3 ms·
I see it this way: NASA tries to make a new launcher by itself, though with big inputs from your usual defence industry contractors. Gets shut down by politic
by baybal2 6y ago
I see it this way:
NASA tries to make a new launcher by itself, though with big inputs from your usual defence industry contractors.
Gets shut down by politicians.
SpaceX waltzes into the room, hires all fired engineers working on that from NASA, and LM for a dime, has NASA do half of their rocket for them, for NASA's money (and thus US government's.)
Essentially Musk resold the exiting RnD, and work of US government's engineers to US government.
- nickik 6y agoThat is just pure nonsense. When NASA tried to create the Ares-1 they spend many, many billions and were basically nowwhere and the architecture of their vehicle was absolutly terrible and not remotely competitive with commercial rockets. The got 'shut down by politicians' is because it was a black money pit for a suppar rocket. The reason SpaceX 'waltzed in' was that they actually executed on price, so you don't really have an argument for shutting them down. SpaceX doesn't just sell NASA RnD back to them. First of all, non of that RnD was anywhere near production level, and specially not at the prices SpaceX wanted offered. A lot of the NASA archtecture were simply fundamentally unusable or unpractical, specially if you wanted to use it in a commercial market. In fact, one could argue that going againt everything NASA was doing at the time is what made SpaceX successful. SpaceX made its own choices on every part of the rocket and the capsule, systematically innovated on each part of the rocket and architecture ending up far away from what NASA would have ever even considered doing. That NASA did in no why what so ever build half their rockets for them, or design them. I don't know where you came up with this. What SpaceX is did is fundamentally innovate and rethink the problems to achieve a better solution both from a design and a manufacturing perspective. This downplaying of SpaceX achivement by claiming its all just NASA tech that they are selling to the government is just petty and sad.
- baybal2 6y ago> SpaceX doesn't just sell NASA RnD back to them. First of all, non of that RnD was anywhere near production level, and specially not at the prices SpaceX wanted offered. A lot of the NASA archtecture were simply fundamentally unusable or unpractical, specially if you wanted to use it in a commercial market. Saying that they "resold their own RnD to them" is not copy-paste Ares-1. ULA, Nasa, defence contractors at large had decades of experience with kerolox rocketry starting with first American rockets, which they threw away, and Musk picked up at the cheap with their engineers. And it was a very safe, and sound decision. The same for returnable capsules, and orbital vehicle expertise.
- nickik 6y agoThe engine that SpaceX started out-with was not very impressive, and it was also not just a simple copy of an existing engine. And the Merlin now is a engine far beyond what any other US engine ever managed in a number of metrics. Was it a bit easier to develop a kerlox engine for SpaceX in the US as compared to doing it in Bangladesh and starting fresh with every bit of technical knowlabe about Kerlox, of course it was but SpaceX went from a pretty simple starting point to an incredibly advanced rocket engine that they are flying now. Putting the empasis on well somebody else has done a Kerlox engine before, rather then SpaceX designing and mass producing and incredibly advanced Kerlox engine is just downplaying what they achieved.
- mschuster91 6y ago> Essentially Musk resold the exiting RnD, and work of US government's engineers to US government. What Musk/SpaceX do is a tiny bit different - they're taking politics out of the equation, because unlike ULA they have a boatload of private customers willing to launch satellites for cheap and not have a major problem if one or two launches go bust. If NASA/ULA manage to fuck up a mission there will be political consequences. Not to mention that SpaceX is staff lean which means they have the freedom to do whatever they want to keep costs low, while NASA/ULA is under Congressional pressure to dole out money across the country, even if this is completely against efficiency (and for what it's worth the ESA/Ariane/EADS/Airbus complex suffers from the same problem).
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI think our different point of view is here: >NASA tries to make a new launcher by itself, though with big inputs from your usual defence industry contractors. The way NASA works is as follows; First, they put together a program proposal. Like they put together the Mars Exploration Program[1] in response to their 2014 Science Plan[2]. The program is allocated budget from NASAs annual budget allocation from congress. Then they create science missions which are specific projects within a program that support the program goals. The current Mars mission, Perseverance, is an example. Then they go out and contract with vendors for hardware that they can use in the mission. That includes everything from rovers to launch services. In the case of Artemis, NASA created a program to return a person to the moon. And they started creating requirements for the equipment that they would need. And they put out those contracts and request proposals, which capable vendors will send in. Then they select from the proposals they get and issue a contract. The vendor then builds the part to the requirements, NASA verifies that it meets there needs, and then they pay the vendor. Often these contracts will have several milestones that have to be met, and the vendor will be paid for meeting milestones. This lets the vendor get some money to buy raw materials and start construction, etc. Cost overruns occur when the vendor discovers something between milestones that wasn't anticipated and they negotiate with NASA for additional funds to cover that need. NASA has never "tried to make a new launcher", that they have done is specified requirements for a launcher that doesn't yet exist and asked people to send them proposals for how they would build it. [1] https://mars.nasa.gov/ https://mars.nasa.gov/ [2] http://smd-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/science-pink/s3fs-public/atoms/files/2014_Science_Plan_PDF_Update_508_TAGGED_1.pdf http://smd-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/science-pink/s3fs-public/at...