3 ms·
> I don't understand this objection at all. They feel policing plagiarism turns them into a parking warden or a cop, when they want to be more like a coach, ol
by michaelt 6y ago
> I don't understand this objection at all.
They feel policing plagiarism turns them into a parking warden or a cop, when they want to be more like a coach, older student or parent.
I assume that's important, if you're hoping to have productive exploratory discussions in class, rather than the classic take-notes-in-silence type lecture.
- darawk 6y agoIf you aren't going to police plagiarism why are you assigning essays at all though?
- tokai 6y agoTo facilitate learning ofc. Not using software to check for plagiarism, isn't going to invalidate the use of essay work in learning.
- darawk 6y agoMy point is that using software is just a consequence of the desire to check for plagiarism. Your options are: 1. Check for plagiarism poorly by hand. 2. Check for plagiarism thoroughly with software 3. Don't check for plagiarism at all. Option 1 I don't understand at all, and option 3 seems to negate the purpose of assigning essays.
- notduncansmith 6y ago“Police” being the verb in this situation is exactly the problem, just like with actual crime. Like another comment mentioned, this calls more for coaching or mentorship than rule-enforcement and punishment. Aside: I think we should stop using the word “police” for things that are not law-enforcers/punishers.
- darawk 6y agoBut that is completely orthogonal to the issue of detection. In order to coach/mentor correctly, you need to know what it is your students are doing. It's still up to the teacher how they respond to plagiarism. But if you don't even know your students are plagiarizing, you're hardly in a position to coach them.
- bitwize 6y ago> They feel policing plagiarism turns them into a parking warden or a cop, when they want to be more like a coach, older student or parent. This is new, then. When I was in college, plagiarism was treated as serious academic malpractice, practically on the level of a crime. The gravity of the offense, as well as the ease with which it can be committed, was emphasized. If you quote even a few words from a source without proper attribution (typically as dictated by the MLA), you are plagiarizing. This was drilled into our heads.