6 ms·
It appears as though very few Hacker News commenters have spent any time using Tiktok. It is the only enjoyable, enriching social media service I've ever used.
by xnx 6y ago
It appears as though very few Hacker News commenters have spent any time using Tiktok. It is the only enjoyable, enriching social media service I've ever used. Most everything many of us liked about the old/weird internet is present on Tiktok right now: almost no ads or commercial presense, personal content from real people (not hyper produced productions from influencers and pros), weird content, niche content, organically viral content, positive/encouraging comment sections. I've been exposed to such a huge diversity of things on Tiktok: people with physical disabilities, hilarious and creative videos from high schoolers, an elementary school kids frog journal, dance videos with single-digit views, large engine repair tips, home improvement tips, pet ducks, absurdist memes. You owe it to yourself to not dismiss Tiktok as a time-waster for idle teens. Those positive aspects of Tiktok are something we should be figuring out how to expand elsewhere.
- ptx 6y ago> almost no ads It usually starts out that way with any centralized for-profit communications platform. They wouldn't want to spring the trap before luring you in.
- edoceo 6y agoCome into my parlour said the spider to the fly...
- monocasa 6y agoAds are coming either way the platform goes. I was getting ads on Facebook _from_ TikTok trying to get me to create ads on TikTok. A meta-ad.
- Causality1 6y agoBut it doesn't make up for the downside, which is installing robust surveillance software on your phone that sends data to and takes orders from China and is subject to their arbitrary control of messaging. You know what else has a super amazing upside that still doesn't make up for the downside? Methamphetamine.
- leptoniscool 6y agoI think you need to look up Edward Snowden.
- gbrown 6y agoWhile US surveillance is also bad, it’s not yet subject to the same levels of abuse as in China. Don’t get me wrong, if this administration could, I’m sure they’d find a way to compete on that front, but we’re not there yet. The Chinese government is running forced sterilization, reeducation, and internment campaigns against Uighurs. They’re arresting people for being critical of the government online based on dragnet surveillance. Again, I’m not defending the US on these points - we’re running concentration camps too, and the fourth amendment is under assault, but there are important differences of scale and severity.
- Causality1 6y agoHaving a roach problem in my house doesn't mean I'm happy to invite termites as well.
- chvid 6y agoSo many IT-professionals here; only very few actually sitting down and trying to understand the appeal of this thing. And so strange to see that everyone assumes that TikTok can be taken apart by a competitor (Triller) paying top creators to shift platform and the rest will just go to Instagram or YouTube. If you spend some time on TikTok you will notice that the experience is actually not orientated around top creators but is guided by algorithm that entertains you in personalised manner. What you are seeing not necessary new, not necessary from someone within your social graph. It is really is something quite different from older social media.
- gigatexal 6y agoAs long as it’s a Chinese owned surveillance application I’ll not touch it. I got rid of Facebook for similar reasons (s/Chinese/American). I’m not sure I see the synergies MSFT gets from TikTok - a Snap Inc., makes more sense as a buyer to me.
- maltelandwehr 6y agoMSFT has an advertising business. TikTok Ads would be a nice addition to Bing Ads.
- gigatexal 6y agoAhh I had forgotten about bing :eek:
- kenhwang 6y agoOn the other hand, Tiktok is the only social media platform I absolutely can't stand. Low quality content, repeated jokes, people desperate for attention, impersonal, memes, and all of it video so there's an unavoidable fixed time cost. With so much good high content available on the internet and how little time people have, it saddens me that so much time is spent on the low quality noise.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoRegarding content quality, I don’t see TikTok isn’t meant to be an epic dessert at a 3 star restaurant. I see it as a can of Pringles when I have the munchies.
- maltelandwehr 6y agoLow quality? TikTok videos are much better (in terms of story arc and editing) than Videos on other social networks. And it takes one swipe to go to the next video. The repeated jokes are part of the TikTok culture. Pure copycats will normally not go viral - only adaptions that add their own spin. I agree that it is an insane time killer. But that is because the content is so good and presented in and addictive way.
- mantap 6y agoWhen I tried tiktok it seemed to only give me videos by British schoolkids. Maybe the content is better in some regions than others but the whole region locking thing stinks.
- iKevinShah 6y agoOne of the factors might be region but also: > Consumers (audience) side: Tik Tok use AI to calculate what content will be the best fit for the consumer. When consumer use the app, consumers even do not need to put their preference. AI will automatically get a sizeable database of the consumers’ behaviors. Source: https://digital.hbs.edu/platform-digit/submission/tik-tok-using-ai-to-take-over-the-world/ https://digital.hbs.edu/platform-digit/submission/tik-tok-us...
- rvz 6y agoIf you were in Hong Kong, you will get thrown in jail over a post of critiquing the government actions through viral dancing memes, which the CCP has access to TikTok / Douyin. If you anger the CCP in Hong Kong through its approved social networks, well you are going to be found out.
- jerrygoyal 6y agoI'm not sure about content quality in other countries but in India it's so cringe i cant stand it for 5 minutes! (gen Z might feel otherwise).. So glad it got banned in India.
- ALittleLight 6y agoI laugh heartily at Indian TikToks. Seems like a unique style of humor - the poisoned water bottle meme is hilarious to me and the fact that it occurs in ~20% of the even Indian TikToks is even funnier. (I haven't used TikTok in a bit, so maybe this meme has died out)
- anoncow 6y agoI can understand your concern, but like most things on the internet it depends on who you are following. For example, there are educational Tiktokers and some really creative ones. It also is a social equaliser. The search functionality on Tiktok can be better though. That said, I am not sure about the security aspects.
