3 ms·
These articles always leave out whether and how much the person actually ended up paying. Being an attorney, she should not have paid more than $175. Medical p
by mindslight 6y ago
These articles always leave out whether and how much the person actually ended up paying. Being an attorney, she should not have paid more than $175.
Medical providers get away with playing price roulette under the theory that when you show up and ask for help, they're entitled to fair compensation for their services. Their billing department then goes to work manufacturing a bill that justifies "costs" much higher than they actually incur, and there is no specific way to refute them.
But in this case, she had a contract for those services at $175. The provider can't just decide that they deserve more than their contracted rate and send her an additional bill. That would be like going to the grocery store, paying your total at the checkout, and then receiving a bill in the mail for the cashier's time under a theory that you had only paid for the food.
Since the victim here is an attorney, writing a strongly worded letter repudiating the fraudulent bills should have come naturally. Did she do this? Did the provider then go to court and successfully substantiate their fraud, or what?
edit: I don't know what the downvotes are for.
Reading the article again, I guess she ended up punting to insurance and so far has personally paid $0. Although her insurance states that she may have to pay "up to $600", so the matter doesn't seem over. These stories always lack so much agency, its frustrating.
The cost disease is a problem, and it seems none of the businesses involved have an incentive to reign it in. Apart from the future possibility of single payer, cash payers are currently one of the few checks on the market. But the dynamic is never fully explored - just because someone sends you a bill does not mean you have to pay it!
- pessimizer 6y agoMy downvote is partially because you seem to be objecting based on what you think "can't just" happen, rather than on observations of what did happen, or citations of relevant law. Additionally, you have specific objections based on what you've decided that this specific person should be capable of and what should come natural to them, and also assuming that this action would be productive (rather than costing more than $2500 to see through.) Seeing as the larger question isn't about how much lawyers are charged, but how much people in general are charged, it seems like a irrelevant observation. I don't think you meant to sound like this to anyone, and I think we're probably on the same side of the issue. To me, getting bogged down in specifics is an enemy to systemic change (only when the specifics don't threaten to contradict the general case - when they do, specifics are of course important.) If I know of a good way for a particular person to get out of an irrationally inflated medical bill, that's really something that I should be communicating with that person. If I see that people in general don't use a good method (that I am personally aware of) to get out of irrationally inflated medical bills, then either 1) the system is broken because it's not automatically funneling people toward that method, or 2) if everybody used that method, it would start to fail, which means that the solution was never a universal one.
- mindslight 6y agoThanks for responding. I agree you can go from what I said to "the system works there is no problem", but that is certainly not my intent. Unfortunately flipping between different paradigms (individual action vs collective action) is always going to feel like this, because it is exactly what politicians get paid to do to us. This tendency to judge other-paradigm thinking as justification for corruption is a cause of our polarization. I have personally been in this situation, but for much smaller stakes ($80 initial quote, $50 agreed-upon xray charge, $120 surprise charge at the end). I complained, they dropped it a bit, and I rolled over and paid it on the spot because I was in the process of administering an estate and didn't need more paperwork to save $70. So yeah, life can certainly get ahead of all of us. But this isn't a friend telling me her story while I'm telling her she's wrong, but an example that has been elevated to a news article. What is the article's overall point - the healthcare industry is corrupt and Covid is yet another opportunity for a cash grab? We already know that! To the extent that my basic explanation in terms of contracts is incorrect because there's some Texas statute that allows healthcare providers to engage in surprise billing even when there is a contract, then this article really needs to cite it - scrapping that law would be a direct path to reform! If there is no such law, and this has just developed by custom, then these articles need to investigate what happens when you litigate this. Imagine widespread form letters to repudiate fraudulent debts - half of these cases would disappear overnight. Otherwise we're left sitting and just waiting for single payer, which will be yet another corporate cash grab. I do think single payer is the way forward (let patients deal with one bureaucratic nightmare instead of being trapped in between two of them), but if you think it's going to be some straightforward sea change then check out how Medicare Advantage plans work.