4 ms·
Aren't Facebook ads essentially a perfect market (in the economic sense) if done properly? Even if someone drops out, there would be someone with a slightly low
by MattGaiser 6y ago
Aren't Facebook ads essentially a perfect market (in the economic sense) if done properly? Even if someone drops out, there would be someone with a slightly lower bid just behind them.
- cowpig 6y agoAren't they the farthest possible thing? There is literally one entity (Facebook) controlling the supply (human beings with dopamine addictions).
- MattGaiser 6y agoThere is one supplier, but they almost function like a stock exchange or an auction house. You place per unit bids for actions/types of people and depending on what you bid, your ad gets shown to to different people. You would think that bids would eventually become quite economically efficient simply because of how easily conversion can be tracked.
- aaron695 6y agoThat's a pretty interesting question. I would have said no. But I can't think why. Certainly Youtube and the other big monopolies behave like they are not a perfect market. Every now and again you'll see an article saying it's not known if advertising on the Internet even works that well. So the opinion is information around advertising is not really fluid enough, not sure in practice.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe bit on internet advertising not working that well is interesting given that all the startups I know can tell you (to the cent) what it costs to acquire a customer. Perhaps that number provides a false sense of understanding and control and there is an information bias towards it over harder to analyze types of advertising such as radio, but it seems like the ROI for internet advertising would be the most clear.
- cwhiz 6y agoMy understanding is that the average of average costs to obtain a customer is relatively unchanged over the years. Even going back to well before the internet existed, the numbers are relatively equal. So we have all these platform vacuuming up massive volumes of personal data so that companies and organizations can target individuals with surgical precision.... and it might not be any more effective on the aggregate than traditional advertising in the 60s. https://www.nber.org/papers/w20171.pdf https://www.nber.org/papers/w20171.pdf
- WhompingWindows 6y agoWhat is a perfect market? What is FB advertising "done properly"? I don't believe FB is a perfect marketplace because there are too many powerful interests with their thumbs on the scale. If Zuckerberg and crew were actually impartial and objective and wanted a perfect market, which they don't, even if they did want it...could they make it? Where is the line between marketing, lying, up-selling, persuasion, and truth?
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe term I should have used was "efficient market." Basically, because of the bid system and assuming that companies are testing different prices, prices for ads should be relatively efficient. I was not commenting on the content on the ads, just the pricing of them.
- bryan_w 6y agoIndeed, when one big advertiser defects, the remaining advertisers get cheaper ads which should lead to more conversions