3 ms·
Screen distance from the user greatly impacts the usability. I would also add that if you have HN (or Reddit) open on one of those monitors, you probably aren't
by malandrew 16y ago
Screen distance from the user greatly impacts the usability. I would also add that if you have HN (or Reddit) open on one of those monitors, you probably aren't going to be more productive.
For the benefits of those on HN, here is my answer to the question on Skeptics-StackExchange:
==
Having championed the purchase of five 30" for the equity research officers at Itaú Securities, I have some anecodotal evidence to share, which pretty much invalidates any study regarding 30" monitors.
Here's the deal:
A 30" monitor is pretty large and its distance from the user GREATLY impacts its usability. For a 30" monitor to be usable it needs to be placed on the desktop at about an armslength to be comfortable and productive. For many desks, this distance is an impossibility, especially corner desks where the monitor is catacornered.
Most people when they use an external screen place it just behind the keyboard. This does not work with a 30" monitor, as it is too close and you end up shifting your head up and down and laterally far too much.
This effect is significant enough to invalidate pretty much any study that doesn't take this into account and control it.
At Itaú Securities all five 30" monitors were first used on corner desks with the monitor catacornered. The major factor which determined if it was useable was each analysts body posture when seating at their desk. Those analysts which sat slouched in their chair and leaning back when they were modifying their financial models in Excel, loved the monitor and said that others would be allowed to use it when you pry it from their cold dead fingers. Those with good posture ended up sitting far too close to the screen and since the monitor was catacornered, they were unable to adjust the distance to be comfortable. None realized that monitor distance were the reason for their discomfort. All that sat with good posture abandoned the 30" monitor and return to their crappy 19" monitors. It was only when one of the monitors was relocated to a non-corner desk and placed at the very back of the desk when we realized the impact of monitor distance and comfort.
Anyways, I've never seen this particular issue with larger monitors discussed anywhere with regards so I figured I'd share it here. I'm sure this issue is equally applicable to multi-monitor setups.
- malandrew 16y agoI wish I could go back and add this to my YCombinator app (without it being marked as late) as "something I have discovered" as it's fairly original semi-scientific research and more interesting than the answer I originally put.