4 ms·
Asking students what they think they need to learn? Problem is, they don't know - so they answer with whatever is the niftyest gizmo they adhere to. The real a
by ctdonath 16y ago
Asking students what they think they need to learn? Problem is, they don't know - so they answer with whatever is the niftyest gizmo they adhere to.
The real answer is: they need to learn to DO THE WORK with whatever tools they have. I teach introductory programming, and the biggest problem students have is lack of inclination to simply perform and submit assignments (about 1/3rd suffer this affliction); it is not for lack of understanding, but for lack of action. Getting wound up in arguments about the suitability of various technologies completely misses the problem: if a student is unwilling to absorb the material as given, and to perform assignments on whatever medium is available, they will not learn.
An old copy of Knuth's "Art of Computer Programming" and a willing student will make a far more talented engineer than giving a disinterested student an iPad with anywhere/anytime access to the totality of human knowledge (including Angry Birds).
- guptaneil 16y ago> An old copy of Knuth's "Art of Computer Programming" and a willing student will make a far more talented engineer than giving a disinterested student an iPad with anywhere/anytime access to the totality of human knowledge (including Angry Birds). Likewise, a willing student with an iPad is going to have the potential to learn so much more than a disinterested student with a textbook. If a student is disinterested and completely lacks motivation, it won't matter if you use a tablet or a textbook, that student is probably not going to learn much. However, a willing and interested student can learn so much more with newer, more powerful tools. Does it really make sense to hold the willing student back because of the disinterested student? As far as motivating the lazy student goes, you are far more likely to spark their interest with real-world applications on a tablet or smartphone than with a boring old textbook.
- onan_barbarian 16y ago"However, a willing and interested student can learn so much more with newer, more powerful tools." This is complete bullshit. To stay within the grand-parent post's framework (although Knuth is perhaps a reach), you would reach a fixed point where adding nifty tech isn't going to make your experience studying Knuth that much more productive. It would be nice to have a decent laptop capable of running a compiler and whatever IDE or not-so-integrated environment you prefer; a well configured device from the last 5 years would be fine. An iPad isn't going to solve any problems here. Lazy students are lazy because they don't want to think hard, solve problems and learn. This is largely a constant and is not going to be affected by being given a iPad. To quote Jack Vance (why not?): "Whatever you have heard about me, dismiss it. I do not regard my class as a confrontation between the clear light of my intellect and twenty-two examples of sloth and willful stupidity. The exact number may be only half that, if we are lucky, and of course varies from term to term."
- guptaneil 16y agoBased on your logic, calculators shouldn't have ever been introduced in the classroom either because an abacus filled our needs. Or perhaps 128k of memory really was enough, since what possible use could we have for more memory or advanced technology if the status quo fills our current needs? We are just beginning to untap the possibilities of mobile devices in the classroom, and to completely dismiss them as "nifty tech" is very short sighted. People tried to do the same ten years ago when laptops started appearing in classrooms. Had they succeeded, companies like Google would not even exist today. We are seeing many interesting uses of mobile devices in education now that the devices are finally appearing in classrooms. However, until they become more ubiquitous and accepted, it will be impossible to fully demonstrate how much they can impact education. Having spoken to professors who have personally experimented with iPads in classrooms, I can tell you it makes a day and night difference just in student engagement when they are given a textbook to study from versus being encouraged to explore a topic and discuss it using mobile devices like the iPad. I've observed biology classes where roughly half of the students used an iPad. These students consistently participated more than the other students. There are several reasons for this behavioral change, but I think the most important one is the design of the device and OS. It focuses on the single task at hand. When an app becomes the whole device and actually discourages multitasking, students pay attention more compared to their distracting laptop screens. Compared to laptop users, they also benefitted from a lack of a physical barrier from the laptop screen between the student and instructor. Those students that had no electronic device and just depended on the textbook generally participated the least and seemed least interested. It will be interesting to see how these devices continue to change how classrooms operate as more and more schools open up to the idea. Keep in mind that the target audience is not tech savvy nerds, but the typical student, who for the most part is still afraid of using traditional laptops. These students, however, live off of their cell phones, so why not take advantage of an environment they are already comfortable in to encourage learning instead of forcing them into a foreign environment?
- WalterBright 16y agoBack in the olden daze, I was taught in college with nothing more than a prof and a blackboard, and I took notes. It works fine. I learned a helluva lot in a very short time. The thing is, it takes work to learn something. You have to make an effort. Labor saving machinery doesn't help any more than using a motorcycle to train for a marathon. As they say in athletics, no pain = no gain.
- quacker 16y ago"Asking students what they think they need to learn? Problem is, they don't know..." This is typical of a teacher giving his or her students too little credit. While this may be true of elementary- and perhaps middle-schoolers, I'd say most high school students know what helps them learn. I knew what kinds of books, teachers, writing utensils, memorization techniques and the like that I preferred, and the same was true of just about everyone around me. Similarly, I also knew what failed to help me. There was a girl in one of my classes who always quietly hummed behind me some jingle she had created to help her remember something for that test, but I never liked using songs to memorize important facts. I did something kind of like the memory palace technique (but I didn't know it had a name at the time). There were also plenty of assignments the teachers gave and tools/methods they tried to use that they thought - not without reason - would work. But they often confused me much more than taught me anything. "it is not for lack of understanding, but for lack of action" I agree with this. A huge mistake of many of my teachers is that they assumed some students were dumb or lazy and missed the fact that students simply don't care about some (or all) of the classes they have to take, and teachers that focused on getting students interested in the material were generally more successful than the ones who complained about kids' poor attitudes (not that a bad attitude isn't an issue, and not that it's all on the teacher to do something about it). But then came the "action" part - get kids to do something "right." I hated teachers that tried to force their study habits on me. Many teachers would check and grade our notes to see that we were taking them "properly." Others might make us go step-by-step through some writing process that is "guaranteed to make you a successful writer." While good note-taking and writing skills should definitely be taught at some point, the level of detail enforced was absurd, and single methods cannot work for every student. I know teachers have hard jobs, and I don't claim to know everything. The point is just to give the students some credit. They aren't stupid, and they're all different. If you listen to them, they'll like you better for it. If you don't listen to them, you will never seriously consider some little idea they say that might work wonders for them. But don't get me wrong about the article. This survey says nothing about a correlation between access to technology and success in school/life, and I really doubt smartphones and iPads will help students more than distract them. However, there is merit taking their opinions into account. And there is merit in using the available resources to their full advantage. Considering that mobile devices will become ever more prevalent and powerful in the future, it's a good idea to begin determining their potential in the classroom.