4 ms·
The FDA has done plenty of research on direct to consumer (DTC) advertising for drugs.[1] It's not like they just said "yeah, that's cool, go ahead". In a rep
by refurb 6y ago
The FDA has done plenty of research on direct to consumer (DTC) advertising for drugs.[1] It's not like they just said "yeah, that's cool, go ahead".
In a report from 2015, the FDA found that there were benefits (shocking!) and drawbacks to DTC advertizing.
Positives:
- Most physicians agreed that because their patient saw a DTC ad, he or she asked thoughtful questions during the visit.
- Many physicians thought that DTC ads made their patients more involved in their health care.
- The study demonstrated that when a patient asked about a specific drug, 88 percent of the time they had the condition that the drug treated. And 80 percent of physicians believed their patients understood what condition the advertised drug treats.
- Eighty-two percent responded either "very well" or "somewhat" when asked whether they believe that their patients understand that only a doctor can decide whether a drug is right for them.
Negatives:
- 65 percent believe DTC ads confuse patients about the relative risks and benefits of prescription drugs
- Eight percent of physicians said they felt very pressured to prescribe the specific brand-name drug when asked.
[1]https://www.fda.gov/drugs/drug-information-consumers/impact-direct-consumer-advertising https://www.fda.gov/drugs/drug-information-consumers/impact-...
- tmpz22 6y agoThoughtful questions like "shouldn't I be using this drug"? Isn't that what the doctor is there for, particularly for a broad enough condition that it is targeted by ads?
- refurb 6y agoDepends on the doctor and specialty. Family medicine covers a massive number of diseases that are treated by thousands of different drugs. Family doctors may, but not always, know about newly approved drugs.
- tmpz22 6y agoIs there no database where they can lookup "drugs for x" as a quick refresher? Aren't they paid like 300k/yr?
- refurb 6y agoSure, there are service that collect data for new drugs. But do you want your doctor prescribing something they’ve glanced at for 5 min? Take a look at the label for a random drug, it’s often 20 pages or more of data. Doctors, rightfully so, don’t want to prescribe something unless they are well versed in benefits and risks. That takes time and effort.
- bluGill 6y agoSure, but like everyone doctors get lazy and won't look into new (maybe better) treatments if not forced somehow.
- sukilot 6y ago> Eighty-two percent responded either "very well" or "somewhat" when asked whether they believe that their patients understand that only a doctor can decide whether a drug is right for them. That's a huge negative in my mind. Blind faith in doctors is terrible for health.
- solidasparagus 6y agoPatients who have a little bit of knowledge and think that means they can make as informed decisions as professionals are also terrible for health. People tend to dramatically overestimate how much they know about complicated topics like medicine.
- raverbashing 6y agoThat's an interesting research. But it seems it's not making a distinction between the multi-thousands drug for very specific conditions together with Tylenol and other OTC stuff. DTCs have a point and being involved in your care makes sense. Doctors also get plenty of doctor-targeted specific advertisements/incentives as well (some less ethical than others) The main issue I see is that ads might be pushing for the "latest" treatment which might not be the most effective or have the best cost-benefit.
- refurb 6y agoIt was limited to prescription drug DTC, but yes, you're point about cost-effectiveness is true. That typically falls on the patient and their insurance, but the system doesn't make the ability to take cost into account very easy at all (i.e. you usually find out the cost when paying for the Rx).
- triceratops 6y agoThis isn't conclusive by itself. Thanks to the Internet, consumers can conduct their own research on what drugs exist to treat their conditions. Do patients in countries where prescription drug advertising is illegal ask fewer questions or have less understanding of or involvement in their healthcare?
- missedthecue 6y agoYou would be stunned at the number of people to whom it would never occur to search the web for drugs, and among those who do try to search, how poorly they do it. The average person is still not very intuitive when it comes to that area. On top of this, the majority of drug consumers are old people, who (statistically speaking) are far less likely to even use the internet at all. This is why drug advertising can be quite useful for them.