4 ms·
Unpopular opinion: I see it as a little bit similar the coronavirus masks here. Your choice can potentially impact my security. (or, security of the platform).
by dijit 6y ago
Unpopular opinion: I see it as a little bit similar the coronavirus masks here. Your choice can potentially impact my security. (or, security of the platform).
Personally I like apple devices, I like that when I give them to my family I don't get a bunch of support questions like I do when I give them PC's or my old Android devices.
That said: I would prefer apple devices (and thus, their store) to be a minority market share, which pushes the play store to look at their own practices and increase the barrier to entry, or the standard to which applications are held.
Even my girlfriend (who is young and relatively tech savvy, though does not work in tech) has downloaded and executed virus' from the play store by mistake.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoif you don't install sideloaded apps, it won't impact your security in the slightest. Or, maybe, you don't like the idea that you'll have to sideload the app you need because it isn't available in the AppStore? Hmm. Well, you'll feel a biiiiit like other people who don't have a choice under Apple's regime, with only difference that they can't run the app at all, and you can run it in a way that you don't like.
- dijit 6y agoContext of this thread is an alternative application store; Sideloading is still possible and is free, but you have to know what you're doing. It's a tremendous barrier to entry (your keys even expire every few days so you have to keep re-sideloading) thus people don't bother with it.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoSideloading is you press a link, download app, install it (granting permissions), run it. Anything else is not sideloading. Alternative appstore is basically same as sideloading, cause the latter is necessary for the former to function. Btw important overlooked issue is not only sideloading per se, but unrestricted access to push notifications / subscribing to alternative push notification services. With restrictions on running in background iOS apps are next to useless without notifications - you won't get VoIP, email, chat apps working without capability to wake up on push.
- dijit 6y agoI think we fundamentally disagree here then. :) I'm very happy in my locked platform, I'm happy that my family are on a locked platform. If they (or I) want to be on a more open platform then that exists, just not for apple devcies; but for now I trust random developers less than I trust Apple. If it becomes normalised to bypass the app store, then it's going to be very difficult to control the quality of software generally; and on a macro-scale will entice even large developers (like banks) to go the 'alternative app store' route, which will force everyone to be using applications which are not vetted in a reasonable way.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoIn other words, as I said in the beginning of the thread, you like not having a choice, and you do not want me to have a choice, too. But why are you wording this as if AppStore will somehow vanish? I don't think it will be going anywhere even if some apps will start working without Apple's permission. Chances are, it'll get better if it has some real competition.
- dijit 6y agoWell, very very technically; you kinda made a choice when you bought an Apple product. It's like buying an android phone then being sour that photoshop doesn't work, I think. As for why I'm wording it as if the AppStore will dissapear, it's because of all the reasons I laid out. Right now it's a gate or a fence; the great filter which all must pass through; but if there exists a cheaper/easier alternative that gives the same results, why not use that? It will become incredibly normal to run the alternative app store- to the point where a lot of software will be released only to run there (which is a stated aim) and if everyone has the alternative store, why bother with Apples?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mstolpm 6y ago