3 ms·
What's missing here is a netflix style model where your donations are distributed among people you want to support instead of having to micromanage donations.
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
What's missing here is a netflix style model where your donations are distributed among people you want to support instead of having to micromanage donations.
I pay about ~30 euro per month for netflix, spotify, and amazon prime. So, it's not a stretch of the imagination that I would be willing to pay for (some) of the free content I enjoy on e.g. Youtube.
However, I follow dozens of youtubers asking for donations and while I like most of them, it's not going to add up to me handing out multiple dollars to each of them on a monthly basis because it would add up to vastly more than I spend on commercial content. And it's kind of unfair to single out just a few of them.
But, I'd be willing to put in 10 a month if I did not have to worry about allocating that to each of them or micromanaging who gets what. IMHO a simple distribution based on views/listens/clicks, could work.
It would probably add up to just a few cents per personn I donate to; but if lots of people do that, it adds up. The deal with patreon is that you rely on a handful of people supporting you while you give away most of your content for free. IMHO most of that is unrealized potential for monetization.
Several youtubers I follow have numbers of followers and views that would put some tv channels to shame and they also get revenue from sponsorships. Several others are a bit more modest but still rake in tens to hundreds of thousands of views easily.
I'd love a platform that gives me a simple predictable cost per month combined with a fair, no hassle way to ensure that money gets funneled to artists, writers, coders, and other content creators I care about. Donating 10cents per month is not a thing and donating 1-10$ per month means I have to cherry pick people out of group of dozens to hundreds I might consider donating to but currently don't.
- Nullabillity 6y ago> But, I'd be willing to put in 10 a month if I did not have to worry about allocating that to each of them or micromanaging who gets what. IMHO a simple distribution based on views/listens/clicks, could work. YouTube Premium?
- auxym 6y agoDoes YT Premium redistribute any money to content creators?
- coldpie 6y agoYes, but not to your creators. Google's description is vague, but my impression is YT Premium revenue (after google's cut) goes into a big pool and is split up among all creators: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6306276#YouTube_Red_revenue_2 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6306276#YouTube_Re... So your creators are getting paid by watch time, but not all of your $10 is going only to creators you watch.
- auxym 6y agoYeah, the Spotify model. Not the best thing if your main intention is supporting the creators you enjoy.
- geerlingguy 6y agoYes, but there are vanishingly few people who pay for it, IME. It's maybe 3% of the revenue I get on my channel.
- charwalker 6y agoSome creators note it is many times what ad revenue brings them and is a significant part of their income on that platform. I think LTT and other tech creators have mentioned this however buying merch or subscribing on Patreon/their own site is a bigger generator than anything on YT.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoI don't care about their premium content or enriching Google instead of the creators I want to actually reward.
- addandsubtract 6y agoflattr does exactly that. I never really caught on, though.
- palsir 6y agoyou will likely be interested in this comment below: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24004503 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24004503
- kelvin0 6y agoThis exactly. You could pay your money to some entity that curates the creators and content you enjoy. This entity would then redistribute the payments among the creators. You would go on that platform and create your own content 'bundle'. You could also choose from various pre-bundled categories : tech, science, self-help, cooking, music ... You also would have the option to simply consume some content and pay for that 1 item (song,video,podcast,print or other content). I would definitely go for that!
- charwalker 6y agoSome media groups have done this but only for content under their umbrella like Rooster Teeth FIRST. If you follow a few RT groups, ten it likely pays for itself vs youtube premium as you get live and locked shows on the RT site. I bet Patreon could take on a similar model, but I'm not sure how it would be curated. Who would bundle creators? Patreon, the creator(s), or the user(s)? I don't think Patreon would want to show bias by grouping anything. To support creators working together it might be really cool to see them create alliances and tag team projects. But I'd probably want to bundle them myself to hand pick who I support. I only follow 1 Patreon user, a good (very talented) high school friend with a knack for explanation of musical concepts. He's brilliant on a guitar and I want others to see that.