3 ms·
> "Are you denying ..." No. It is hard to understand what you are arguing. Are you criticizing the comparison because it is not apt, or because it is? In the
by ncmncm 6y ago
> "Are you denying ..."
No.
It is hard to understand what you are arguing. Are you criticizing the comparison because it is not apt, or because it is?
In the mid-20th century, there really were communist moles in governments; just not as many as were claimed, and mostly not the ones accused. The craze to root them out mainly swept up, and blighted the lives and careers, of innocents.
There really were individuals who would supply poisons, but the overwhelming majority of those hung for witchcraft were women who owned property the Church wanted.
The people who take advantage of Q will not be rooting out actual offenders, and any of those who are in positions of authority can use Q to divert attention from themselves.
I suspect, but cannot support, that obsession with witchcraft arose only after, and largely because, the supply of heretics dried up.
- jakeogh 6y agohttps://archive.fo/tOXxh https://archive.fo/tOXxh
- core-questions 6y ago> It is hard to understand what you are arguing. Well, you appear to be drawing a false equivalence between pedos and communists (real, proven) and witches (not real, unless you believe in magic).
- ncmncm 6y agoThere is a very real equivalence in people promoting hysteria about pedos, communists, and witches, completely independently of their expressed targets' existence. Are there actual pederasts and human traffickers? Yes. Do you imagine they are the individuals the Q enthusiasts accuse? I doubt.
- core-questions 6y ago> Are there actual pederasts and human traffickers? Yes. Do you imagine they are the individuals the Q enthusiasts accuse? Who do they accuse whom you think has a really solid excuse? Some demonstration of a false or plausibly-false accusation would be nice.
- ncmncm 6y agoAs always in such cases, they will accuse anyone they don't like. Being disliked by demogogues is not probable cause.