4 ms·
The original motivation (from back in 2007) was threefold: (1) BSD licensed, which was felt to be preferable to GCC (ie. GPL) for BSD developers. (2) It's sup
by rwmj 16y ago
The original motivation (from back in 2007) was threefold:
(1) BSD licensed, which was felt to be preferable to GCC (ie. GPL) for BSD developers.
(2) It's supposed to compile things 5-10 times faster than GCC.
(3) Very portable to new architectures; obviously a good thing for NetBSD which is ported to just about everything.
LLVM doesn't figure into this; perhaps it was unknown or not very capable back in 2007?
Source: http://marc.info/?l=netbsd-tech-toolchain&m=118961767521349&w=2 http://marc.info/?l=netbsd-tech-toolchain&m=118961767521...
- _delirium 16y agoAlthough LLVM existed and was fairly well known, it was a middle/backend-only project until mid-2007 or so, and used gcc as the language frontend. Clang's first source release wasn't until July 2007, and I don't think it got much traction until 2008, and a 1.0 release in late 2009. So it seems plausible that a September 2007 discussion wouldn't have it on the radar.
- dwc 16y agoAlso in (3), very portable to old architectures. PCC is written in C, where LLVM/Clang is C++. This makes one less hurdle to bootstrapping a new compiler on some archs.
- Hoff 16y agoFrom experience in porting an OS, common porting scaffolding can include a cross compiler and a cross linker, and replacing an assembler with a compiler for compiling the assembly code for the new target box. Getting a native build and a native C++ and a native assembler re-hosted can then proceed secondary to getting the basic OS pieces booted and rolling.
- nickbp 16y agoWith regard to 2, I don't care so much about compile speed (within reason) as I do about the speed of the produced binary. How fast is the output?
- tedunangst 16y agoDepends entirely on what particular optimizations apply to your code. Overall, pcc is probably within 10% for most code, but you'll also find examples where gcc or llvm is 10x faster. It all depends.
- protomyth 16y agoIf your maintaining code on a VAX, you care a tad bit about compile speed.