3 ms·

So you have two problems: users need to be able to figure out what are good comments to read, and correspondingly you want users to vote on comments that make g

So you have two problems: users need to be able to figure out what are good comments to read, and correspondingly you want users to vote on comments that make good reading. Have you thought at all about discerning between vote value based on some metric? You'd need something that doesn't disproportionately disadvantage new users.

gnosis 16y ago
Elsewhere in this thread I proposed a scheme that meets both of your requirements: it discerns votes based on a metric (how closely the voters vote to your own preferences), and it doesn't disadvantage new users: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2405266 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2405266