7 ms·
> Somehow along the way the cable/TV companies introduced latency in the channel changes and people just accepted it as the new normal. The technical reason is
by formerly_proven 6y ago
> Somehow along the way the cable/TV companies introduced latency in the channel changes and people just accepted it as the new normal.
The technical reason is that digital TV is a heavily compressed signal [1] (used to be MPEG2, perhaps they have moved on to h.264) with a GOP (group of pictures) length that is usually around 0.5-2 seconds. When you switch channels, the MPEG-2 decoder in your receiver needs to wait until a new GOP starts, because there is no meaningful way to decode a GOP that's "in progress".
[1] And the technical reason for the compression is that analog HD needs a lot more bandwidth than analog NTSC/PAL/SECAM, while raw HD transmission would need an absurd amount of bandwidth per channel (about a gigabit/s for 1080p30). So HD television pretty much requires the use of digital compression. Efficient digital video compression requires GOP structures.
- zozbot234 6y agoMost video players can decode an "in progress" stream just fine. This obviously involves quite a few artifacts for the first 0.5–2 seconds or so, but seeing artifacts is generally preferable to seeing a totally blank screen.
- formerly_proven 6y agoTrue, and the decoders in receivers already have this capability, since they keep decoding even if the forward-error-correction can't save the stream any more, resulting in similar artifacts. I'm not sure why it's not done on a channel change, perhaps it's the manufacturers not wanting their TVs to routinely show glitched footage, or perhaps advertisers don't want it because it would be against Corporate Design rules to glitch-effect the logos they use on the daily.
- frandroid 6y agoIt's obvious that TV makers have decided that seeing artifacts is not preferable. I wish that was toggleable.
- ipnon 6y agoImplicitly TV users are also prohibited from making their own technical decisions. I claim this is because the TV predates the era of open computing platforms like Unix.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I claim this is because the TV predates the era of open computing platforms like Unix. I claim it's because DRM, since if it wasn't for DRM wanting control of the whole reception to display path to be protected, you could just stick an open computing device in between the streaming signal and the display device, and make your own technical choices. You still can, AFAIK, for content that doesn't require HDCP.
- grawprog 6y agoI remember having a TV tuner card back in the day on my old desktop and this is exactly what I did. I don't watch much TV or anything so.I haven't really checked, but are such cards available today with the encrypted digital cable that's ubiquitous everywhere? Even most broadcast is digital now and requires a decoder box between.
- jfrunyon 6y agoOTA: Yes. Cable: no, you'd need a CableCard, and approved device (i.e. DVR), etc.
- majormajor 6y agoI don't think it has anything to do with Unix or DRM or any of that. It's because we have a trendy now-decades-long wave of product managers and designers who assume their job is to know better than the user. Open source software is not immune.
- jfrunyon 6y agocough Ubuntu cough cough systemd cough
- catalogia 6y agoThere is also the matter of modern screens needing 5-30 seconds to "boot" when old TVs and monitors turned on in less than a second.
- formerly_proven 6y agoCRTs did tend to take a couple seconds to properly warm up, charge up and reach final image size (the image is directly scaled by the acceleration voltage, which is a high impedance source charging a not-so-small capacitor formed by the aquadag on the inside and outside of the picture tube).
- catalogia 6y agoCRTs did need a moment to stabilize the image, but they showed signs of life virtually instantly. At the least they'd make a little noise and had buttons with tactile feedback so you knew something was happening. Many screens today have capacitive touch buttons and have 5 seconds or more between a button 'press' and anything happening at all, leaving you to wonder if you even managed to successfully press the power button in the first place.
- SilasX 6y agoYes! I remember movies and TV shows would have scenes where a character is called and told to turn on the TV for breaking news. They'd see it the story instantly, and that was actually realistic! (Assuming it was big enough news to be on all channels.) Today if you had such a scene they'd be like, "okay <presses remote, waits five very immersion-breaking seconds>".
