3 ms·
There are thousands of different restaurants to choose from. There are only two pocket computers. And they're both beating people up over protection money. Mo
by echelon 6y ago
There are thousands of different restaurants to choose from.
There are only two pocket computers. And they're both beating people up over protection money.
Moreover, computing used to be free like water. These companies locked it down so you have to go through them.
Imagine if you had to pay McDonald's to open your own restaurant.
Imagine if every restaurant in the US had to do so.
Imagine if McDonald's gathered data about your customers.
Imagine if McDonald's saw what worked about your restaurant, copied it, and then hid yours from consumers.
It's not okay. This is one of the worst abuses of the American consumer and small businesses in history.
Edit: I think we're all being downvoted by corporate brigading. Every one of my posts is being downvoted. I made a compelling and respectful argument, and note the lack of rebuttals.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> There are only two pocket computers. There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. > It's not okay. I'm okay with it.
- RealStickman_ 6y agoThere are two pocket OS systems.
- bhupy 6y ago> There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. There are only 2 major OS's.
- chrisseaton 6y agoAnd doesn't one of them allow your own apps? So why don't you use that one if that's what you prefer?
- bhupy 6y agoI understand that, but your original argument was disingenuous. The central question at hand is the App Store monopoly, and your argument was: > There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. But that number willfully misrepresents the current state of the market as it pertains to the current discussion because all but one of those powerful smartphones only operate on one other OS, and by extension, one other App Store regime. Whether this OS duopoly is acceptable is the whole debate.
- scarface74 6y agoYou know what the “mono” in “monopoly” means right?
- bhupy 6y agoNo, I'm an idiot, please explain it to me. Of course I know what it means — the argument is way more nuanced than "hurr durr there are 2 and 2 > 1".
- scarface74 6y agoIt actually isn’t. When you have a choice between paying a premium and paying half as much like 85% of the world. It isn’t a monopoly.
- bhupy 6y agoI encourage you to read the original article. Couple things: 1. The argument isn't that it's a monopoly, it's that it's arguably monopsony. The issue is less that users don't have the choice to buy the phone they want with the OS they want, it's that developers/suppliers are unable to access a huge chunk of the market without being forced to pay 30% of earnings. 2. While it's closer to a "duopsony" than a "monopsony", it gets a little more complicated when you look at the level of each regional market. In the US, Apple's market share is closer to 50%. Maybe it's not anti-competitive for there to be only 2 app buyers on the market, but maybe it is. That's the debate, and it's by no means clear cut.
- echelon 6y ago> There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. You're being deceptive here. Apple App Store and Google Play Store are what we are talking about. There aren't many other avenues that can reach consumers. > I'm okay with it. You're okay with me having to pay hard earned money to Apple and Google? Having to work that much harder? To be unable to afford to lean into scaling? Because that's awful. Fuck that. These companies are anti-entrepreneur.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> You're being deceptive here. Apple App Store and Google Play Store are what we are talking about. I'm using your own words - you said 'pocket computers'. And you can load your own applications onto Android, can't you? So use that!
- savaki 6y agoI'm not sure what the laws are in Europe, but in the US, there's nothing inherently illegal about being a monopoly. The illegality begins when one tries using the monopoly to gain an edge in other markets. Arguably, Apple has monopoly power in the market they built so nothing wrong there. If you're trying to make the argument that maybe we should change the laws to make monopolies illegal, it would be easier to discuss if you define what the guiding principle is. Are you saying companies shouldn't own more than X% of a market? Companies should comply with a set of practices? etc Here's why it's difficult when you just use anecdotes. Consider your example, restaurants. Restaurants are a local industry with lower barriers to entry so naturally you have thousands to choose from. Online marketplaces tend to be global marketplaces with very high barriers to entry. So comparing restaurants to the App Store is a stretch at best. A better example might be a national every day low price store like Walmart. So let's try your examples with them. Imagine if you had to pay Walmart to open your own store INSIDE Walmart ... sounds reasonable. Imagine if every store that wanted to open a store in Walmart had to do so ... again, reasonable. Starbucks pays to be inside target, Wells Fargo inside Safeway, etc. Imagine if Walmart gathered data about your customers. They do, and again reasonable. Imagine if Walmart saw what worked at your store and copied it and hid yours from your consumers. This happens as well. Consider Equate, Walmart's private brand. Or Safeway select. Basically the same thing.
- echelon 6y agoI think we fundamentally disagree about Apple's behavior. > Arguably, Apple has monopoly power in the market they built so nothing wrong there. Apple embraced the web and the internet, then extinguished it as a means of getting software to consumers. > Online marketplaces tend to be global marketplaces with very high barriers to entry. This is false. The web is a free for all. A better analogy for iPhone and Android being marketplaces is x86 and ARM being marketplaces. Can you imagine having to pay to run your code and your commerce on CPUs? Phones should be utilities. > A better example might be a national every day low price store like Walmart. I don't know. There's Target, Home Depot, Lowes, Whole Foods, Kroger, REI, Dick's, CVS, Dollar Tree, Dollar General, ... Why don't Netflix and DHH try to sell their wares there?
- 6y ago