7 ms·
Twitter faces FTC probe, likely fine over use of phone numbers for ads
- cracker_jacks 6y ago> Twitter estimates the "range of probable loss" it faces in the probe is between $150 million and $250 million That's close to 10% of Twitter's annual revenue. How do the likes of Google and Facebook get away with fines <1% of annual revenue? This seems disproportionate. I am not taking a position on whether it should be higher or lower, just that it appears unbalanced.
- gundmc 6y ago$150 - 250 MM is more like 4-7 % of revenue than 10% based on their 2019 figure.
- tjoff 6y agoAlso note that they did this for seven years. It is really hard to grasp how pathetic the modern web is, where this is commonplace.
- thephyber 6y agoWhat does this have to do with "the modern web"? The weakness here is both the legal system that allowed it and the regulatory system that failed to police it for years.
- kulahan 6y agoBecause the modern web is based entirely around invading the privacy of every user as much as possible in order to sell their private details to advertisers. If Twitter's money came from users in the form of subscriptions or purchases, rather than from advertisers in the form of paid, targeted ads, this would be guarded information, rather than shared.
- mrosett 6y agoPart of the difference is that Twitter has much lower revenue per user than the other two. If you frame the fine as "$X per user impacted" rather than as "y% of your revenue" then it seems more proportional.
- grecy 6y ago> How do the likes of Google and Facebook get away with fines <1% of annual revenue? This seems disproportionate Google and Facebook spend more on lobbying.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoHard to say without getting into specifics. Which specific thing has FB/Google done that deserves a 5% of revenue fine?
- jeremynixon 6y agoThis is a deep violation that makes every user of 2fa _unsafe_. A mere $250 million? This needs to be the kind of violation that endangers the company. It's not a mistake or honest error when 2fa phone numbers are used for advertising. This is malicious. Should be scaled to 100X the amount the company gained in advertising for the violation.
- noscrewstoyous 6y agoYou shouldn’t use a phone number for 2fa to begin with, you’d be better off without 2fa if that’s the only option IMO (assuming you’re using a strong unique password). This is just more fuel on that fire.
- diabeetusman 6y ago2FA with SMS protects against password reuse or leaks. It's my understanding that SMS is weak against attacks targeted at particular people while being sufficiently strong for the majority of cases.
- thephyber 6y agoSS7 attacks scale better. SIM cloning is a lot of effort just to compromise a single SMS number. In general, SMS is better than no 2FA, but it's weaker than OTP/OTH or a token like YubiKey or Titan.
- moscovium 6y agoRemember when Jack Dorsey had his SIM attacked for the 2fa?
- t-writescode 6y agoWouldn’t a phone-based 2FA also give you the knowledge that someone’s trying to log in? Can the SMS message somehow not be sent to all users on the network with your phone number?
- geofft 6y ago
- RandomBacon 6y agoGood. Didn't Facebook do the same thing? I don't remember if they were fined or not.
- tyre 6y agoThey did and were fined $5bn for privacy violations generally, of which one part was: > In addition to these violations of its 2012 order, the FTC alleges that Facebook violated the FTC Act’s prohibition against deceptive practices when it told users it would collect their phone numbers to enable a security feature, but did not disclose that it also used those numbers for advertising purposes. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2019/07/ftc-imposes-5-billion-penalty-sweeping-new-privacy-restrictions https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2019/07/ftc-i...
- mercora 6y agois there any benefit in using the phone network for 2FA besides (IMHO too) easy recovery in case of loss? Is there an equivalently usable method for recovery? recovery codes aren't practicall i guess because people would keep loosing them too. Maybe some pseudonymous proof using cryptographic functions of modern passports could be used somehow without revealing real identity to the passport issuer too? It should not be possible to know who issued the pseudonymous identity proof but should also only be proof-able by me...
- gruez 6y agoYou can outsource it to something like authy, which is still sms based, but gets disabled if you install their app. They also claim that they can detect number porting attacks, so that might be marginally better. >Maybe some pseudonymous proof using cryptographic functions of modern passports could be used somehow without revealing real identity to the passport issuer too? You can still lose your passport. It's less likely than losing your phone, but still. Also, to access the cryptographic functions of a passport, you probably need a NFC reader, which isn't exactly accessible.
- mercora 6y ago>You can still lose your passport. It's less likely than losing your phone, but still. Also, to access the cryptographic functions of a passport, you probably need a NFC reader, which isn't exactly accessible. i thought maybe the pseudonymous identity proof could still work after your passport has been reissued either because of loss or because of invalidation. But its probably not really doable with named constraints. Modern phones are apparently often equipped with an NFC reader. I think this could be usable enough for the recovery case.
- segmondy 6y agoDespite all that, their ads are straight up garbage. Either that or I'm very hard to target. I swear Twitter and Facebook must display random ads to me. I'm often having to mark it as never show this again because it's so way off from my interests.
- yelloworangefog 6y agoI leave my Adblock off for youtube a fair bit of the time. Not for any sense of ethical responsibility to help content creators, but because of how entertaining I find their failed attempts to target me. The ads are so bad, they’re oftentimes literal scams. I go out of my way to engage with the bad ads so I’ll get more like them. Luckily screwing with the ad algorithm doesn’t seem to have too great an effect on the video recommendation algorithm.
- anitil 6y agoMaybe this is just me being thick, but I still don't have a clear idea of what they actually did. Did they send spam SMS? Or were they using the numbers as another data point for analytics?
- Jordrok 6y agoI've always hated giving my phone number to sites, even when it's ostensibly only for recovery purposes. Even worse are the sites/apps which refuse to let you make an account without one. I remember Facebook getting busted for the same thing so this just goes to further confirm my suspicion that this type of practice is more widespread than most companies would like to acknowledge.
- justjonathan 6y agoYou could not create a new Twitter account with out a phone number last week. (Attempting from US). It rejected my disposal number as invalid too. :(
- nabaraz 6y agoCurios on how you are creating disposal number? I need one. I know there is Google Voice, but it I don't want my disposal number to be linked with my real phone number.
- Nextgrid 6y agoFrom the past several years they've been constantly suspending brand new accounts for "security" reasons and requiring a phone number to unlock them, even if the account wasn't doing anything that looks spammy or suspicious. When opening a support ticket about it, they claim it was a "mistake and" offer to unlock the account but I always suspected it was a disgusting tactic for harvesting phone numbers and I guess I was right.
- yelloworangefog 6y agoThe fine (and others like it) is a meaningless gesture. Unless companies like twitter start getting fined in amounts that aren’t pocket change to them, there is literally no incentive to change their abusive behavior. They make enough from abusing their users and absconding with their data to pay these paltry fines a hundred times over in most cases.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoThe government went suddenly active... TikTok for Tulsa Twitter for warning labels Or did the investigation begin before those events?
- Khaine 6y agoTwitter delenda est