4 ms·
About 60% of product searches now start on Amazon Now that's a big problem for Google. Product searches are Google's money machine. Google's other big problem
by Animats 6y ago
About 60% of product searches now start on Amazon
Now that's a big problem for Google. Product searches are Google's money machine.
Google's other big problem is being terrible at anything which needs repair or customer support. Their various attempts at becoming an internet service provider, via WiFi, fiber, or balloons, have not been successful. Buying up all the good robotics startups and running them into the ground benefited nobody. The self-driving car thing is a huge money drain that still hasn't produced a product. Anyone remember the Google Search Appliance?
Two other engineering-first companies blew it - Hewlett-Packard, and Westinghouse. Both were successful, profitable, and renowned for excellent engineering. It's useful to study what they did wrong.
- gundmc 6y agoGoogle Fi was widely praised for excellent customer service when they first launched, but I think that reputation was lost as they scaled out in the last few years. Edited to make past tense more clear.
- rainyMammoth 6y agoDo we live on a different planet? Google Fi is well known to be one of the worst customer services. I used it for a couple of months and most obvious queries are automated. Anything that requires an human barely gets any attention. The subreddit for Google Fi is very telling.
- bronco21016 6y agoI think the parent is referring to when it initially rolled out. I was among the first customers when it came out and the customer service was indeed excellent. I was always able to quickly get through to talk to a native English speaker in the US. The support staff were always very knowledgeable and friendly as well. I didn't last long on the service though. I just couldn't live without my iPhone in those early days of the service. No idea how things are now. EDIT: My bad, I see parent is referring to present day. Experience from the early days still stands though.
- OkGoDoIt 6y agoI can’t speak to their email or chat support, but I had to call them a few weeks ago and got through to a human nearly immediately with no frustrating phone tree or hold or any issues. Perhaps their support is inconsistent, but I’ve never heard anything but praise about Google Fi customer support. Especially compared to literally any of their competitors.
- murgindrag 6y agoThere were threads on the internet about thousands of people permanently losing their phone numbers to Google Fi, and having no way to get them back, ever. Google didn't do a thing. Automated systems and disempowered minimum wage drones all the way down. Basic outline was that Google Pay would mark something as suspicious, and refuse to take payments. Payments would stop to Google Fi, resulting in the number / service being frozen. At that point, the whole thing would grind to a halt: * No way to pay Google * Overdue payments and accumulating problems * No way to port number out with overdue account All based on Google's automated systems falsely triggering suspicious activity detection. It didn't happen to me, but I would never, ever, ever even consider Google Fi. I have T-Mobile. Not very competent, but I talk to a human being every time, and if there are problems, they escalate to people empowered to fix them.
- esrauch 6y agoI use Fi and the customer service is just OK, but the baseline comparison is Verizon where the customer service was easily reached but worse than terrible. More than once after talking to them I had seemingly compelling arbitrary fees added or removed, and once the caller ID entirely stop functioning on all phones on our family plan based on actions from CSRs.
- jdm2212 6y agoThe one time I needed Fi customer service, I only got my issue (which had left my phone unable to make calls) fixed after months by abusing my Google employee privileges and complaining directly to Fi engineers. EDIT: I absolutely love Fi. I've had no issues except that one time, and it was years ago. I show up in any random foreign country and every just works. My phone bill for me and my wife both is less than $50 a month these days, which I'm pretty sure is less than a lot of people pay for just one line. But I have this nagging fear that one day my account will stop working and I'll have to call up friends who are still Google and see if they can intercede.
- OkGoDoIt 6y agoI had to contact Google Fi recently and was pleasantly surprised with how easy they were to get a hold of when every other service provider is using the pandemic as an excuse to drop their phone support quality or remove it entirely. Compared to my experience trying to get support from any other utility, from T-Mobile to Comcast to my power company, or any other company no matter how modern (Amazon has been especially bad since the pandemic started, I literally can’t get them on the phone no matter how much I try), Google Fi has been a breath of fresh air. That being said, it’s only a matter of time before they lose focus and that goes away. If there’s one thing Google does consistently, it’s take something good and abandon it or kill it outright. I have no doubt I will be switching back to a traditional phone carrier eventually, but for now I’m a happy customer.
- posguy 6y agoThe Prohject Fi data pricing model made more sense 7 years ago, and with no domestic roaming outside US Cellular, middling customer service and no exclusive phones, consumers are not driven to the service. Sprint & T-Mobile merging also eliminates the core novelty of the service, leaving you with something worse than Ting or T-Mobile prepaid that permits more domestic roaming.
- bane 6y agoI've had mixed experiences. Sometimes they fix stuff quickly or are helpful about service changes or questions. Other times it feels like beating your own hand with a hammer. The worst was when we last switched phones we traded our old phones in. My new phone arrived and my wife's just...didn't. It took weeks to make them believe we didn't steal her phone for some reason and they wouldn't give us the photo from the Fedex delivery receipt (in case it just went to one of our neighbors). It turns out that yes, it did go to our neighbor's house right when they had moved in and it took a couple months for them to even get to the package. In the meanwhile we escalated, escalated, escalated, and so on for weeks until somebody finally just shipped my wife another phone. It could have all been solved in maybe 10 seconds with the delivery photo. Despite that, our phone bill is almost free with all the rebates and data usage refunds and we've traveled all over the planet with the service and it works fantastically.
- bsder 6y agoWestinghouse is easy. Just like GE, they ventured into finance in order to chase returns. While that arm was returning scads of money, everybody turned a blind eye. Of course, at some point your finance arm crashes. In Westinghouse's case, it effectively killed the company by draining it of cash. At that point, Westinghouse had to start selling off portions of the company to fund itself. And thus began the downward spiral.
