3 ms·
I don’t see any reason to think that all engineers contribute the same amount of value (and therefore paying different amounts is entirely reasonable). Thought
by sokoloff 6y ago
I don’t see any reason to think that all engineers contribute the same amount of value (and therefore paying different amounts is entirely reasonable).
Thought experiment: if you were going to form a startup and needed two other engineers, would you know across your history which ones to pick from and which ones to avoid?
- satyrnein 6y agoI wholeheartedly agree with your first sentence. However, the thought experiment feels vulnerable to bias and other factors unrelated to performance, (just like the salary negotiation process you're comparing it to).
- ithkuil 6y agoThe thought experiment indeed highlights the same dynamics: it's not about whether there are effective differences in quality in people (and thus different "valuations"), but whether the noise in the system is larger than the signal.
- baddox 6y agoPerhaps I would be more comfortable hiring engineers I was friends with, or even worse, engineers with similar experiences and backgrounds to me. But hopefully I would deliberately try to recognize and adjust for those tendencies, and I certainly hope I wouldn’t choose who to hire based on how good the engineer was at negotiating.
- danShumway 6y ago> and therefore paying different amounts is entirely reasonable Then the engineers sharing their salaries with each other should also be reasonable. If anyone complains about the discrepancy, you can point out that the engineers being paid more are more talented. Extending off of your thought experiment. If you were going to form a startup, and you believed that pay discrepancies corresponded to value, wouldn't you want interviewees to be extremely open about their previous salaries and their salary comparisons within previous companies? That would make it even easier for you to find the engineers who were the most talented. We already ask interviewees where they've worked -- would you feel comfortable asking them "how much money did you make in comparison to your coworkers?" --- My feeling here is that companies want to hide salaries for the same reason my car mechanic would prefer me not to discuss my bill with any other customers. In an open market, discrepancies in knowledge about market rates favor the people with more knowledge; in this case, the companies. Companies are smart, not stupid; they understand how the market works. They're hiding salaries because that gives them an advantage when trying to drive down the price of engineers. Whether or not pay discrepancies can be justified is kind of a false conflict. Regardless of whether or not pay discrepancies are a good idea -- in a free market, the prices should be transparent so that companies are forced to compete on honest terms for employees. A generally applicable question that I've found applies to a number of situations beyond just this one: if a thing is good, then why do we need to hide it or force people to accept it?
- sokoloff 6y agoIt is perfectly reasonable for coworkers to be discussing their salaries. I agree that money topics in general should be less taboo than they are currently. If I found out I made less than someone else, I’d first see if I agreed with that call and, if not, use that signal to figure out what change I should make (in performance/level of effort, in communication/publicity, or in company).