5 ms·
Are you familiar with British libel law? It's infamously plaintiff friendly. People have lost even though the statements in question were, in fact, truthful.
by eli 16y ago
Are you familiar with British libel law? It's infamously plaintiff friendly. People have lost even though the statements in question were, in fact, truthful.
- timthorn 16y agoI'd like to see references for that. Truth is an absolute defence against libel.
- burgerbrain 16y agohttp://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/sep/20/richard-dawkins-libel-laws http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/sep/20/richard-dawkin... Simon Singh has since won that case last I heard, but it was by no means a given. That it took so long for him to get off for saying fucking chiropractors of all people "quacks" (if they aren't, who possibly could be?) should say a lot about the extent to which correctness or belief in correctness is a real defense. edit: spelling
- xiaoma 16y agofucking chiropractors of all people "quacks" (if they aren't, who possibly could be?) You're mis-informed. Chiropractic treatments are very useful for certain problems. Some quacks say it will treat any and all illness, but most licensed chiropractors I've dealt with have been highly professional. I have first-hand experience. After a knee injury playing on my high school basketball team, I suffered from mild swelling in my right knee. As a result it was difficult for me to fully bend it. This condition persisted for 4 months, despite icing, anti-inflammatories and several treatments by multiple physicians. Eventually, one referred me to a chiropractor. It took him about 10 minutes to find the problem, and he was able make the proper adjustment. Within two hours, the swelling was gone and the range of motion was back to normal. Many whiplash victims are also referred to chiropractors. (FYI, my mother is an MD. I'm hardly a healing crystal using homeopathy enthusiast.)
- burgerbrain 16y agoIf you read the article I linked, the relating articles, or the original author by Simon, you'd know that he was sued for describing chiropractics treating things like ear infections as "bogus". Things that no poorly executed "scientific" study would ever even dream of asserting chiropractics can affect. The extent to which chiropractics can alievate back pain, the only sort of thing they can have a positive impact on in scientifically executed trails, they are only acting as (often unlicensed) physical therapists. IF this is what you go to the chiropractic for, and IF they are a licensed physical therapist, then call them your physical therapist. If on the other hand, they're not licensed, then do yourself a favor and go find one that is. "Many whiplash victims are also referred to chiropractors." The industry itself doesn't seem to agree that whiplash is among the defensible things they treat: "If you have a website, take it down NOW. "REMOVE all the blue MCA [McTimoney Chiropractic Association] patient information leaflets, or any patient information leaflets of your own that state you treat whiplash, colic or other childhood problems in your clinic or at any other site where they might be displayed with your contact details on them. DO NOT USE them until further notice." --the McTimoney Chiropractic Association This all said, even IF chiropractics can effectively treat a subset of the things the claim, they are still quacks for daring to claim the rest.
- xiaoma 16y agoI completely agree that the lawsuit is bogus. I also realize that there are some weird alternate care groups in the UK (which somehow get subsidized by tax payers!) What I didn't agree with was your cursing proclamation that chiropractors are quacks. Had fewer people held that general belief, I probably wouldn't have suffered as long as I did before being referred to one.
- burgerbrain 16y agoIf chiropractors were not quacks, the science would show it. Unfortunately for them, it shows the exact opposite. And your personal anecdote is meaningless. I know an elderly lady who swears she's met aliens. Nice lady, not trying to get on the local news, no reason to lie. I honestly think she believes it. Doesn't mean alien encounters aren't bullshit. Unreproducible anecdotes are not how science works. EDIT: There seems to be a believe in some circles that chiropractors are just a type of legitimate "back doctor". This is the most important misconception that needs to be stopped in it's tracks, the rest would really just be icing on the cake.
- eli 16y agoIANAL, but it doesn't just have to be true -- it's on you to prove it to the court with a high degree of certainty.
- KaeseEs 16y agoIn America, yes, truth is an absolute defense against libel claims; in Britain, truth is no defence, yet: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/mar/15/libel-law-reforms http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/mar/15/libel-law-reform...
- adriand 16y agoI believe the same is true of Canada - a court can find you guilty of libel if you tell the truth with malicious intent.
- latch 16y agoI don't think it has to do with malicious intent. It has to do with whether it serves the good of the public to know the information. If I distribute pamphlets that say "John Smith is gay", even if true, its libel because it isn't information that serves the public's interest. If, however, I distribute pamphlets that say "Smith Jones is a convicted pedophile", then I'm on much safer footing (assuming it's true) because it can (and has) been argued that such information does serve public interest.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mc2k 16y agoI doubt the BBC's legal team would have allowed it to broadcast if they didn't think it would end up in their favour. The losers in this are the British public, who are presumably paying to defend the broadcaster from some car manufacturer who didn't like a review.
- estel 16y agoAt least we have Loser Pays, so it feels unlikely that the license fee payer will actually lose out. As Top Gear is a big winner for BBC Worldwide (commercial, not-license fee funded), it's been frequently the case in the past that they will fund any legal action should that become necessary.
- mc2k 16y agoTrue, but if Worldwide end up paying/losing, that means less money paid back to the corporation, therefore a lower budget for other productions (effectively the same thing). I'm a fan of electric cars, but I am disappointed by Tesla on this... using the legal system like this leaves a bad taste.
- samh 16y agoThat's not as surprising as you may think. "Truth is not a complete defense against libel". Imagine I contacted someones workplace and business partners and told them about a drug conviction that occurred 22 years ago. Or if I took a statement you make after a some drinks in the pub and stuck a print out on poles all around your business. There are cases where suing someone for libel even if what they say is true doesn't seem demonstrably wrong.