- formerly_proven 6y ago> Today if you had such a scene they'd be like, "okay <presses remote, waits five very immersion-breaking seconds>". But they still have these scenes in movies The way these scenes work now is "picks up phone - check the news!", they grab the remote, and turn the volume up on one of the many already running and tuned in wall-mounted 24/7 on TVs ... :)
- gruez 6y agoAre we talking about seeking in media players, or streaming websites? If I watch a random twitch stream I just see a loading throbber, while it loads, not a artifacted version.
- Trias11 6y agoI won't be surprised if TV manufacturers further screw customers by forcing them to watch ads in between switching channels.
- magicalhippo 6y agoOur cable box has three decoders. My gf can watch one channel and record two others at the same time. Yet does it use any of those extra decoders when not recording to proactively decode the previous and next channel, or something smart like that? No, of course not...
- jlokier 6y agoRecording doesn't use a full decoder. The incoming channel data stream is saved as-is. It will need a demultiplexer to separate out one channel from the multi-channel data stream, but it won't need to decode that stream, which is the intensive bit. Decoding happens when you play it back later.
- magicalhippo 6y agoAh, I did check out the specs again and it does indeed say it has a bunch of tuners, not decoders. Mental slip then. Thanks for the correction, very interesting.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y ago> proactively decode the previous and next channel Do you find yourself actually moving up and down the channels, and not through the guide to somewhere else entirely different than where you once where? My first move if I'm switching channels is to go to the guide, not to a channel one above or below my current channel. I suppose it could run on the previous channel, but it certainly can't guess my next channel.
- monocasa 6y agoThe first startup I worked with was an IPTV startup that would send the I-Frames for the channels on either side of the channel you were watching at the higher bandwidth tiers so you could channel flip instantly like the old days. Toxic culture and relationships so the startup imploded, but there was some cool tech.
- rsynnott 6y agoI'm not sure if this is the whole story. Watching DVB terrestrial TV on my television, channel changing is definitely slower than a good analog TV, but it's much faster than any satellite/cable box I've ever used. And there's a lot of variance between cable boxes. I strongly suspect some of them are doing something silly.
- cameldrv 6y agoRight, but there's a social/business reason why this is true. There are various things that could be done technically to fix this, for example, you could have three decoders running simultaneously so you always had the adjacent channels buffered, you could send keyframes more often, or you could even use a totally different compression scheme that didn't use keyframes. The real reason problems like this aren't solved is that the organization does not allocate resources to fix them. The status quo has been deemed to be good enough and not leading to the loss of too many customers to the competition, so that's where it stands. This pervades all engineering -- everything just barely works, because once it barely works, for most things, it's good enough, and no more resources are deployed to make it better.
- philwelch 6y agoRealistically, it’s because it was considered an acceptable tradeoff for replacing 480i analog video with 1080p digital video.
- jfrunyon 6y agoBy who? Many people wouldn't even be able to reliably tell the difference with common dpi's and viewing distances.
- andrewstuart2 6y agoBetween 1080p and 480i? Have you never watched old video/shows on an HDTV? The difference is stark.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoAll the time, and unless the images are next to each other you don't really notice unless you're looking for it. Not because there isn't a big difference, but because you just don't really care that much unless it is called to your attention.
- 6y ago
- unfocused 6y agoOTA TV (Rabbit Ears picking up Digital TV - c.f. older analog NTSC), at least here in Canada, is still using MPEG2. The stream is typically around 20 Mbps, including the audio, which is Dolby Digital 5.1 (except certain channels, such as TVO (TV Ontario), which is DD 2.0). It's all based on ATSC. While there is an ATSC 2.0, they skipped that in Canada, there will be ATSC 3.0, which will use HEVC (H265) for 4K. But don't hold your breath on that...the TV stations aren't exactly opening their wallets to upgrade anything!
- dfox 6y agoAnother reason for the lag is that the modulation scheme is complex and requires considerable time to both acquire the actual demodulator lock (in fact, the symbol in typical terrestrial DTV system is surprisingly long) as well to acquire synchronization of the higher level FEC layers.
- c3534l 6y agoI don't buy this. We had an old cable box that had instantaneous channel-switching. The cable company made us switch to a brand new one. Same signal coming in, but the new one was infinitely slower. It wasn't some change in the signal that made things slow, it was the software and the complete lack of care for performance.
