15 ms·
Bogleheads
- simonebrunozzi 6y ago> The Bogleheads® emphasize starting early, living below one's means, regular saving, broad diversification, simplicity, and sticking to one's investment plan regardless of market conditions. I've heard about Bogleheads for the first time today. Twice! I thought it would be interesting for HN readers to know about it too.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mherdeg 6y agoWith the demise of FatWallet Finance (which I read daily) I haven't really had a good source for the kind of content that used to live there. The Bogleheads forums live in kind of a parallel universe, with sometimes very similar content but a very different outlook. I try to read weekly but a lot of it is kind of "interesting but not useful". Another interesting resource, although not my niche, is the Whitecoatinvestor forums, which offer a neat view at a very specific profession's finances at every stage of their career.
- ve55 6y agoReminds me so starkly of how much of the Internet has moved into single websites like Reddit. I definitely enjoyed browsing a huge variety of interesting forums in the past, but the amount I go to nowadays is much smaller. Convenience is nice, but it still feels like something has been lost.
- kanobo 6y agoFor those who are new to boglehead history, John Bogle was the CEO of Vanguard and is credited with creating the first index fund. Maybe it's just the branding and history, but Vanguard is the only financial institute I think of as a friend.
- jjeaff 6y agoThat might be be because it is one of the few financial institutions that are owned by their members.
- nerfhammer 6y agothe technical term for this is "mutual" or "mutualized"
- zrail 6y agoThe Vanguard ownership and revenue structure is very weird and the subject of multiple IRS and SEC private rulings. It’s not a mutualized organization like a mutual insurance company. Each mutual fund is a separate corporation and contracts with a management company. This is standard across the industry. The Vanguard “twist” is that all Vanguard funds contract with the same central management company. Each fund also owns a share of this company. The management company charges the funds for its services at cost. This has been the subject of at least one lawsuit, alleging that Vanguard is engaging in anti-competitive behavior by not charging funds for management services at an arms length level.
- refurb 6y agoThe Boglehead wiki is a real asset. If you want to start doing index investing, there is a ton of information to get started. And it's very readable. I love the lazy portfolios. You can pick 3 funds (they give you the symbols for Vanguard, Fidelity, etc funds) and just go.
- atombender 6y agoThe Bogleheads site is fantastic. Both the wiki and the discussion board are of high quality; the board is one of those rare niche "Web 1.0" boards with super-knowledgeable posters that almost doesn't exist anymore. The book (The Bogleheads' Guide to Imvesting), written by the website creators, is also one of the best introduction to passive investing. A must for anyone starting out needing to figure out the ins and outs of IRAs, ETFs etc.
- dehrmann 6y agoObviously these old Web 1.0 sites are still relevant because they ~always had high-quality content. I wonder if not jumping on the latest design bandwagon helped cement them in that place. And how much does the design turn off the average Robinhood investor (and I do mean investor, not speculator)?
- uzakov 6y agoIt's indeed, I wonder if there is a list of "Web 1.0" gems anywhere
- jchook 6y agoGonna conjecture you submitted this link because of the discussion around Ask HN: I have $450K cash, what should I do to maximize my return?[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24020899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24020899 Edit: Not trying to rag, just noting that I also found this forum today through that discussion.
- snazz 6y agoYes, see this comment by the OP of this story: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24023607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24023607
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoExactly correct.
- neilv 6y agoBogleheads is great, and one of the more wholesome things on the Web nowadays. When my consulting business was finally doing well (after way too many years of school, debt, and turning down better-paying opportunities), it took me a few tries of asking around and Googling, to find what people were supposed to do with excess money. I ended up wasting some of it on naive sector investing, and on funds/stock-picking, before I stumbled upon Bogleheads. Then I quickly settled into a simple your-age-in-bonds mix of ITOT and AGG (was already at Fidelity), and followed the Bogleheads advice of not touching it, not even looking at it. I also do the solo 401K, maxed contributions, and the HSA bonus (though the HSA was more headache than it was worth). One of the odd things about Bogleheads, however, is that, once you're up to speed, have your accounts set up, no unusual events, and you take the "index on autopilot" to heart... frequenting the forum then seems counterproductive, like it becomes temptation to tinker with financial arrangements, or just a distraction from better things to be doing.
