3 ms·
All those sites look like news sites to me, except the Atlantic, which is indeed limited to opinion/commentary. Salon's About page: "Salon covers breaking news
by rbecker 6y ago
All those sites look like news sites to me, except the Atlantic, which is indeed limited to opinion/commentary.
Salon's About page: "Salon covers breaking news, politics, entertainment, culture, and technology through investigative reporting, commentary, criticism, and provocative personal essays." A few titles from their site:
-As pandemic spreads, feds go MIA
-Did Steve Daines get pharma kickback?
-The second pandemic: Pollution
-Many Black, Latinx and poor Americans who needed relief the most never got a stimulus check: study
-Dr. Fauci says it's not "dreaming" that a coronavirus vaccine could arrive by 2021
-The COVID-19 downturn triggers jump in Medicaid enrollment
The Root has an explicit "News" section (theroot.com/c/news). Some titles from the site (not limited to that section):
-Jamaica's Supreme Court Rules That School Can Ban Child With Dreadlocks (No, We're Not Kidding)
-Protests Planned in St. Louis, Mo. After New Prosecutor Says He Won't Make Criminal Charges in Police Killing of Michael Brown
-Brooklyn Man Sentenced to 10 Years for Hate Crime Against Black Woman
-After a Summer of Social Media Trolling By Gen Z, Trump Says He's Going to Ban TikTok From America
-Rumored VP Candidate Rep. Karen Bass Explains Video of Her Praising Church of Scientology, Denounces Fidel Castro
-Michigan Appeals Court Grants Release of Black Girl Who Was Detained After Not Doing Online Homework
Vox:
-The slow-motion 2020 election disaster states are scrambling to prevent, explained
-The US ambassador to Brazil reportedly asked Brazilian officials to help Trump’s reelection
-Scientists have backed away from the worst-case climate scenario — and the best one too
-“The end of arms control as we know it”
-Polls: Biden and Trump are nearly tied in North Carolina and Georgia
-As coronavirus cases increase worldwide, an Australian state is imposing tough new restrictions
-Lawmakers still “not close” to a coronavirus stimulus deal, a day after $600 federal relief expired
Huffpost also has a "News" section (the most prominent of all). Some titles taken straight from their front page:
-Coronavirus Live Updates: Read The Latest About The COVID-19 Outbreak
-Top Health Official: Time To ‘Move On’ From Hydroxychloroquine Efficacy Claims
-College Athletes Threaten To Skip Season Over COVID-19, Racial Justice Demands
-Watchdog Calls For Probe Amid Fears Of ‘Voter Suppression Tactics’ Through Postal Service
-Thousands Ordered To Evacuate As Wildfires Scorch Southern California
-Navy SEALS Investigate Video Of Dogs Attacking Colin Kaepernick Stand-In
The very first section of Slate is titled "News & Politics". A few titles from that section:
-The US Takes On TikTok
-The Republican National Convention in Charlotte Will Be Closed to the Press
-Arizona Congressman Tests Positive for COVID-19, Blasts Republicans Who Don’t Wear Masks
-Hundreds of Coronavirus Infections at Georgia Camp Raise Tough Questions About Schools Reopening
-EU Extends Ban on Dangerous Foreign Travelers (Americans)
In sum, there's no way to claim these are not news sites.
- fock 6y agonothing in "investigative reporting, commentary, criticism, and provocative personal essays" is, what I consider news. q.e.d. vox.com: "Vox explains the news.". No shroud of being objective here either. q.e.d. slate.com: "we are a general-interest publication offering analysis and commentary about politics, news, business, technology, and culture" general interest is vague, but no non-commented news here either, q.e.d. the root has a category "news", but if you visit their main page you see, it's just a sort of "community news-ticker" (like any political page has) and I don't see them making claims to universality. Compare that to Breitbart mingling everything there is into their political agend and explicitly stating: "truthful reporting", ... , "Breitbart News is one of America’s leading news organizations." leaves the huffpost which is laughable by design.
- rbecker 6y ago> nothing in "investigative reporting, [..]" is, what I consider news. q.e.d. At this point I don't think there's anything I can say that will convince you. But yes, if you invent some contrived definition of "news site" that disqualifies every left-wing site, only right-wing ones remain. And I don't understand how that is even relevant to the article - as long as you can "get your news" from some source, that's enough. It doesn't have to pass some made-up purity test of what qualifies as a news site, because readers won't be applying that test. To pretend only right-wing sites share news and opinion for free is just willful blindness.