3 ms·
And the root of this is essentially politics keeping competent people from getting interested in nuclear. We can't do nuclear properly because society tells al
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
And the root of this is essentially politics keeping competent people from getting interested in nuclear.
We can't do nuclear properly because society tells all the smart engineers and financiers that they should be doing other things.
A lot of "boring things" suffer from this problem.
- epistasis 6y agoI don't think that's true. We had the same construction problems in the 70s when we wouldn't have had such a shortage. There are tons of super smart people working on nuclear startups right now, with big funding. It's all bad management, bad execution, and bad promises. And since few of any around the world have been able to keep construction promises recently, it may just be part of the natural variability of the construction process. And 2-3x variability is not a desirable trait for $10B projects, where most of the lifetime cost is in the upfront construction.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoYeah, you are right. The part that causes these projects to fail isn't the nuclear part. It's the construction part. You can't just take a construction crew that's used to building highways or skyscrapers and expect them to build a nuclear complex properly. This was the exact problem they had in the 70s, the contractors didn't understand why things had to be done a certain way, so they did it the way they thought it should be done. Then it turned out that the problems that many of the safety and operational issues that occurred later were due to not doing it properly in the first place. Nuclear is sexy, construction isn't. There is a great book on the history of the US nuclear power industry that goes into this called Beyond Engineering: How Technology Shapes Society. The technical issues were only a small part of why nuclear power is not more widely used. Countries like France that standardized on reactor design and had enough projects that construction crews could gain experience with the different processes and requirements involved were much more successful in deploying nuclear power.