- rewtraw 6y ago> One of the odd things about Bogleheads, however, is that, once you're up to speed, have your accounts set up, no unusual events, and you take the "index on autopilot" to heart... frequenting the forum then seems counterproductive, like it becomes temptation to tinker with financial arrangements, or just a distraction from better things to be doing. That's what I've recently discovered. Dumping everything into VTSAX is the best thing you can do to your investments, but then... where's the excitement? So I've allowed myself a "fun money" brokerage account that I initially deposited $5k into, and just play with options trading. I've already paid myself back the initial investment, so any profit/loss from now on is irrelevant. This way I can still geek out over investing, but not gamble my life savings.
- potiuper 6y agoVTI is the ETF version of VTSAX; has lower expense ratio
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoI prefer the mutuals because I can invest money that day. With a broker account, there’s the ACH waiting period, so you miss out buying dips.
- pixelmonkey 6y agoI found this Wikipedia-style page on personal finance advice for "managing a windfall" so well-written, that I was really startled (by the quality!). I came across it earlier today on HN in an "Ask HN" thread: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Managing_a_windfall https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Managing_a_windfall I had to help my Mom with personal finance. She is a first-generation immigrant who entered her late 60s with no stock or cash retirement savings, but with a lot of home equity value built up by sheer luck of buying a house in a booming suburb right before it really boomed, and holding it for 40 years. She lived paycheck-to-paycheck her whole life, and, because she fled communist Romania when she was in high school, she had a real distrust of the US financial system. (Perhaps warranted at times!) So, I had to help her manage the windfall from the sale of her primary residence as she downsized her living space and needed to tap the newly-liquid cash as a kind of pension and healthcare issue rainy-day fund. She wanted to stick all the money under the mattress (quite literally). I was in my mid-20s at the time (and a college-educated programmer, so savvy enough to wade through the systems), so I tried to wise up to the situation to help her out. I dealt with all the issues outlined in this page (on her behalf) via a lot of haphazard ad-hoc research and through expensive advice from personal lawyers and accountants. I am impressed with the way in which the page tackles not just the pragmatic issues, but also the psychological ones -- e.g. that someone facing a windfall will feel temporarily "rich" because they are newly in the money, and thus won't manage smartly toward a long-term future, and may also be more prone to frivolous purchases. Financial literacy is a really hard thing and so much of the information you find is biased and is selling you one thing or another. I wish I had known about this page -- and the wiki overall -- years ago. The "Bogleheads" philosophy aligns a lot with my personal outlook, which has a a lot of trust for the power of markets and financial management, but a whole lot of distrust for financial advisors and money managers. Now that I've been on this side of the table, representing my Mom's interests in retirement, it became really clear to me why fraud against the elderly is so common, and why it's a very legitimate interest to ensure they are well-protected if they don't have savvy family members who can guide them through it.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI saw that too, and that prompted me to post Bogleheads' home page on HN!
- smabie 6y agoA lot of the stuff on the wiki and site is massively simplified and not strictly true. If you don't know much about finance, stuff like "return is always associated with risk, there is no free-lunch" is a good place to start, but more knowledgeable and quantitative investors know that this isn't true (according to CAPM, only systematic risk generates return, not specific risk). If you haven't thought much about what kind of volatility you are okay with and aren't really interested in managing your money, a boglehead kind of portfolio is good place to start. It's something, for example, that I might recommend my mom, if I wasn't willing to put in the work to manage her investments for her. But for a technical crowd, like HN, the stuff on the site misrepresents modern financial theory and perpetuates people saying stuff that doesn't even make any sense, like, "you can't beat the market", "don't hold a leveraged index fund", "active management is a scam", etc. Like all things people say, these have a kernel of truth, but the specifics and context are so far removed that these statements become meaningless, or even flat out wrong. Even by just holding simple, automated ETFs (I don't call this passive investing, because passive investing doesn't exist), there's tons of room for really interesting optimizations that increase return and decrease risk. Things like risk parity portfolios, minimum variance optimizations, persistent factor portfolios, etc. And best of all, with zero commissions, super tight bid-ask spreads, and easy to access APIs, "quant-lite" investing is more accessible than every before. In conclusion, every portfolio is an active portfolio, from deciding a equity/bond ratio, to investing in real estate, to deciding to buy some TSLA. It's all the same, so stay away from any dogmatic approaches to investing (I would say the bogleheads are pretty dogmatic). By becoming familiar with the biggest and most important advances in quantitative finance, along with understanding your own risk tolerance, you can construct a portfolio that is perfect for you, and that will give you so much more than a one-size-fits-all boglehead portfolio could ever hope to.
