4 ms·
This has nothing to do with communication. The article makes the case that overemphasising English for NLP has produced approaches that are limited in what they
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
This has nothing to do with communication. The article makes the case that overemphasising English for NLP has produced approaches that are limited in what they can do and can only solve some of the problems of English language modelling. In short, they're "one trick ponies" that only work well in one kind of problem. Further progress requires the ability to tackle more diverse problems and that's what the article advocates for. So I'm sorry to say but your "vision" of a united world under English is a vision of a world united under technological stagnation, a world where our NLP (and possibly AI, in general) approaches can only handle a limited set of "low hanging fruit" problems associated with English.
The opinion expressed in your comment, that we should adjust ourselves to our technology, rather than improving our technology to suit our needs, is not entirely new. For example, Andrew Ng has said that rather than trying to make self-driving cars capable of dealing with an unexpected situation such as a pedestrian on a pogo stick, we should make sure that people don't engage in such unexpected behaviour that self-driving cars can't handle [1]. Obviously, this is a recipe not just for suppressing much of the diversity of human behaviour with unpredictable results for our own cognitive capacity, it's also backwards and antithetical to the motive of improving technology to make it capable of new applications.
___________________
[1] Rodney Brooks, Bothersome Bystanders and Self Driving Cars:
https://rodneybrooks.com/bothersome-bystanders-and-self-driving-cars/ https://rodneybrooks.com/bothersome-bystanders-and-self-driv...