writing the articles. H
by Barrin92 6y ago
>"I must confess, I actually lied earlier when I told you only one person noticed. Only one person reached out to me to ask if GPT-3 was writing the articles. However, there were a few commenters on hacker news who also guessed it. Funny enough, nobody took notice because the community downvoted the comments."
this is pretty hilarious. Although the genre has probably much to do with it, virtually all business/productivity/ lifestyle/self-help stuff has the same sort of generic tone and is full of crap
- jayd16 6y agoI'm finding it hard to distinguish the article from the normal self-help word salad. It doesn't seem out of place to me. Articles are also upvoted because of the discussions in the threads so I'm not that surprised a lot of "warm body" type threads make it to the top.
- Klinky 6y agoI would sometimes listen to New Dimensions radio very early in the morning on NPR on my way to work. It's a show about new age spiritually concepts, typically with interviews of new agey book authors. I eventually had to turn it off, as while the dialogue was grammatically correct, it was repetitive and basically incomprehensible. It was like a stream of consciousness that lacked substance behind any of the words being said.
- deeg 6y agoMaybe we should go back and up-vote the poster who recognized GPT-3. Seems a little unfair now that we know they were right!
- stareatgoats 6y agoSeems people already did ...
- smitty1e 6y agoFa(ir|re) is what you pay to ride a bus.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leafboi 6y agoIt's actually quite scary and shows a lot about human nature. The comment in question was insightful and displayed intuition and judgement a level up beyond other people. Really every other comment was a load of crap, and the one comment of actual substance was buried. Many comments like this are voted down on HN. These are the comments that should in a perfect world be the top voted comment under any topic. The fact that this is common shows that there is a huge difference between what people actually value and what they think they value. People value opinions they agree with, not opinions that are new, different or insightful. What's even more scary is the fact that the comment wasn't insulting. It was factual and to the point, yet the replier accused the original commenter of punching below the belt and not being civil. Accusations that originated completely from his imagination. It shows that people in general don't just respectfully disagree with differing opinions. People attack all opinions that aren't inline with theirs. And what's even more crazy is no one is aware of this. That responder thinks he's being civil and logical when in reality he's being stupid, illogical and biased. I know the policies of HN are done for the purpose of preventing HN from becoming like 4chan or reddit. BUt where do I find a community where that guy who made the insightful GPT-3 comment will get voted up? Somewhere buried in every HN topic is a comment that is ahead of it's time but you won't see it because it's been buried to oblivion by the mob.
- oscargrouch 6y agoI guess part of the problem is that our brains tend to use the authority of who says what to validate the opinion. We need to switch our brains to focus on what is being said instead and a lot of people have a problem with this. When there's no way to define the authority of who is saying it, the authority is transferred to the subject instead, in this case "Hacker News". People will have a tendency to flock on the authority represented now by the subject. (BTW, in my experience HN is the best place i know where "whats being said" is more important and have an authority on its own, and the reason why i keep coming back here)
- leafboi 6y ago>(BTW, in my experience HN is the best place i know where "whats being said" is more important and have an authority on its own, and the reason why i keep coming back here) I agree. Still, even though it is the "best" it is still quite bad and this very article proves the point.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 6y agoIt’s too easy to get enough upvotes to be able to downvote anything you want. Downvoting prevents others from seeing a comment and there are no safeguards to ensure that facts don’t get buried by bandwagons. HN clearly means to control downvoting because it requires a minimum karma, but it’s no longer effective. Perhaps also limit the number of upvotes an account can dole out and a comment can receive...