52 ms·
I teach math in the first year of the university and it's not a good moment to discuss about the subtle details of topology and definitions. So every time someo
by gus_massa 6y ago
I teach math in the first year of the university and it's not a good moment to discuss about the subtle details of topology and definitions. So every time someone ask me that, I reply "It is not continuous for all the real numbers"
- thaumasiotes 6y agoWell, obviously it's not continuous. How is that an answer to "is it piecewise continuous?"?
- gus_massa 6y agoIt is continuous in the natural domain[1] that is (-∞,0)∪(0,+∞). The problem is that the students of the first (or second) year of the university will then try to use the the Bolzano's theorem / Intermediate value theorem to prove that it has a zero in the interval [-1, 1]. So I must answer NO, but the problem is that usually in the question the domain is implicit, so it cause a lot of confusion. I think it's more clear the definition of "piecewise differentiable". I'm not sure what is the "official" definition of "piecewise continuous". The definition in Mathworld looks a little fuzzy. I'd probably request not an horrible behavior in the borders of the intervals that are glued, like in * sign(x) -> yes * 1/x -> no * sin(1/x) -> no One of the best keep secrets in math is that the definitions are somewhat arbitrary. [1] At least it is how we call it in Argentina, sometimes the names/definitions change in each country.