3 ms·
> ...but Jews are... definitely not white To be fair, I don't think this is a common view anymore, least of all in polite society. "White" was extended from in
by zozbot234 6y ago
> ...but Jews are... definitely not white
To be fair, I don't think this is a common view anymore, least of all in polite society. "White" was extended from indicating strictly WASP settlers (excluding even the Irish) to Europeans in general as early as the late-19th to early-20th c. - and then further extended to include Middle-Eastern folks and the like sometime later. It's definitely weird though how these ethnical and even overtly race-based characterizations are used in the U.S.
- rbecker 6y agoI think AmericanChopper meant that in the sense that when someone complains about whites, they don't have Jews in mind.
- zozbot234 6y agoHow could you tell that they don't, though? And does it really matter, since they probably don't have Polish or $RANDOM_WHITE_SUBGROUP folks in mind either, but this doesn't make Polish folks non-white.
- austhrow743 6y agoBecause the kind of people that complain about whites don't like the kind of people that complain about jews.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe whiteness of Jews is certainly not a settled topic. You’ll find Jews with varying opinions on this, white supremacists generally don’t consider them to be white, and neither do those who support the “social justice” political ideologies. The reason it confounds so many people so much is because Jews are known to be a historically oppressed people (despite exceed statistical averages for life outcomes so consistently), and white people cannot be oppressed, because they are the people who do the oppression! In reality these contradictions only serve to highlight how stupid (and racist) it is to make those sorts of generalizations. Categorizing people by skin color is especially stupid, because the larger a group becomes, the less homogenous it becomes, and the less merit the generalizations have. Scottish, Irish and English people are all white, yet two of those groups have a rather long history of particularly horrific oppression at the hands of the 3rd. When should we start discussing reparations for the highland clearances? Should Dan Castellaneta resign from his role on The Simpson’s for so blatantly reinforcing a negative racial stereotype? Is Elon Musk America’s wealthiest African American? How much oppression does a brown-skinned African American have in common with a brown-skinned Indian immigrant? The reason those questions sound so stupid is because the world is actually full of roughly 7.5 billion individual people, who all have their own individual circumstances, views and life experiences, and the more you try and group them together, the further you drift from reality. Especially if you’re trying to group them together for the purposes of holding some form of racial prejudice.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- himinlomax 6y ago> and neither do those who support the “social justice” They certainly count them as white when complaining about representation in Hollywood.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoOf course, their whiteness depends on the circumstances. They’re white when it’s time to complain about the oppressive white establishment, and not white when it’s time to talk about how they’re an oppressed ethnic minority. It’s the same way that an Indian is an oppressed person of color when they want to soapbox about progressive race issues, but absolutely not when it’s time to meet the diversity quota, or fill out college admissions forms.
- zozbot234 6y agoIrish, Polish, Catholics etc. are all "oppressed ethnic minorities" within the broader white population, yet few would regard them as not white.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThat is completely true, and I imagine that if any of the atrocities committed against Irish, Scottish, Polish, Catholics (the list goes on really) had been as prominent in our culture as study of the Holocaust has been, then you would find the same hypocrisy there too. Questioning the scope and scale of Jewish oppression is (quite rightly) absolutely not tolerated in our society, however doing the same for Irish oppression for instance is perfectly acceptable. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3790116?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/3790116?seq=1 More recently this line of reasoning has been quite thoroughly debunked, but you’d be forgiven if you never really knew the Irish were ever oppressed, not noticing that disputing this was common place or not noticing that such denials have been proven false. Outside of some high Irish density areas, these topics have never been a significant part of our culture. So a white Irishman saying “I too have grievances of historical oppression” isn’t going to be taken all that seriously, whereas a Jewish complaint would be. Which is really what my whole point has been in this thread. When you start grouping people together in large numbers, you deny them any level of individual identity, or shared culture that may set them apart from other group members. When you do this along the lines of skin color or ethnicity, you’re just being racist.