- 300bps 6y agoI don’t know your background. But I’ve worked at an investment bank the past 15 years and have traded every kind of stock, bond and derivative there is. With respect, you sound a little bit like every new programmer that I’ve worked with. They get a taste of learning about finance and suddenly become day traders. They make some money and then suddenly they give it all back and more because they really weren’t understanding what they were doing. In general, anyone with a full time job that thinks they can out-compete full time traders that specialize in the exact instrument that you are trying to trade will have a very expensive lesson some day. If you really want to pursue it at least take the level 1 CFA exam. If you can’t pass that you don’t have much of a chance and if you can pass that you’ll probably realize you don’t want to do it.
- Spooky23 6y agoBoglehead stuff is safe and easy. It’s too dogmatic for me in 2020. Following their advice Is good for a 401k, but means holding a lot of garbage. Owning the whole market was smart in 1990. We do not live in 1990. My portfolio of 5-6 stocks + cash has beat any Boglehead portfolio, and has for decades now with a minimum investment in time. No bonds except for GNMA 15-20 years ago. It’s not that hard. AAPL and AMZN have outperformed the market for 15-20 years.
- icebergwarrior 6y agoPlease let us know how to consistently identify the 5-6 stock which will over-perform the market. You would be a billionaire if you could do this.
- Spooky23 6y agoA small number of companies are almost 20% of market value. Unlike the 90s technology improvements are benefiting a small number of entities.
- xapata 6y agoAre you familiar with the "past performance" disclaimer?
- throw0101a 6y ago> A small number of companies are almost 20% of market value. That's been a 'tradition' for a long time: * https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2020/07/the-nifty-fifty-and-the-old-normal/ https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2020/07/the-nifty-fifty-and... * https://theirrelevantinvestor.com/2018/11/26/the-nifty-fifty/ https://theirrelevantinvestor.com/2018/11/26/the-nifty-fifty... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nifty_Fifty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nifty_Fifty * https://etfdb.com/history-of-the-s-and-p-500/ https://etfdb.com/history-of-the-s-and-p-500/ * https://www.qad.com/blog/2019/10/sp-500-companies-over-time https://www.qad.com/blog/2019/10/sp-500-companies-over-time It's just that which companies have been the top 20% has changed over the decades.
- roenxi 6y agoI like Bogleheads and their philosophy, but I do worry about the risks of advertising doing things on autopilot. If index funds become big enough the equilibrium for active traders shifts from trying to own great companies to trying to game the index fund algorithm. Investors have to pay at least a little attention to the market to make sure that they are still sane.
- xapata 6y agoPart of the funds' expenses (thus the expense ratio) are investment in techniques/technologies to avoid getting fleeced by hedge funds as they rebalance.
