3 ms·
Do you not tie yourself to your Bitcoin when you try to use it for something physical like turning it into cash or buying a physical asset? Can you not track a
by chrisseaton 6y ago
Do you not tie yourself to your Bitcoin when you try to use it for something physical like turning it into cash or buying a physical asset?
Can you not track all Bitcoins going in and out of a mixer?
- walrus01 6y agoI think one of the ideas of mixers is to achieve such a large volume of transactions that dedicating man-hours and personnel resources to tracking down every transaction path becomes cost prohibitive on the part of a law enforcement organization.
- jki275 6y agoThe idea is that you can't track any of the transaction paths. There's nothing tying a specific input transaction to a specific output transaction, and great pains are taken to ensure there cannot be any publicly available link.
- zenexer 6y ago500 unrelated accounts all deposit money into a single shared account. From that shared account, payments are made to 1,000 other accounts. None of the amounts match the original deposits, even when summed. Whose money is whose? This is an oversimplification, but it should give you a rough idea of how difficult it is to trace Bitcoin.
- vdfs 6y agoAuthorities might already know mixers service providers and a subpoena will give them all info they need. Not sure tho, I haven't used bitcoin but there always be weak link somewhere
- walrus01 6y agoI would be very surprised if any mixer operators are located in places that care in the slightest about a US subpoena (russia, etc).
- zenexer 6y agoHow are you going to identify them? When they cash out, all their Bitcoin has already been laundered. Granted, this is all theoretical. In practice, it’s not unusual for such people to make mistakes that reveal their identity; however, there’s nothing inherent to Bitcoin that ensures they can be de-anonymized. Usually they attempt to go after hosting providers, but when the services are only accessible by Tor and they’re using bulletproof hosting—hosting providers who do their best to avoid law enforcement—that’s no easy feat. It’s not impossible, but it can be both a technical and diplomatic nightmare.
- sonicggg 6y agoYou clearly have no idea what you're talking about.
- hombre_fatal 6y ago> This is an oversimplification, but it should give you a rough idea of how difficult it is to trace Bitcoin. You'd be surprised. The feds have very advanced taint analysis if they have reason to go after you.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoWhen you use a mixer, there’s a delay between when you put your money in and when it comes back out. The mixing service randomly splits up the transaction into batches and sends them out at different times. So even if you know that somebody sent to a mixer (perhaps as an investigator you could find out mixer addresses by sending lots of transactions to the mixer service yourself), you wouldn’t be able to associate those inputs with any particular output. If the mixer has a lot of users, at best you could determine that the your target is among the entire set of people who used the mixer this hour/day. Although if the mixer was compromised, you’d have everything. That does seem like a substantial risk. It’s kind of like deciding to trust your vpn. You could mitigate that risk by using multiple mixers.
- el_nahual 6y agoWouldn't using multiple mixers increase the risk? You only need to be traced once.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI would not split your transaction between mixers, but instead mix your entire amount through one, then mix all of the outputs through others. Use multiple mixers in series, not in parallel. Compromising one mixer there would associate the inputs and outputs of that step but wouldn’t associate your initial input with your final output. You’d also want to conceal your ip at every step so you don’t get compromised that way either.
- walrus01 6y agoWould there not be a huge danger that a mixer operator, if they received $4m+ of BTC in one big transfer, could simply shut down immediately and pull what's known as an 'exit scam'? They would be in possession of the BTC and could themselves then launder it through other mixers. Perhaps they might do this if the saw keeping the entire 4m as much more lucrative than many years of taking the percentage skimmed off the top from a number of smaller transactions, and just going into "retirement".
- sjtindell 6y agoIf you understand enough about Bitcoin to know how the immutable ledger works, your questions feel bad faith. One of the biggest “selling points” early on was obviously anonymity.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]