3 ms·
(This is already getting tiring, so forgive me for the flippant answer) I don't want to associate with Richard Stallman (even before his stupid comments regard
by rglullis 6y ago
(This is already getting tiring, so forgive me for the flippant answer)
I don't want to associate with Richard Stallman (even before his stupid comments regarding pedophilia), yet I use Emacs every single day of my life. If you tell me that Emacs itself only came to existence due to any of Stallman's ridiculous statements or if you tell me that my usage of Emacs enables Stallman in any way to be the asswipe that he is, then I would seriously consider dropping it.
- throwanem 6y agoI also use Emacs, and I also harbor a profound distaste for Stallman's opinions on pretty much everything, some of which disagreement he and I have hashed out loudly in public before now. But I'm not uncomfortable with using, or unwilling to use, Emacs in the way that I would be Pleroma with the Soapbox frontend. I think that's because Stallman's views don't have the same import that Alex Gleason's do. Stallman's apologia for pedophilia, for example, which you cite, is abhorrent - but it's not something that anyone takes seriously. Stallman's views on people who use platforms like Facebook or tools like Photoshop, namely that they deserve whatever abuse they receive for being too stupid or lazy to become programmers and sysadmins so they can use FSF products instead, likewise repel me - but, again, outside clapping at his talks and the very occasional hardliner, no one really cares enough about those opinions to act on them. There is no movement around those views of Stallman's. Not even the movement he helped originate seems much to heed him any longer. The same cannot, unfortunately, be said of Alex Gleason. He's part of a concerted effort to deny young trans people access to gender-affirming, and in many cases thus actually lifesaving, therapies, ultimately in support of a paternalistic belief that the people with these opinions, rather than trans people themselves, get to decide what it means to be trans, and gatekeep access to medical and psychological support on that basis. They're not above such underhanded means as inventing official-sounding medical terminology ("rapid-onset gender dysphoria"), or attempting by manipulation of public opinion and legal systems to defund trans charities and aid organizations (Mermaids UK), to advance that cause. And while they have less support now than they might have four or five years ago, their movement remains very active, and still quite able to inflict harm. So, I don't think the cases are really all that similar. In the abstract realm of pure ideas, sure, we could look at them as parallel examples of contrarianism. But the abstract realm of pure ideas isn't where we actually live. Here in reality, ideas exist in the context of the actions they motivate among people who believe in them. Stallman's weird gross ideas motivate nothing in particular, beyond maybe a little yelling and the occasional incoming F-bomb, among anyone of whom I'm aware. Gleason's weird gross ideas, by contrast, move people in ways that cause other people real harm. Maybe you're willing to overlook that. It's definitely a choice you can make. It's not one with which I'd be comfortable, but we all have our own concepts of morality and ethics, and judge one another and the world in which we live accordingly.
- dependenttypes 6y ago> but it's not something that anyone takes seriously I do, and so do a lot of other people. His arguments were tolerant and made perfectly fine sense. > Stallman's views on people who use platforms like Facebook or tools like Photoshop, namely that they deserve whatever abuse they receive for being too stupid or lazy to become programmers and sysadmins so they can use FSF products instead This is not his views as far as I know.
- throwanem 6y agoThen he should say different things at the talks he gives, if he still does. What I described was what he said to an SRO audience at HOPE 2016.