3 ms·
They have a monopoly on iOS app stores. This is a different market than Android app stores because the set of customers is completely different. It's like havi
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
They have a monopoly on iOS app stores. This is a different market than Android app stores because the set of customers is completely different.
It's like having a monopoly in California. "Just sell in New York instead" doesn't work, because you already sell in New York and not selling in California doesn't get the California customers to the New York store.
Compare this to stores that actually have competition, e.g. three grocers on the same street corner. If you don't want to sell to one of them, the customers who want your product just go across the street and buy it there. If you sell to all of them they each represent a third of your sales. If you don't want to sell to one of them, you don't actually lose all of those sales because the same customers can still buy your product from the other stores.
If you don't sell to Apple, none of those app sales go to Android because people don't replace their $1000 phone to buy a $1 app. That's what makes it a different market, which is what makes it a monopoly.
- jpttsn 6y agoIs Mercedes a monopoly for Mercedes leather seating?
- bubblethink 6y agoMercedes doesn't stop you from replacing the leather, does it? Why do you need a flawed analogy to make a flawed argument? You can make a flawed argument as is.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Is Mercedes a monopoly for Mercedes leather seating? The key to understanding this is to realize that you're talking about two different markets, which makes your question ambiguous. Are you asking, do they have a monopoly over the market for the Mercedes brand of leather seating? In that case the answer doesn't really matter, and I suspect this is the point you were trying to make, because the market for the Mercedes brand of leather seating is not a meaningful market definition, since there could be other seating brands that compete for the same customers. But the analogous question to the one I'm asking is, do they have a monopoly over seating for Mercedes vehicles? That could very well be a sensible market definition, because if you need a new seat for your Mercedes, one designed for a Chevy may not fit. And then the answer depends entirely on whether they have any competitors in that market. If five different companies make seats you can put in a Mercedes, none of them have a monopoly. If Mercedes -- or another company which isn't Mercedes, if Mercedes itself doesn't make them anymore -- is the only one making seats that fit in a Mercedes, then they have a monopoly on that market. The question is whether the customer who has a Mercedes and needs a seat can only buy it from one place.
- ric2b 6y agoNo, you can replace the seats without violating any laws or licenses.
- nodamage 6y agoThe way you have defined the word monopoly does not make legal or practical sense. Consider this, if Apple only ever made 100 smartphones and sold them to 100 people and had 0.00001% share of the smartphone market, no one in their right mind would consider them a monopoly or ever consider bringing an anti-trust case against them for the restrictions they impose on their own App Store. But everything you said would still hold true: "They have a monopoly on iOS app stores." "This is a different market than Android app stores because the set of customers is completely different." So clearly this definition cannot be the correct way to define what is and isn't a monopoly.
- Dahoon 6y ago>The way you have defined the word monopoly does not make legal or practical sense Maybe not to you but it is how the anti-monopoly law work in lots of countries. Funny that you can just say "Doesn't work, NEXT!" as if you know better than Telegram's lawyers. Apple will be fined or settle.
- nodamage 6y agoI can't speak for every country, but in the EU I think it's likely the case will be thrown out due to the inability to prove that Apple has "substantial market power" with 25% market share. The Commission considers that low market shares are generally a good proxy for the absence of substantial market power. The Commission's experience suggests that dominance is not likely if the undertaking's market share is below 40 % in the relevant market. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX%3A52009XC0224%2801%29 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX%3A...
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYou keep using their share of the phone market when we're talking about the app market. Whether the iOS app market and the Android app market are the same market has nothing to do with what percentage of the market for phone hardware each platform has.
- scarface74 6y agoYes only Apple can sell it’s own products. That’s not how monopolies work.
- ifmpx 6y agoOnce sold, an Apple device is no longer the property of Apple. Maintaining exclusive access to the primary (and I'd argue only) means of purchasing software for a device they do not own is a monopoly, even if it might not have been classically considered as such. I hope the investigation ends in telegrams favor.
- scarface74 6y agoDo you feel the same way about consoles? But the question remains, why buy a device that doesn’t meet your needs if there are alternatives?
- Apocryphon 6y agoPerhaps they bought the device based on the primary metric of security and privacy. But with the banning of Telegram, it turns out the potential for secure chat is insufficient on iOS. Therefore, Apple is falsely advertising themselves as a privacy-focused platform. [0] Therefore, the legal options available to Apple are either 1) open up their platform, 2) permit Telegram to be sold on the App Store, or 3) rescind their false advertising. The ball is in the EU court. [0] https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/03/14/privacy-thats-iphone-ad-campaign-launches-highlights-apples-stance-on-user-protection https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/03/14/privacy-thats-iph...
- scarface74 6y agoTelegram was not banned. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/telegram-messenger/id686449807 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/telegram-messenger/id686449807
- ghostwriter 6y ago> Maintaining exclusive access to the primary (and I'd argue only) means of purchasing software for a device they do not own is a monopoly The device is yours, the operating system is not, it has its own license and you even get regular updates of its terms. If you don't agree with them, you are free to jailbreak your device and use it at your own discretion & expense.