4 ms·
If people didn’t use Autodesk’s software I wouldn’t have to pay a surreal amount of money to use their binary API so my cad program can write DWG. But the fact
by alkonaut 6y ago
If people didn’t use Autodesk’s software I wouldn’t have to pay a surreal amount of money to use their binary API so my cad program can write DWG.
But the fact is DWG is the de facto standard in so many engineering disciplines, and that probably won’t change.
The format is also so convoluted and complex that I doubt even Autodesk could ever write a new implementation of it. If someone succeeds, they will still keep changing it slightly every year, so a third party implementation would always be slightly behind.
This type of moat is exactly the type of moat every business dreams of and tries to create, and the only reason it’s bad when Autodesk does it is because they are so big it actually hurts competition on a large scale.
I can’t see a good “open” replacement for DWGs (DXF, IFC, ...) on the horizon, sadly.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoWhat CAD program is this? I’ve switched some users at my work away from Autocad for 2D stuff to DraftSight and have had no problems opening dwg. An annual DraftSight license is $180 or something similarly trifling.
- alkonaut 6y agoA “narrow” cad+fem package for building components. It’s not a general cad program even though it can be used as such. If DraftSight opens the latest dwgs correctly I’d expect it to contain Autodesks dwg dlls.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoAh right, thanks for clearing that up.
- rurban 6y agoLibreDWG comes to rescue, and for better formats JSON is widely used.
- alkonaut 6y agoThere are multiple open reverse-engineer efforts, but Autodesk changes the format every single year, and customers expect to be able to read drawings immediately in the latest format. This is deliberate by Autodesk I think. LibreDWG is also GPL I believe with no option for commercial?
- rurban 6y agoAutodesk changes the format only every 3 years, and since r2007 the changes were minimal. Haven't looked into the r2021 changes yet. Afaik only LibreDWG matches Acad and ODA/Theiga, the rest does only DXF, no DWG write and a minimal numbers of objects. LibreDWG only offers GPL, but many CAD packages thrive with the GPL: Qcad, FreeCad, SolveSpace, Blender.
- alkonaut 6y agoThey release their own library (ObjectARX/RealDWG) yearly in sync with the AutoCad releases, and at least call the format “DWg 2018“,2019,2020 and so on. The library (I think) refuses to open a 2019 file with version 2018. Even if the problem just occurred every 3 years that too would be unacceptable of course. We are developing a proprietary bespoke program, it’s not possible to use GPL style licenses, nor will the niche filfilled by it ever be filled by an OSS program.
- alkonaut 6y ago> JSON is widely used. Not sure I understand how JSON fits into the discussion tbh. Our users don’t decide which format they receive drawings in. They need to handle all the major formats. Our users can’t ask their customer “can you send me a dxf/step/ifc/... instead of the dwg you sent me?”, sadly it’s just not possible.