- tomc1985 6y agoIt's not nearly as revolutionary as the WWW and there's only so much info that you can cram into a short video. So... nah
- rsa25519 6y ago> there's only so much info that you can cram into a short video Which is a huge feature. Unlike YouTube, for example, TikTok videos tend to have no boring intros
- trianglem 6y agoIt’s enjoyable yes but it’s enriching in only the narrowest of contexts.
- xoxoy 6y agoTikTok makes me nauseous. It’s literally crazy to me that we’ve normalized an app targeted to kids and teens that encourages them to make hypersexualized mini music videos that rewards the “sexiest” videos with likes/followers/views/trending. The absolute creepiest part is that anyone can browse and fully download any video without even logging in. You would have to be completely naive to think that there aren’t a million pedophiles on TikTok everyday downloading content of teenage girls and boys twerking to Nicki Minaj songs without a trace. All while we sit back and laugh about it like we’re on Facebook circa 2009.
- xnx 6y agoDupe
- rsa25519 6y agoTagging along, the TikTok algorithm adapts to which videos you skip. It's unfair to claim that the platform has poor quality content without spending at least some time browsing, much more than 5 minutes
- jianshen 6y agoMy personal opinion is people don't realize the app/algorithm doesn't just reward the viewers, it rewards the creators. I do video/photo work outside of coding and at first what got me hooked was the effortless video tools (useful realtime effects, non-generic music). Not a video editor? Someone in my feed already posted a 15s tutorial so you learn how to create as you consume. Then after posting a few vids as a joke (cuz 15s videos couldn't be anything meaningful right?) the algorithm rewarded me with 100k's views that IG/YouTube/FB/Twitch/Vimeo COMBINED could never give me. Then they randomly invited me to their Slack where I could get tips on how to use the latest new effect, upcoming hashtags and give feedback to devs. I'm not a full time content creator, I'm old and I'm not a looker but for the first time, I felt like I could be a content creator and all I did was post a few 15s videos. It just works. I don't want to debate the politics, security issues or your judgement of the content. I want whoever comes up with the next killer app to learn from what they were able to achieve because they hit an amazing product market fit and I'm hoping the HN crowd can at least understand that. /rant
- rumanator 6y ago> the algorithm rewarded me with 100k's views Question: a) why do you interpret that as a reward? b) what leads you to believe those views are real or even meaningful?
- robbrown451 6y agoThese are odd questions to me. I can understand why someone might not care about having some level of "internet fame." But I can't really understand how someone can not get how that can be rewarding to many. Do you understand why people are rewarded by an audience applauding them? Do you understand why a musician would be excited to hear their song on the radio? As for how they know the views are real... do you think TikTok is just faking them?
- rumanator 6y ago> I can understand why someone might not care about having some level of "internet fame." But I can't really understand how someone can not get how that can be rewarding to many. I've asked the question because I really don't understand the point the OP or you were trying to make. My question was very straight-forward: why do you feel that counter a) has any meaning, specially as a reward, b) is even real. Could you please shine a light on this? After all, even the OP admitted that the counter was not a result of something users did or a reflection of the value of your contribution. The Op framed it as being a number that was gifted to you for no reason. Why do you see any value in it?
- mesa8 6y agoTiktok's recommendation algorithm was TOO personal for me. It started recommending specific teenage girls who went through the same specific traumatic situations I went through as a teenager (which is common but rare <.001%). It completely got into my head and knew more than I would ever admit to anyone (sexual preferences, types, etc..).
- randomsearch 6y agoHN commenter here who has spent a lot of time on TikTok as a relative wanted me to use it. Hard disagree on the OP. It’s like every social network starts out (more positive, no ads), but it has especially lowest-common-denominator content. It’s brilliantly engineered to suck your time away, I’m genuinely very impressed how manipulative it is, really a big step up. And at least one young relative is totally addicted to it, far beyond anything I’ve seen with other networks, so it works.
- ehsankia 6y ago> It’s like every social network starts out Isn't that more reason to enjoy it while it's still great? Early youtube was fantastic, vine was a joy while it lasted, etc. > but it has especially lowest-common-denominator content Disagree. The whole point of having highly specialized recommendation algo is exactly to avoid LCD content. If I see low quality content, I instantly mark it as "uninterested". I have not seen a single "dance video" in almost a year. LCD happens on popularity based systems, TikTok's system is based on your specific usage pattern. > It’s brilliantly engineered to suck your time away Again, yes and no. It's engineered to match your preference. Personally, I have trained my to give me quality content. Of course it technically wastes my time. So does hackernews, but I still consider it great use of my relaxing time.
- gbrown 6y ago> It's engineered to match your preference. No, these things are literally engineered to maximize engagement. Preferences are complicated, and we often actually prefer to consume less content... or at least would prefer to prefer to do so. Apps don’t measure that, they see eyeballs and maximize.
- ehsankia 6y ago> literally engineered to maximize engagement Both can be true though. Personally I only engage with educational and non-low effort content, and that's what the algorithm feeds me. By definition, my engagement comes from non-low effort content, so to claim that TikTok pushes for low effort content is just plain false.
- zeroer 6y agoOn your suggestion I browsed the front page for 10 minutes just to see what all the fuss has been about. Tiktok is worse than I could have imagined.
- tarkin2 6y agoTiktok has beaten the US competition. The soft-power dominance of the US—especially with Zoom—has taken a massive hit lately. China has outperformed the US on the global stage. The fact the US has to ban Tiktok, not outcompete, is surely a worrying sign for the US: it’s now on the soft-power defensive against a cultural and military adversary in one of the US’s strongest areas.