3 ms·
> I can't install the apps I wish to install on my Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft, Tesla, VW etc. People keep bringing this up as if it wouldn't be better if they w
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> I can't install the apps I wish to install on my Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft, Tesla, VW etc.
People keep bringing this up as if it wouldn't be better if they were required to allow competition too.
> Your argument that "every platform must allow open access" is an unprecedented one that would destroy many business models.
The illegality of murder destroys the business model of hitmen. Destroying harmful business models is the idea.
It's not as if consoles wouldn't exist under a different business model. The console itself would cost more (or just generate less profit) and the games would cost less. It's hard to see how that wouldn't be an improvement.
- swinglock 6y agoI'm not convinced it would exist in any meaningful way. We already have such a "console", it's called a PC. You could buy one today but for whatever reasons people still buy the locked down consoles.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe consoles are purpose-built devices. They come with game controllers rather than keyboards. They're designed to be attached to a television with an interface designed to be used from across the room. You might very well end up in a market where you could build your own console by plugging a game controller into a PC and installing SteamOS on it in addition to companies selling them pre-built like that, but what's so bad about that?
- ballenf 6y ago"Harmful business model" is a reductive, meaningless argument. I don't buy many games and have 2 latest gen consoles. I would be harmed by your suggestion. How do you choose which group's harm is more important? And who do you trust to make that analysis?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> "Harmful business model" is a reductive, meaningless argument. It has a very specific meaning here. It means a market where the company is not subject to significant competitive pressure. > I don't buy many games and have 2 latest gen consoles. I would be harmed by your suggestion. You are engaged in arbitrage. The company sold you a subsidized game console on the theory that you would buy games for it, and you didn't. If everyone did what you did the business model would fail anyway (or the company would devise a way to prevent you from doing that), so you're hardly in a position to argue against something else that attacks the same business model that you're attacking yourself. You would also have no recourse if the company implemented some method of preventing your arbitrage. > How do you choose which group's harm is more important? The one being deprived of the benefits of competition. > And who do you trust to make that analysis? You can make it yourself. Obviously you have to hire someone to actually do the enforcement, but if they come to the same conclusion as you then you know they're doing it right.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]