3 ms·
I'm asking for concrete evidence that his opinions have predictive power which has been assessed independently. If no such evidence exists then all we have is
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
I'm asking for concrete evidence that his opinions have predictive power which has been assessed independently.
If no such evidence exists then all we have is just-so story-telling, which can be discounted.
The fact that a lot of people seem to believe his ideas are convincing is irrelevant to this discussion.
People believe all kinds of things because they sound plausible to them - partly because other people have made careers out of working out how to push people's "This sounds plausible so I shall believe it" buttons.
Which is why reproducible evidence and independent peer review are things. And why it's absolutely reasonable - in fact required - to question assertions that can't be grounded in them.