10 ms·
Could they not pick better names?
by 29athrowaway 6y ago
Could they not pick better names?
- riffic 6y agocould they not paint the bike shed in that color?
- 29athrowaway 6y agoDo you think women would be comfortable contributing to a project called "boobsize", which is part of a larger project called "weboob"? Not to mention "QHandJoob". It's a horrible idea and if you don't see it that's not my fault. One thing is painting the bike shed red or blue. Another thing is to put a sexual graffiti on top of it. The latter is no longer bikeshedding. There's a difference.
- riffic 6y agoWhile I agree that the name is unfortunate and problematic, the bike shed reference was intended to be a metacomment pointing out no matter what people post on HN, it is inevitable there will be a gripe about that project's name. edit: and there seem to be larger problems with the developer and the project altogether considering other comments posted here. ick, but the author has every right to be icky.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoPick a baby name: a) John b) Robert c) Dickhat Is there a name that doesn't belong here? See? This is a non-discussion. You cannot name a project "QHandJoob", what the hell is that.
- riffic 6y agoIf a fully grown adult wants to be named "Dickhat" I don't see anything wrong with letting them have that choice, with a full understanding of its implications. Same if they want to name their sculpture, invention, magazine, or club something patently offensive. This isn't really equivalent to the name of an infant who has no choice in the matter. This is, however, the single most trivial discussion people can have about a project and it's quite a common thread here on HN.
- froasty 6y agofound "think of the contributors" http://laurent.bachelier.name/2018/07/a-proposal-for-sanitizing-weboob/ http://laurent.bachelier.name/2018/07/a-proposal-for-sanitiz...
- hydragit 6y ago> Do you think women would be comfortable contributing to a project called "boobsize", which is part of a larger project called "weboob"? Not to mention "QHandJoob". Looking at the authors, several women did contribute to the project.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoAll good names are taken. This sounds fun.
- wk_end 6y agoWhat, you don’t want QHandJoob on your desktop?
- weboob 6y agoOr wetbook, comparaboob, or boobsize? http://weboob.org/applications/ http://weboob.org/applications/
- dhosek 6y agoOh dear, it's clearly intentional and, frankly, not that funny. The concept is kind of neat, but I don't think I will use these people's software.
- nyberg 6y agoIt's a great filter for those that care more about names than code.
- dhosek 6y agoIt's not a question of caring about names over code, it's a question of dealing with software written by people who are at best emotionally immature and are likely to have negative values of half the population. This is a warning sign about the quality of the code too. Cultural assumptions can make a big difference in the design of a program. I also wouldn't use software written by white supremacists no matter how well-written it is.
- nyberg 6y agoWhy it's a good filter. It deters a large portion of those that attack someone based of silly jokes the authors may have made in the past or present and would judge without speaking to the person before hand to get a better view of who they actually are. Judge the code for technical merit and not the assumed character of the author. Denying work based on social correctness only curbs engineering and scientific progress in the long run over bikeshedding matters.