3 ms·
I think it's interesting how few read to the end. The author is a "professor of the practice of public leadership." At a business school. It's worth asking wha
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
I think it's interesting how few read to the end. The author is a "professor of the practice of public leadership." At a business school.
It's worth asking what a "professor of the practice of public leadership" is, because - with my combined liberal arts and STEM academic background - I honestly have no idea.
Which piques my curiosity, because this piece reads like a parable. Second son not interested in college? Never mind. He can always work dawn to dusk - note that work ethic - among "hard-working honest folk." And then join the marines. Where happiness ensues.
As career outcomes go, what could possibly be more wholesome and indeed American?
Which is why should we teach the liberal arts in colleges and schools. Because if we taught the liberal arts - including media literacy and critical thinking - this piece would be seen for what it is: a transparently manipulative piece of propaganda written by someone who works for a right-wing think tank.
Now - you can agree, or not agree, with the political positioning. But unless you are liberal arts-literate, you will not be agreeing freely. You will not know how a piece like this is crafted with stock techniques of manipulative rhetoric to persuade you of a point of view, and a course of action, and in fact a complete moral package, while appearing to be an entirely anodyne but reassuringly plain speaking personal story.
Because - apparently - that is what "the practice of public leadership" really is.
- grawprog 6y agoThat's pretty much what public leadership is have you ever seen a leader that doesn't do that? I've never had any liberal arts background, but we sure did learn to persuade people in my biology schooling. It's pretty much required to get anyone to care about saving animals and forests over making money. Public leaders do the same thing every day to get you to agree with laws or decisions they make. Corporate leaders do it to get people to buy their shit or work for their company. Leadership, is literally persuading people to follow you. Because in the end, you're going to be a lot more successful as a leader doing it that way than through orders and fear or something. As to the rest of your post about the article itself though, I don't disagree with you, having written many persuasive things designed to sway people using facts, and perfectly placed numbers, that's pretty much what this is.
- rtx 6y agoSounds like good old marketing and sales.
- golemiprague 6y agoGive me a break, most liberal arts students don't have any more "critical thinking" than anybody else. They also don't have much knowledge about liberal arts. They just do it so they can have the title "college graduate" which will open the doors for them for certain jobs in the corporate world, mainly secretarial in nature which they could have done with a 3 months internship. As a society I believe we should put some of our common resources into teaching young people a profession and into maintaining and developing our knowledge in all possible subjects, whether scientific or arts or whatever. But it needs to be more targeted, if someone studying a profession they should study a profession and if someone want to study for the sake of academic advancement they should do it but we shouldn't confuse the two things and the system as is is just a very inefficient, prolonged and expensive job entry evaluation test. Armies around the world are doing the same thing in couple of basic tests and then teach those profession in a 3 months course. You don't need a liberal arts degree to do any job in the HR department and those, usually women, who study it don't contribute any advancement to the liberal arts anyways.