15 ms·
In my experience, when a manager has a lot of reports, it usually ends up with team members playing all kinds of pathological controlling behavior (e.g mild to
by BeetleB 6y ago
In my experience, when a manager has a lot of reports, it usually ends up with team members playing all kinds of pathological controlling behavior (e.g mild to not-so-mild bullying). Conflicts arise, and team members who are the loudest usually win. The manager simply is too stretched to understand enough to manage these situations. He will usually cede to the people who he thinks are the "experts" in the team.
Essentially, you now have unofficial managers in the team. It's no longer de facto a flat hierarchy. And worse, there is little to no accountability.
People will try to "seize power" and carve out their niche. This is usually not intentional on the part of said people, but I think it is more or less the "natural" dynamic that arises.
I'm sure there are exceptions.
Having a manager who can assert authority and make decisions in conflict situations is great. He/she shouldn't do it often (i.e. micromanage), but a manager who has lots of reports (e.g. > 10) rarely makes good decisions in such situations.
- freedomben 6y agoI tend to agree. Philosophically I really, really wanted to do away with managers but after working in a company that basically did that, it was the loud and forceful personalities that became the de facto bosses/decision makers. It created several monsters that I could not wait to get away from. Having good managers is my goal now rather than having little to no managers.
- quercusa 6y agoBad/weak/over-stretched managers make the best case for good managers!
- Spooky23 6y agoMilitary hierarchy has been pretty similar for a very long time because it works conceptually. Section/Squad/Platoon/Company/Battalion/etc. 10 direct reports don’t work from a management sense unless some folks are expected to operate very independently or if the reports themselves are second level managers, or the manager is only nominally “managing” a time card or whatever. Management to me means you are accountable for output. I can’t be aware enough of what 10 different people/teams are doing to be meaningfully accountable for a longer period of time. It’s not fair to me and certainly not fair to the people not getting the support they need. In my professional life, I’m responsible for a team of ~200, with 5 direct reports. It’s a mix of engineering and product/service teams. We aim for teams of 4-5 with two functions each. The secret is to be as honest as you can, have high standards, and be flexible.
- MetalGuru 6y agoCan you elaborate on what you mean by the last sentence? Sounds interesting