3 ms·
Between cheap GPS and facial recognition tracking people is basically free now. The technology will come to the rest of the world by virtue of simple economics.
by roenxi 6y ago
Between cheap GPS and facial recognition tracking people is basically free now. The technology will come to the rest of the world by virtue of simple economics.
It raises an interesting question of what types of political dissent will even be possible in this century. The incumbent advantage to the police is huge.
Something I've noticed is that since around the turn of the century is it is now technically possible for governments to enforce all laws. That wasn't the case even as recently as the 90s.
- magicsmoke 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty I remember taking a class where the professor claimed the framework above as the basis for understanding interactions between people and their governments. People ultimately have two actions they can take, to use their voice/dissent, or leave the country. In a world where dissent isn't possible, leaving will be the only response to poor governance. How seriously a government takes emigration will also depend on the people emigrating as a highly skilled engineer is far more valuable to the national economy and military than a fast food cashier, and this would skew political influence away from one person one voice towards one dollar one voice even more. In the event even leaving isn't possible due to an emigration ban, the only response may be to refuse to work on new technologies and let the country stagnate economically until the government is weak enough where dissent/rebellion is possible again. At the end of the day, power games form the foundation for most large-scale human interactions, and you only have power over someone if you can give them something they want, or do something to them they don't want. Governments want their people to not rebel and overthrow them, and to be economically and technologically productive so they don't fall behind and get conquered. In a world where rebellion isn't possible, not giving governments the economic production they want is the only way to exercise power.
- inetsee 6y ago"In a world where rebellion isn't possible, not giving governments the economic production they want is the only way to exercise power." Made me think of "Atlas Shrugged" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_Shrugged https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_Shrugged
- jlokier 6y ago> leaving will be the only response to poor governance There are an awful lot of people around the world who want to leave their country but can't. When I visited China ~15 years ago, I met several people who told me they wished they could leave and see where I lived, but they didn't think they would ever be able to. I assured them I thought they could someday, but I'm not so sure about that now. Last I heard you need to take care of your social credit score to travel at all. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/01/china-bans-23m-discredited-citizens-from-buying-travel-tickets-social-credit-system https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/01/china-bans-23m...
- modeless 6y ago> it is now technically possible for governments to enforce all laws This change is underappreciated. As enforcement gets stronger it's becoming feasible to make stronger and more specific laws. I don't believe this is a good thing for society in general. It's also possible for governments to hold power with less and less public support by quashing opposition and shutting down protests more effectively with overpowered police and militaries. I don't think the right to bear arms helps much with the growing power imbalance. It just doesn't make sense anymore for civilians to be armed with the same weapons as governments, now that government weapons are so powerful. Technology is only accelerating these trends, especially AI. The governments of the future will hold unprecedented power over their populations. Democracy is supposed to ensure that power isn't used against the people, but I think current political systems won't be able to prevent it. We need much better implementations of democracy to handle the power that is coming to governments in the next century.
- zarkov99 6y agoI often wonder if these advancements in information processing now allow for centrally planned economies to compete with free market ones. What would have happened if the USSR had all the tools we have today for monitoring and computation?
- logicchains 6y agoThe problem with centrally planned economies wasn't one of processing power, it was one of information. The market is essentially based on "actions speak louder than words": if someone is willing to spend their hard-earned money on something, this reveals their preference for this thing. The market aggregates these preferences, incentivising production that meets this demand. Without a system for people to express such preferences, it's impossible to determine what to produce, no matter how much processing power is available, because one cannot know what people want. If people were given some allocation of credits that they could spend to indicate what they'd like, then that's just a market under another name.
- zarkov99 6y agoI am not sure preferences are as inscrutable as you imply when you can monitor every conversation, every social media interaction, every email exchange, every Baidu search. In fact I am pretty sure they aren't.