- stevep001 6y agoIt only takes about 30 seconds to show that the BH site is anything but dogmatic. For example, check out the Hedgefundie thread on risk parity investing using leveraged ETFs (now at 9000 posts): https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=288192 https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=288192 or this recent post on factor investing: https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=257223 https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=257223 as proof of the board's openmindedness. The bread and butter for BH is the unsophisticated investor who is paying their Edward Jones advisor 1-2% for an overly complicated, underperforming portfolio. These folks are better served by a simple plan (like the three fund portfolio) that they administer themselves. Their success in investing is mostly driven by advice to save and maintain long term exposure to the market. Saving that 1-2% makes a meaningful difference in their retirement lifestyle. Ordinary people can come with their portfolios and get free, unbiased financial advice that saves them thousands of dollars a year. Investing discussions are the tip of the iceberg, though. Anything related to personal finance is germane. Discussions of tax planning, estate planning, withdrawal strategies, with participants who are experts in the field, are invaluable. For example, this long running thread with monthly posts that tracks a forward test of a mechanistic Variable Percentage Withdrawal strategy (as an alternative to the 4% rule): https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=284519 https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=284519 Personal Consumer Issues section is golden for advice on purchases. It's real secret, though, is the heavy moderation. It is very strongly curated around its subject matter, and in particular its "no politics" and "posts must be actionable" policies work to ensure that it has a very high signal-to-noise ratio.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Saving that 1-2% makes a meaningful difference in their retirement lifestyle. If you really want to see how much a few fractions of a percentage point can effect things a fellow named Larry Bates has a really good interactive page where you can enter various numbers: * https://larrybates.ca/t-rex-score/ https://larrybates.ca/t-rex-score/ Starting with $100K, with returns of 5%, over 25 years: * a 2% fee will net you $209K at the end * a 1% fee wil net $266K * a 0.50% fee will result in $300K 1.5% eaten away in annual fees, compounded over 25 years, sure adds up.
- surajs 6y agofunny how you never find gems like these on any other site, go HN!
- palcu 6y agoIn the same category, if you live in the UK then http://monevator.com http://monevator.com is the go to source for passive investing advice. The comments section is a gold mine as well.
- dan1234 6y agoI’d second Monevator, but also add the UKPersonalFinance subreddit as a great source of UK specific info (they have a great flowchart[0]). [0] https://flowchart.ukpersonal.finance/ https://flowchart.ukpersonal.finance/
- baxtr 6y agoThe passive investment strategy was very good for me. I was quite active before, lost a lot of money, was occupied with the topic daily. Now I have peace of mind and a great return on my money. The book that made me rethink everything is “The simple path to wealth” by JL Collins. It’s basically a round up of his blog posts. Although the title is a bit cheesy I can’t over recommend the blog/his book. It’s eye opening and straight forward to implement. He only recommends funds of Vanguard, John Bogle’s fund.
- vagab0nd 6y agoThis forum is a treasure trove of financial information but it's too much for me to read. Hmmm.. if only a computer program can read all that and tell me what to do. Does GPT3's training set include this? I want it to be my financial advisor.
- throwaway50ish 6y agoRequesting recommendations and resources: Almost 50, after a few boom and bust years, I’m finally debt free, but have zero savings or retirement, and make north of $200K. I have a partner to think about in my plans (so, retirement for two). Job will let me work from home permanently, so I’m moving to Nevada. I can aim to max out 401k contributions, and then what? I consider things like side hustles (with my partner) that could generate additional incomes which would go straight to retirement. I considered investing in a B&M business that would generate modest income that could go to retirement but that’s a weird option given pandemic circumstances. I may be generating more income at some point that would let me pivot to self employment with non-salaried caps on income, but I won’t know for about a year (side hustle generating money isn’t past that “it’ll be stable now” maturity level yet).
- sigstoat 6y agothe bogleheads wiki and forum is of course, a great resource, better than HN for this. > I can aim to max out 401k contributions, and then what? unless your 401k has extremely good expense ratios (<0.1%), i'd: put enough into the 401k to get the full employer match, then max vanguard/fidelity/schwab IRAs for yourself and your partner. then go back and max the 401k. (i think you'll want to do a backdoor roth on that IRA, but i'm not familiar with that, as my income isn't quite there yet.) at 200k i expect you can pull all of that off easily enough. > I consider things like side hustles... at this point you're already generating more funds than you can squeeze into tax advantaged status. so... make as much as you can, save as much of it as you can, and aim towards investments that produce fewer dividends, so that you can reduce your tax burden.
- throwaway50ish 6y agoThanks, will dig into researching this.