5 ms·
This is like complaining that it's unfair that only McDonald's are allowed to sell inside a McDonald's.
by chrisseaton 6y ago
This is like complaining that it's unfair that only McDonald's are allowed to sell inside a McDonald's.
- mathnovice 6y agoHow is a Mcdonalds restaurant (which McDonalds owns) in any way equivalent to my iPhone (which I supposedly own).
- albertop 6y agoNothing prevents you buying Android phone if you do not like Apple policies. The policies were in effect when you bought your iPhone.
- scarface74 6y agoWell, you chose to own an iPhone knowing it didn’t meet your requirements. Do you need the government to protect you from your own decisions?
- Silhouette 6y agoGiven that (a) no smartphone exists that is a perfect fit for my ideal requirements and (b) having some smartphone is now almost essential to function normally within society I would say yes, I absolutely do want the government to intervene. Market competition is obviously not doing the job, and none of us individually is strong enough to force the issue with the suppliers. That is exactly the situation where regulatory intervention is appropriate to protect the little guy from the power of the big guy.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> I absolutely do want the government to intervene Well I don't know what to say apart from this is incredibly selfish. You can't find a product suited to your particular esoteric requirements so you want the government to force someone else to perform labour to build the product you want. Can you see how wacky that sounds when you write it out like that?
- Silhouette 6y agoBy that argument, all consumer protection laws should be abolished. Clearly I don't agree with that position. I don't think it's selfish to argue that government should protect the little guy from being exploited by the big guy who has much greater power, for each of the numerous little guys affected by a situation. Indeed, that is arguably one of the most important functions of any government. I would have less of a problem with this if we were discussing some luxury item that people could easily do without. However, the reality is that many organisations -- including government entities at various scales in my country as well as other essential services -- now effectively require the use of certain technologies in order to function as a normal member of society. It is therefore reasonable to ensure that the technologies available are provided on an acceptable basis. If a supplier doesn't want to play by those rules, they're not forced to perform any labour for me or anyone else here. They're perfectly entitled to simply exit the market instead.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> However, the reality is that many organisations -- including government entities at various scales in my country as well as other essential services -- now effectively require the use of certain technologies in order to function as a normal member of society. But you can already access these Government services - the apps already work, right? You don't need a third-party-app-store to use them? So that isn't a reason to change anything. You want the iPhone to be changed so you can do other things with the iPhone, unrelated to these Government services.
- Silhouette 6y agoYou keep quoting a partial comment and then trying to shift the discussion away from the fundamental point. The fundamental point is still that, for practical purposes, many people now have to have a smartphone. There are, for practical purposes, two types of smartphone available. If neither of those meets some reasonable conditions that many people would prefer to have -- for example, retaining control of your own device and data -- then this implies a lack of effective competition in the marketplace. Government regulation is the solution to that problem. Arguing that people don't have to buy the product isn't helpful. Many people are effectively forced into buying one product or the other. Arguing that people don't have to buy the Apple product isn't helpful. Buying an Android one instead is worse in other respects.
- scarface74 6y agoSure let the same idiots who put on the dog and pony show with tech CEOs design the SilhouettePhone just for you....
- Apocryphon 6y agoThat's real snazzy name for a smartphone. When can I preorder it?
- chrisseaton 6y agoIf you go to a a McDonalds and get upset that you can't buy Pepsi, you're unreasonable. If you buy an iPhone and get upset that you can't install your own apps, you're unreasonable.
- oscargrouch 6y agoThe MacDonalds its not yours, while your iPhone is. There's a big difference between the two, and the key difference here is ... Property. But i like your example because its shows the mindset that the iPhone you bought, is in the end the property of Apple, not really yours, and that you are "fine with it".
- chrisseaton 6y agoYou can do already do whatever you want with your phone from the point you receive it in the condition Apple sell it to you. But you cannot require that Apple do work to build support for third-party app stores. Property rights do not extend to forcing other people to do labour for you. If your phone doesn't come with support for third-party stores when you buy it then I don't see how it would be your right to have that feature added.
