3 ms·
> If processing IPs always required consent, every website, app, and operating system would have to come with a cookie banner. Or, you know, they could just no
by mschuster91 6y ago
> If processing IPs always required consent, every website, app, and operating system would have to come with a cookie banner.
Or, you know, they could just not do data collection or limit to reasonable amounts? The way stuff used to be before ubiquitous broadband connections? As the GDPR intended?
> Instead, processing IPs falls under the "required to make things work" banner. I'm sure VSCode processes your IP address for many things such as installing extensions and updates and nobody is arguing they need consent for those.
Because installing updates is something the user wants and needs (and is recommended by international IT security standard). But telemetry is not something the user wants or needs and the software works fine without the data, therefore it should be opt-in only.
The problem: Microsoft formally has the Ireland subsidiary listed for data processing (as many US tech companies do), and the Irish DPO is notorious for being slow and lax. It will take years for courts to decide on that matter.
- esperent 6y agoWell, I honestly don't care enough about non-identifying data being collected to continue this discussion. However, if you really feel that this is illegal under the GDPR, rather than wait for lawyers to get involved (which might never happen), why not open an issue on the VSCode repo and discuss it there? Even if they dismiss it, it might help matters for lawyers at a later date - as in, they can point to the issue that was opened and say, you cannot deny being aware of this issue because you dismissed people's concerns previously.