4 ms·
That's probably... fine? these vaccines are developed in a process far more open than any typical pharmaceutical research. The risks at issue here are unlikely
by IfOnlyYouKnew 6y ago
That's probably... fine?
these vaccines are developed in a process far more open than any typical pharmaceutical research. The risks at issue here are unlikely to be of the bad-faith variety that can be discouraged with liability.
Instead, these will be genuine known and unknown unknowns. There will be a lot of scrutiny, which will allow governments and the public at large to make these decisions under uncertainty with the benefit of the best possible information at the time.
With the company not enjoying a significant informational advantage, the moral and practical case for liability just doesn't make any sense.
That is a standard approach for the otherwise intractable collision of a legal system that apportions the damages of anything that goes wrong on the party mostly responsible for it, and the medical reality of almost all interventions coming with some potential for grievous harm: by default, your surgeon would always be "responsible", in sense of civil law, not morality or criminal law. Because the general principle allocates responsibility with those making decisions.
"Informed consent" is about getting you into a position to make decisions, and thereby share in the responsibility.
- mrgordon 6y agoWell put
- WalterBright 6y ago> apportions the damages of anything that goes wrong on the party mostly responsible for it That is usually interpreted to mean the party with the money gets stuck with the damages. Nobody sues a penniless person.
- mrweasel 6y agoThe Covid-19 vaccine is also expected to be ready in an amazingly short time frame compared to normal vaccine development. If we’re asking for a vaccine in 2020/2021 we have to accept that it may have serious flaws and side effects. I’m fine with the exemption, it’s the speed of development and testing that concerns me. We can’t possibly know the side effects after short trials.