4 ms·
The only monopoly here is Apple’s monopoly on designing its own products. The iPhone, iOS, it’s development tools and the App Store are all Apple products, so A
by simonh 6y ago
The only monopoly here is Apple’s monopoly on designing its own products. The iPhone, iOS, it’s development tools and the App Store are all Apple products, so Apple gets to decide what features they have.
It’s also not unusual for companies to make deals with third parties to include their technology and software in their products, often as optional chargeable extras. That’s all the App Store is, it’s a way to add optional features to your phone, offered by the phone manufacturer. There is nothing illegal or abusive about this.
What’s the alternative. Are you going to mandate what features Apple, or any manufacturer of devices with embedded software, can or cannot implement? Are you going to mandate by law specific features for side loading that all manufacturers have to implement in all devices containing software? What features, who gets to specify them, how will this be enforced?
So now we’re going to have governments design the software in our phones, enshrined in law?
Finally, how does this serve my interests as an iPhone user or developer? Is fragmented app stores going to make it easier to find software, make it easier for developers to connect with customers and increase software revenues? I don’t see it.
Android has had tons of app stores over the years, the public converged on the Play Store because they want to go to one place to get apps and have one company to deal with. Users like consolidation, it serves their needs.
All this does not mean I’m against any regulation. I thing there’s a reasonable case for oversight of these things and a dialogue between law makers and tech companies about how they manage their products and customer relations. That’s fine, but chopping up the market and products arbitrarily does not serve the public interest.
- Apocryphon 6y agoIf the government forces a platform open and hands it over to a consortium of industry leaders, as well as associations of independent developers and open source foundations... sure why not?
- xvector 6y agoBecause the government should not have unilateral power over a platform you've poured your own time, money, and effort into developing. That would be theft. I am honestly amazed that people are still in favor of gross government overreach in the era of Trump.
- Apocryphon 6y agoYou can say the same about Ma Bell, or Standard Oil. The pre-edited version of the original post asked the ludicrous question "So now we’re going to have governments design the software in our phones", so he got a ludicrous answer in kind. But in theory, if Apple's control of the App Store platform constitutes a monopoly, it would not be gross government overreach to pursue antitrust, as it has done historically, even if it has been unfashionable in recent decades.
- xvector 6y ago> if Apple's control of the App Store platform constitutes a monopoly, But it's not a monopoly. The vast majority of the "app store" ecosystem is the Play Store. Apple's "App Store" is a minority player. Otherwise you could arbitrarily divide any platform recursively until something is a monopoly in need of getting regulated.
- Apocryphon 6y agoThe OP article argues that it is a monopoly. You are free to agree or disagree with its thesis. However, my statement was that "if Apple's control of the App Store platform constitutes a monopoly", then the government should have free rein to do so, as it has repeatedly done so in the past.
- xvector 6y agoIndeed. I would agree with you if Apple was a monopoly in this space.
- coldtea 6y ago>If the government forces a platform open and hands it over to a consortium of industry leaders, as well as associations of independent developers and open source foundations... sure why not? Because the platform only exists because somebody created it, somebody specific not some consortium. I don't want my iPhone OS to be created by a consortium, I want it to be run by Apple...
- HunterWare 6y agoAnd because if that happens I would promptly go find a phone with a curated locked down store again. If I wanted otherwise I would have bought an Android phone, with my _choice_.
- Apocryphon 6y agoAnd, if the unlocked store charges independent app developers lower fees, and if market trends favor the non-locked down store over the locked down store- say in the example of Android vs. BlackBerry OS- then the apps would flock to the former over the latter.
- simonh 6y agoSo the reward for developing a successful valuable product that hundreds of millions of people like and trust, is to take it away and give it to somebody else? Wow. If that consortium is so great, why don’t they just make their own product. Let the public decide what they want.
- Apocryphon 6y agoTheir reward is being the most valuable company in both the world, and perhaps much of human history. Their reward for restrictive anti-competitive behaviors is antitrust investigations.
- simonh 6y agoMonopoly or anticompetitive regulation is intended to prevent behaviour enabled by market domination. Nothing Apple is doing is like that, they’ve been doing the same since they had 1% market share. The public chose them because this is how they do things. It makes no sense to punish them for that. Justifying punishment simply on the basis of success is morally unjustifiable.
- Ericson2314 6y agoEither the government can tell Apple how to run the App store, or the government can limit iPhones to < x% of the population. I will say it's embarrassing that we've allowed one company's products to become such a status symbol that there is no alternative to the insecure masses, but such is the present world. Then again, perhaps competition itself is obsolete, and we should just get on to centralized socialism already.
- tootie 6y agoI'd love to see a Congressional panel ask why developers need an OSX device to build for iOS and still have to pay a fee to Apple for the privilege.
- millstone 6y agoI'm not sure what you're saying. Is it that all software companies should be required to support developing on every platform for free?
- simonh 6y agoThe iOS application frameworks are Apple products based on the libraries in OSX. In fact in many many cases they are the exact same libraries in OSX, and apps running in the iPhone simulator actually run against the OSX libraries under the hood, not iOS versions of them. To develop iOS apps on another platform, Apple would have to port their entire development tool chain, and their OS application frameworks and test tools to other OS platforms. Why should the be coerced into doing that? These are all their products, what gives you the right to demand that they spend millions of dollars adding features and doing all that work? Should we coerce Microsoft into porting the Win32 development stack and tooling to OSX and Linux? It doesn’t make any sense. If you don’t want to use their products, don’t.
- gioele 6y ago> What’s the alternative. Are you going to mandate what features Apple, or any manufacturer of devices with embedded software, can or cannot implement? Are you going to mandate by law specific features for side loading that all manufacturers have to implement in all devices containing software? What features, who gets to specify them, how will this be enforced? Well, it has been done for Microsoft, it could be done for Apple: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BrowserChoice.eu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BrowserChoice.eu (I'm just stating a fact, not judging whether that is a good or a bad idea.)
- SomeHacker44 6y ago> Are you going to mandate what features Apple, or any manufacturer of devices with embedded software, can or cannot implement? In fact, yes. Just like we mandate cars have seat belts and third brake lights, airliners have emergency exits, automobile fuel contains no lead or added ethanol, houses use electrical wires per code, and so forth. Government can simply mandate a maximum fee (like credit card interchange fee regulation in the last decade), or force the system to allow sideloading (like busting the AT&T attached device monopoly in the 70s), etc.
- Apocryphon 6y agoNot to mention, the EU just ruled recently on what Apple can or cannot include in their actual hardware: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22204174 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22204174
- simonh 6y agoI think lumping this in with health and safety regulations is a super weak argument. In fact it’s no argument, the two are clearly not comparable at all. I’ll accept the comparison to credit card fees though. As I said I’m not against all oversight of any kind. I just don’t think the 30% is all that high.