- LanceH 6y agoThe old cable boxes were literally switches, with all channels flowing into the box all the time. Now switching is virtual and done on the server (plus all the software encoding/decoding). Right now I would be satifsied with at least some caching of the menus, so it doesn't have to pull the data every damn time I scroll up or down. Come on, it should be able to remember what channels I have for more than 5 minutes in a row.
- naikrovek 6y agoIt probably does cache the data, and it just takes ages to draw. Manufacturers really cheap out on settop box CPU and RAM specifications in order to make the pricing attractive to cable companies.
- RulerOf 6y ago...but then it costs you a thousand dollars if you lose or damage the set top box.
- naikrovek 6y agoYes and they still have insurance to cover the loss, anyway. You didn't think a cable company was going to deal with it's customers fairly, did you? Every time you interact with a customer, there is an opportunity for profit. Telecommunications companies, cable TV included, are masters at this type of behavior.
- naikrovek 6y agoYou not "buying" it doesn't make it untrue. You get the cable box for the new system BEFORE they switch the old system off, or else you wouldn't have service until you got a new box. That's why you saw behavior change with the new box. It simply isn't possible to send all the channels to customers at all times. There isn't enough bandwidth. So, the cable box at your house negotiates with the central or regional system so only a subset of channels are sent to you. There is no other way to do it in digital cable systems, and the switch to digital was made because it uses significantly less bandwidth than analog.
- ebg13 6y ago> The technical reason is that digital TV is a heavily compressed signal [1] (used to be MPEG2, perhaps they have moved on to h.264) with a GOP (group of pictures) length that is usually around 0.5-2 seconds. Just because they transmit keyframes and deltas in the steady state doesn't mean they need to wait for the next keyframe when starting the stream. They could also choose to send you the current reconstructed frame as a keyframe immediately instead of waiting several seconds for the next pre-made one. The cost to them would be epsilon (one new stream client per channel to be the source of reconstructed keyframes), and the customer experience difference would be noteworthy.
- anticensor 6y agoThat will only work if the original is in lossless.
- ebg13 6y agoNo. It will work regardless. I'm talking about having a single additional client decompress the broadcast and act as a first-frame keyframe source based on the decompressed stream. In a traditional compressed stream, a reconstructed frame is already the context for the next delta after the first. Sending a frame reconstructed by someone else allows you to immediately begin using deltas, and it's a close enough approximation of the original uncompressed frame that the immediate result will be quite good even if not perfect, especially compared to waiting. At worst it would only be as bad as a transcoded stream for the first few seconds until the subsequent true keyframe arrives. That's loads better than no stream at all.
- giantrobot 6y agoThere's additional issues with changing channels than just GOP sizes. For cable TV signals are still channelized into 6MHz channels. QAM modulation is used which gets about 40Mbps per 6MHz channel. An MPEG transport stream is sent over that 40Mbps "channel". Inside of that transport stream are several elementary streams, each carrying either video, audio, or data/program information. A TV station will be carried by a combination of a video (MPEG-2/4) and audio stream. These streams are packetized such that a receiver won't get buffer underruns or overruns. The transport stream is further packetized. Adjacent station broadcasts aren't always carried on the same transport stream. So when you hit the button to "change channels" the cable box may need to tune to a new radio channel, wait for transport stream packets for the station, and then buffer enough data to start playback. The GOP size then plays a part because the decoder needs an I-frame to do anything useful with the P-frames inside the GOP. Cable providers use longer GOPs to get better quality at a given bitrate, I-frames are much larger than P-frames so the more you send the higher the bitrate you need. Sending I-frames for other broadcasts in the same transport stream would be a waste of bandwidth. The data used for these rarely used extra I-frames takes away from bandwidth programming in the stream could use. There's also still the lag from tuning a new channel and waiting for those I-frames to show up. So you've wasted bandwidth for a very slight increase in responsiveness.
- jedberg 6y agoAnd yet using puffer[0] I get instant channel switches at 1080. There is no technical reason you can't have instant channel switches, it's just that they aren't making the right technical decisions to allow it and/or don't want to pay for it. [0] https://puffer.stanford.edu https://puffer.stanford.edu