- galeos 6y agoWhile I wouldn't deny the Google has a poor reputation for customer support across their product range, I can report a notable exception - my Google Pixel (1) phone purchased from the Google Store in 2016. Every time I have had an issue I have utilized the phone's support chat service. I have always been connected to a live support agent in less than a minute. Whenever I have had any issues, I have been sent a replacement handset next-day, including twice after my 2 year warranty expired. The most recent of these episodes was last month.
- autokad 6y agoalthough, I have had my iphone since 2016 and haven't had any issues. In fairness though, I am just an N = 1.
- mmmeff 6y agoSame here, I'd rather a phone that works so well it doesn't need a dedicated support agent app...
- mav3rick 6y agoSo your sample set means iPhone's don't have issues ?
- Talanes 6y agoI think everyone has been very upfront that they're discussing their personal experiences here.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoHonestly they’re a pretty stable product (minus, of course, the infamous planned obsolescence via battery incident). My iPhones have worked as intended since my first (4s).
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago
- toyg 6y ago> Product searches are Google's money machine. Google has something that Amazon doesn't, though: services search. You cannot go on Amazon to buy concert tickets, change phone contracts, or get to a social network.
- typeformer 6y agoYet...
- bonestormii_ 6y agoOOOOoooooo snap. One word, but it's so true. And that's exactly how Amazon thinks. I got my Amazon Fresh grocery order last weekend, sourced from the Whole Foods up the road. The delivery was cheaper than every alternative (Instacart, etc), the produce was great, and the process was painless. If 5 years ago you told me I'd be ordering fresh produce from Amazon with same day delivery, I wouldn't have believed you. Which do you think is more difficult for them logistically? Delivering perishable goods or digital services? Lol.
- toyg 6y agoThey can deliver a subset of services. Unless they have a general-purpose search engine ready to go, they'll likely always lag Google on that side.
- marmshallow 6y agoHere's a great example of their shit support: https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/35889152 https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/35889152
- monkeydust 6y ago100% of my product searches start on Google. 80% of first link I click through is to Amazon. Means 20% I might buy from somewhere else if I buy.
- m463 6y ago100% of my product searches start on amazon. Only after something isn't coming up (or I'm searching a name brand) do I exit amazon. After a couple of disastrous shipping problems outside of amazon (lost money, no recourse), I've come to trust amazon. Recently a USPS package (from amazon) showed up 1 month late, with most of the contents missing (DVDs all gone). Called amazon, quickly resolved and reshipped. No lingering bad feelings, no drama, no extra work, no litigation - amazon just resolved it and I am good. I had amazon prime, but I asked to cancel before the year was up post-covid since I definitely wasn't getting 2-day shipping. Instead they refunded my entire year of prime service. Amazon is not perfect, but I give them my money, they give me value and I have a good relationship with them.
- titzer 6y ago> Google's other big problem is being terrible at anything which needs repair or customer support. This is the direct result of the pervasive 10x/moonshot thinking. Anything that doesn't immediately sound like it can reach a billion users from the outset starts with a massive handicap when getting churned through the decision-making process. Anything that sounds like it requires a human in the loop, anything that has a manual step, anything that requires tech support, documentation, long-term stabilization....not even up for consideration. It's not just the launch-based performance review and promotion process, a problem which has at least penetrated the internal consciousness and is considered now in the whole perf process. It's not just the obvious product cancelations. Fundamentally, Google is not willing to do anything that doesn't scale. They aren't willing to hold users' hands. They aren't willing to be there when something breaks, when something goes wrong, when someone is in a bind because some automated system locked them out, when all those messy unforeseeable situations occur. Putting users first is Orwellian doublespeak, because it's the thing Google hardly ever does--unless you are a corporate advertiser. Users--people like you and me--are the unwashed masses that Google believes it can wall off and keep as far away from its employees as possible. One user? Roundoff error. Ten users? Roundoff error. At Google scale, even a million users is a roundoff error. Is there a 10,000 strong workforce dedicated to users' tech support? No. But there is a 10,000 strong workforce dedicated to sales, marketing, and partner relationships. Those people pull in the billions and billions of ad revenue, so absolutely they have 10,000 people hammering away at that goldmine. And if you are spending money on Google advertising, they will support your ass off. Google is an ad business. Duh.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoA couple of years ago, Google used to have a program called "Shopping Actions" where retailers could pay a fee and get priority placement in product search results. Google, the middleman, then took a cut if there was a purchase.
- mtnGoat 6y agoThey still have this. In fact it just got new features and is free. https://blog.google/products/shopping/buy-on-google-is-zero-commission/ https://blog.google/products/shopping/buy-on-google-is-zero-...
- chiefalchemist 6y agoPut another way, Google has a blindspot. It can't figure out what it can't figure out.
- travisporter 6y agoI'd argue a corollary would be to learn from Microsoft or Northrop Grumman, two engineering first companies that are still going strong.
- stiray 6y agoI think their main problem is going to far on advertising. For instance mentioned amazon... Google search is lately getting so much noise that it is hard to find anything relevant. Even if you actually search for some product, you are flooded with pages and pages of products and it is just too much to do any informed decision. So I will rather use amazon. Regarding what went wrong: same as always - stocks. Immediately when you allow people who have no interest in company but are only money oriented, "enter" the company by buying stocks, you will get huge pressure to earn money for them and what you actually do is second to profit. Then the slow dying of thousand cuts begins. Product quality goes down, everything that can be monetized will be, manager bonuses for yearly results doesnt help either. Google has lost identity. They are just a huge ads bussiness now (if you look structure of their profit). Everything is second to that. And aws and azure surely doesnt help them. Or search that is becoming useless. I really hope it wont go down as something like private data of people that google stockpiled for years might get on sale - and no one wants that to happen.