6 ms·
TL;DR it's a radio in your pocket that constantly announces its identity. I'm quite interested in the fact that people don't realize this. Is it a generational
by jeffbee 6y ago
TL;DR it's a radio in your pocket that constantly announces its identity. I'm quite interested in the fact that people don't realize this. Is it a generational split between people who can remember when we did not all have radios in our pockets and those who can't, or ??? The fact that an always-on radio you carry everywhere can be used to track you seems like the #1 most obvious thing about the technology.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjulius 6y agoYou can't expect end users with little-to-no technical know-how to have the same common knowledge that you do.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI watched a doco last night where researchers put a sounding beacon inside a shark. Inside it! They said something like "these sharks are used to cuts and scrapes and heal quickly." It's no wonder people don't immediately associate their phone with a locating beacon.
- pvaldes 6y agoMaybe I'm not translating correctly "sounding beacon", but I would assume that what you see was just an (I don't know the exact term) "electronic tag". This is standard procedure in ecology, veterinary and animal husbandry. We did it sometimes. Is a rice grain size object, and does not left any noticeable scar in fishes.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoAll good, I don’t have any issue with attaching or implanting tracking devices for research purposes in what looks like a wholly harmless way. From what they were saying, it emitted a ping every ten minutes, wasn’t entirely clear if it was acoustic or radio. Shark didn’t seem to mind.
- jeffbee 6y agoWell, why not? How can we improve general technological literacy? I don't want people to memorize the protocols, but I do want them to have the foundation of knowledge that would allow them to conclude that if the phone company can connect calls to your mobile handset, then they can also figure out roughly where it is. I'd also like for people to have the basic knowledge required to understand that GPS does not track you. It's the other way around. I'd like everyone to understand that mass and energy are conserved, the Earth orbits the Sun, etc.
- aylee 6y agoAbstracting away all of the details underlying the tech is a double edged sword. On one side, you get massively higher adoption due to a lower barrier to entry. On the other, you now have a massive population of folks who don’t understand the the “fundamentals”. I’m not sure we “need” to improve the general understanding. I mean how many ppl know how to change their own car tires or oil? If anything you just keep creating niches for ppl to make livings in.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago"Why does anyone need to know" is a restrictive premise. In my experience, what follows it are less rights, less ability, greater compliance & increased malleability (eg: susceptibility to "election meddling").
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoThe median IQ is 100, meaning half of all people have IQs below 100. Many of them did not grow up in an environment that pushes lifelong learning. Lots of people do what they've been trained to do and nothing more, which is good! Our society needs people like that. But expecting people like that to think for themselves is a sure way to become needlessly frustrated. edit: switched average to median.
- steffan 6y agoThe measure that describes what you state would be the median, which is defined as the point at which there are as many values above as below. Averages will skew with large outliers on either side. E.g. if Bezos and I are alone in a room together, the average person in that room has $95B dollars. (Granted, in an n=2 situation, the median isn't meaningful either)
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoThis seems like a common tv and movie plot point though. If you don’t want to be found you have to destroy or lose your phone.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoMost folks generally understand how radio works.
- rrose 6y agoI feel like you're ignoring a key point here, which is that these stingray devices can MitM your phone by forcing it to send essentially unencrypted messages. That's both more technically complicated and more serious than passive tracking.
- bob1029 6y agoI don't think OP is ignoring any points. It is a statement of fact that we've been carrying around what ultimately amount to high power RFID surveillance devices in our pockets for about 20-30 years now (en masse). There are also many on this board at this very moment who can remember life before any of this technology or concern was a thing. In 1990, if you walked to the store without telling anyone where you were going, you were basically a ghost as far as anyone else was concerned. In 2020, even if you leave all of your digital electronics at home, you will probably be detected by someone else's electronics.
- rrose 6y agoOP is sort of shrugging off the information in this article by saying that it should be common sense that by carrying a phone you are trackable. I don't really disagree with that. But a major point of the article is that not only are you trackable, but you can be actively surveilled or even have your text messages spoofed, which is not common knowledge and isn't really encapsulated by the "radio in your pocket" analogy
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> these stingray devices can MitM your phone by forcing it to send essentially unencrypted messages. Earlier Harris equip did that by forcing 2g mode but 2g is being turned off: https://1ot.mobi/resources/blog/a-complete-overview-of-2g-3g-sunsets https://1ot.mobi/resources/blog/a-complete-overview-of-2g-3g... I'm less familiar with the capabilities of current IMEI catchers tho.
- bigiain 6y ago> Earlier Harris equip did that by forcing 2g mode but 2g is being turned off Even if the carriers switch off all their 2G towers (which happened here in .au years back), I wonder how many handsets will still happily connect to a Stingray-type device that offers it a 2G connection?
- op03 6y agoDo the math. The odds of someone targeting you (just for kicks) aren't that high. But don't tell Glenn Greenwald that cause then he has to go find something else to scare you with, to capture your attention in our current useless "state of fear" preserving info tsunami ecosystem. But anyway lets do the math... The US has 200 cops per million. Lets say 1% of that million are born douchebags and there is another 1% who have turned douchebagy for whatever reason. So you have 200 cops to deal with 20000 bad guys per million. So in general they have enough going on keeping them occupied. Now even if you assume they don't spend any time doing their job and all of them spend all their time fixating on you and no one else, the chances of them picking on you out of the million other options are still pretty low. What makes it even lower is if you apply the 2% douchebag rule to the cops themselves, you get probably 2 bad apples in that 200. But to indulge you lets apply it also to anyone who has access to the same privacy violating tech - bank managers, google engineers, telco engineers, the military, rich ppl etc. Keep adding whatever category you feel like and applying the 2% rule. You wont raise the odds too badly.
- tspike 6y agoYour comment comes off pretty condescending and dismissive, which clouds a valid point. It's not likely you will be individually targeted by law enforcement. The scarier proposition to me is bulk collection and latent analysis.
- 8note 6y agoI think you can change that to "if you are not politically active, you are unlikely to be targetted" On the other hand, if you are known to criticise police actions, it's likely that they will be targetting you. The BLM leaders probably haven't connected to a real cellphone tower in years
- vanusa 6y agoIt doesn't have to target you directly in order to have a significant negative impact on your life.