5 ms·
To get a sense of the difficulty, imagine sending a million people to the South Pole to set up a self-sustaining colony. That would be much more than 1000 times
by ncmncm 6y ago
To get a sense of the difficulty, imagine sending a million people to the South Pole to set up a self-sustaining colony. That would be much more than 1000 times easier than establishing such a base on Mars.
- shireboy 6y agoI’ve often said the same thing. South Pole and underwater cities would be easier than mars or even moon colony. As much as I want the later to happen- I think 1 million people on Mars or Moon will require something that makes them more appealing than even the worst Earth locations. That has to be something pretty drastic. Elon says motivation will be “it’d be cool”. I don’t think that is enough motivation. Still, I’d rather have the capability developed than not, and hopefully those motivations present themselves without being too dire (like a comet heading our way)
- hugs 6y agoA science outpost, specifically as a place to put telescopes, seems the most compelling. The rest of the population would then grow along side the science outpost to service it (food, transportation, etc.) A looong time until a million people, though.
- buzzwordninja 6y agoWhy would you put a telescope in a gravity well though? Would it not be easier to build large structures in orbit or at one of the Lagrange points?
- ba2plus 6y agoThere's been some really interesting ideas for a new generation of telescopes that Starship's cargo capacity could enable. Telescopes on the far side of the moon are the classic example. They'd be shielded from the sun for 14 days out of 28, permanently shielded from Earth, and still have all the advantages of being in a vacuum. Gravitational-wave telescopes on the geologically-stable lunar surface are another interesting idea. But I think my favourite idea is infrared scopes in the polar craters, some of the coldest places in the solar system. You don't need a complicated JWST-style extendable sun shield or limited helium supply. You are limited in terms of direction, but that's not a bad tradeoff.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoAfrica was in Europe's back yard yet when they got the opportunity they colonized the Americas. Colonizing a formerly unexplored place where nobody has yet laid claim has a lot of appeal (and this time we (probably) don't have to kill/displace the natives to do it).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 6y agoEuropeans were kept out of Africa by disease.
- mschuster91 6y agoI'd rather say the Europeans were kept out of Africa because of nowhere near European levels of valuable resources (think farmland, wood) other than slaves for centuries. Diamonds and uranium are a recent thing.
- menybuvico 6y agoI always heard it was a logistic issue more than anything else? Getting from Europe to the Americas and then back in a sailing vessel is easier than getting to Africa's East coast and back.
- pfdietz 6y agoWhich explains why Africa was colonized so much more successfully than (checks notes) ... Australia?
- fastball 6y agoI'm interested in living on Mars. I'm not interested in living in Antarctica.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoMassive domes to act as greenhouses, melting a couple miles of ice cover. Fossils and untapped resources. Antarctica could be a lot of fun to colonize.
- Jach 6y agoEasier is a downside.
- ncmncm 6y agoIt would be smart to demonstrate ability to do thing A before attempting thing B that is 1000 times harder. With any luck, things you learn actually doing A, and then A' that is 10 times harder, and then A'' that is 100 times harder, will all turn out to be useful, even necessary, in tackling B. Failure is always an option, but there is no point in choosing it at the outset.
- cookingrobot 6y agoMaybe SpaceX should practice colonizing in Antarctica. They could fly all their gear in on Starships and do a dress rehearsal.
- bconnorwhite 6y agoTrue, but I'm not sure difficulty is as relevant if the motivation is there. You can't terraform the South Pole. Mars reopens the frontier whereas the South Pole is a dead end
- ncmncm 6y agoThe South Pole starts out way more terraformed than Mars can ever be. It has air, water, gravity, and is warmer. You can just put up domes and it's already way better than Mars. Mineral wealth is only a mile down, under the ice. Under the sea starts out way more terraformed than Mars can ever be. It has water, gravity, and is warmer. Mineral wealth is right at hand. The cloud tops of Venus start out way more terraformed than Mars can ever be. It has air pressure, gravity, water, carbon, sulfur, and shirtsleeve temperature. What motivation does Mars provide that those don't?
- ben_w 6y agoIf your goal is to be a multi-planet civilisation, neither Antarctica nor the oceans of Earth would work; also the layer of Venusian atmosphere that you’re describing is way too cold for there to be useful quantities of metals you could extract from the rain (unlike the lower layers, where mountain tops are frosted with metal: https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/deep-space/a11506/heavy-metal-rain-venus-17349212/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/deep-space/a11506/hea...). The other option is the Moon, which has even less atmosphere and even bigger temperature swings than Mars.
- ncmncm 6y agoPlanets are for extreme primitives, anyway. But the point was, if you haven't even proven you can settle a mildly challenging environment, your odds on an actually difficult one don't look good.
- ben_w 6y agoWe know by demonstrations that we can make settlements in Antarctica and underwater, we just don’t have any reason to do more than science and military. Venus, you could only settle by bringing in everything from outside unless and until you can convert the atmosphere in a large way into building materials — Mars at least you only need to convert it into fuel, because you can do at least some of your construction from rocks.