5 ms·
Do you think people would be more or less inclined to go to restaurants or order takeout if there's an exponentially-growing out-of-control pandemic sweeping th
by vkou 6y ago
Do you think people would be more or less inclined to go to restaurants or order takeout if there's an exponentially-growing out-of-control pandemic sweeping their city?
Speaking of restaurants, there's a funny thing that's happening with them. Ones in residential areas are currently doing OK. Ones in predominantly commercial areas are dying - because everyone's telecommuting.
Lifting the lockdown won't do a damn thing to help the latter. All of those telecommuting workers are going to keep telecommuting [1], regardless of whether or not some politician decides to sacrifice a few million kulaks on the altar of economic growth.
[1] Amazon, for instance, will keep most of its employees at home until at least January 2021 (And will doubtlessly push that date off, again). Do you think any of the restaurants surrounding their offices in South Lake Union are going to get any customers, even if Washington state re-opens tomorrow? Why would Amazon employees patronize them, when they are all working from home?
- matz1 6y ago>Do you think people would be more or less inclined to go to restaurants or order takeout At very least, it would help. >if there's an exponentially-growing out-of-control pandemic sweeping their city? yes case its growing because there is more testing but for majority the case its either asymptotic or only mild symptom. >All of those telecommuting workers are going to keep telecommuting Sure but doesn't mean they won't go to restaurant. I'm wfh but still go to restaurant.
- xxpor 6y ago"there's more cases because we're going more testing" might be the most uninformed take there is.
- matz1 6y agoHow is it uninformed ?
- nemothekid 6y agoIt’s uninformed because the US has a way higher rate of positive cases per 1000 cases than the rest of the world.
- matz1 6y agoAnd how do u get that number that if not because of testing ?
- fredophile 6y agoTesting didn't make those people sick; It just revealed how many people are actually sick. I only have anecdotes but my understanding is that it can still be hard to get tested in some areas. That implies that tests are being used on people we're pretty sure have it. Increased testing should allow us to test less likely people so the percentage of positive tests should drop with increased testing. Testing also isn't the only indicator we have but the results of the others lag behind testing. Other useful indicators include the number of hospitalizations for covid patients and excess deaths.
- matz1 6y ago>Testing didn't make those people sick; I didn't say testing make people stick. > It just revealed how many people are actually sick Testing doesn't reveal how many people are actually sick. A lot of people tested positive but never get sick. >That implies that tests are being used on people we're pretty sure have it It was hard to get testing before but its relatively easier now. A lot of people get tested despite they never have a symptom. A lot of hospital test all patient coming to hospital get tested despite they come for different reason.
- fredophile 6y ago> I didn't say testing make people stick. You said that there are more cases because we're doing more testing. That's wrong. Testing doesn't change the number of infections; It only changes the number of infections we know about. > A lot of people tested positive but never get sick. If you're infected but asymptomatic or have mild symptoms you're still sick. > It was hard to get testing before but its relatively easier now. A lot of hospital test all patient coming to hospital get tested despite they come for different reason. "Relatively" doesn't mean much when testing was abysmal before. > A lot of people get tested despite they never have a symptom. Where is this happening? Where in the US are there enough tests that anyone that wants a test can get one? > A lot of hospital test all patient coming to hospital get tested despite they come for different reason. Hospitals are a unique situation. They have a lot of people there that are at risk of severe complications if they catch COVID but at the same time have to deal with anyone from the public being able to enter the hospital at any time. It makes sense that they would take special precautions that are not necessary or appropriate elsewhere.
- ars 6y agoHow do you explain such a high case rate and yet deaths are similar to other countries with far fewer cases? The case rate is easy to manipulate with changes in testing rate. The death rate is hard to manipulate.
- matz1 6y agoeven death rate can be easy to manipulate. Someone had a car accident while also tested positive for covid -> death by covid.
- fredophile 6y agoExcess deaths is a better measure and more consistent. If last year you had X deaths per 100 000 people and this year you have X+Y deaths per 100 000 then you can say the number of deaths due to COVID, either directly or indirectly, is around Y per 100 000.
- xsmasher 6y ago> yes case its growing because there is more testing At least in Contra Costa County, the % positive rate is increasing (back to 10%, the highest it has ever been.) Testing more people doesn't increase the % positive rate. An increase in rate of infected people does. We do not have this under control, and rushing to reopen will just cause it to go exponential again.
- matz1 6y agoObviously I was referring to confirmed case. Testing more people increase the number of confirmed case. The fact remain, if you get infected at all, majority of the cases are asymptotic or only mild symptom.