- ac29 6y ago> But you cannot require that Apple do work to build support for third-party app stores. Property rights do not extend to forcing other people to do labour for you. You and I can't, at least not directly. But governments certainly can, if they deem it in the interest of the citizens they serve.
- xvector 6y ago> You and I can't, at least not directly. But governments certainly can, if they deem it in the interest of the citizens they serve. Tyranny defined. “Do what we tell you to do, it’s ‘for our citizens.’” That’s how you get Australia forcing companies to backdoor encryption.
- 6y ago
- echelon 6y agoThere are thousands of different restaurants to choose from. There are only two pocket computers. And they're both beating people up over protection money. Moreover, computing used to be free like water. These companies locked it down so you have to go through them. Imagine if you had to pay McDonald's to open your own restaurant. Imagine if every restaurant in the US had to do so. Imagine if McDonald's gathered data about your customers. Imagine if McDonald's saw what worked about your restaurant, copied it, and then hid yours from consumers. It's not okay. This is one of the worst abuses of the American consumer and small businesses in history. Edit: I think we're all being downvoted by corporate brigading. Every one of my posts is being downvoted. I made a compelling and respectful argument, and note the lack of rebuttals.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> There are only two pocket computers. There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. > It's not okay. I'm okay with it.
- RealStickman_ 6y agoThere are two pocket OS systems.
- bhupy 6y ago> There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. There are only 2 major OS's.
- chrisseaton 6y agoAnd doesn't one of them allow your own apps? So why don't you use that one if that's what you prefer?
- bhupy 6y agoI understand that, but your original argument was disingenuous. The central question at hand is the App Store monopoly, and your argument was: > There are thousands of powerful smartphones on the market, from many different companies and even countries. But that number willfully misrepresents the current state of the market as it pertains to the current discussion because all but one of those powerful smartphones only operate on one other OS, and by extension, one other App Store regime. Whether this OS duopoly is acceptable is the whole debate.
- krzyk 6y agoMore appropriate analogy: Let say Apple is BMW, and when you buy BMW your gas tank has a proprietary connector that will work only on BP gas stations. You can choose different gas there (different octane number, etc.), but you can't tank at e.g. Statoil.
- chrisseaton 6y agoAs long as this is disclosed to the customer up-front and as long as you can buy a different car to a BMW, then I do not have any moral objection to this. I admit I probably wouldn't buy such a car myself as I don't see any advantages. I do see advantages to the Apple model - simplicity and cleanliness. If you disagree then you should probably do as I would with the BMW - buy something else instead.
- throwaway34241 6y agoIn general I agree, but once a business becomes powerful enough it may be able to reduce competition in what otherwise might be competitive markets. Lets say at some point drivers of GM vehicles buy 60% of the gas sold. Gas stations must agree to use proprietary connectors to service GM cars. Because of GM's market share, the majority of gas stations decide to use GM-only connectors, which then sells more GM cars... Such a cycle is great for GM but probably not good for consumers if you think competitive markets are pro-consumer. And it affects people who don't even buy GM cars, because it influences what 3rd party business are viable. I think that's a key difference between companies with enormous market share engaging in anti-competitive behavior and companies with minority market share (like BMW) doing it. As another example, I think it would have been unfortunate if home internet service providers (of which many people have a choice of only one or two, and it's a big hassle to change) became a bottleneck for other types of services such as online streaming (perhaps by charging exorbitant bandwidth costs to competitors). Luckily I think that ship has mostly sailed, and even in the absence of regulation abuses are probably somewhat kept in check by the very real possibility that regulation will happen if things go too far. I think there's an argument to be made that it would be bad for a duopoly in the mobile OS market (Apple/Google) to lead to a reduced level of competition in app stores, payment processing, and possibly computer software in general (because of the approval process). And even though Apple may not have an absolute majority on market share, the percent of software revenue is probably more important and Apple's share of that is probably quite high. There's probably reasonable ways to address this too. Maybe by allowing other app stores (that follow the same sandboxing / security rules), which seems to work out fine on platforms like Windows with options like Steam. And maybe they could let Apple continue to require support for a common payment method, but not let them prohibit other payment methods or require that those other payment methods are the same price (when the fees on the other payment methods may be much less than 30%).