8 ms·
"Instead, why not simply randomly generate a good password for them, and instruct them to write it down or save it in their web browser? If they lose it, they c
by nottorp 6y ago
"Instead, why not simply randomly generate a good password for them, and instruct them to write it down or save it in their web browser? If they lose it, they can use your existing password reset procedure."
Heh. You might as well drop the password and have a 'send the login link to my email" button then.
Why is saving the password in your web browser or any application on your machine - that can also be hacked - considered secure? You're just offering an attacker one single attack point that will yield all your passwords if compromised...
What about people using multiple machines? Should we sync our password store across all our devices, so there is just one server storing them that can be attacked?
And last question, for the SMS-2FA crowd: why would I want my login to depend on my phone number working?
- kabes 6y agoWith your proposed method, the single attack point becomes the email account.
- nottorp 6y agoI know. I was just complaining about generated passwords. Edit: and being forced to depend on a working phone for authentication.
- cordite 6y agoThis is what https://www.fast.co/ https://www.fast.co/ Does
- FabHK 6y ago> Why is saving the password in your web browser or any application on your machine - that can also be hacked - considered secure? So you consider SSH (which normally relies on a private key stored locally) insecure? (Sure, the SSH key can be further protected with a passphrase, but so can the browser database of passwords. On a modern Mac, it requires unlocking with touch ID.)
- nottorp 6y agoSo we have complex secrets that you have to store digitally because you can't memorize. Where? In a secure store. That has access to it protected by a secret you have to store. Digitally because you can't memorize it. And the store where you store the secret for your secure store for your secrets... A touch id protected secret store may be secure, and you lose access to your secrets if your laptop/phone gets stolen or breaks down? Or do you back it up to another store protected by different authentication that you have to store? Looks like you cannot win to me. The only advantage of generated complex passwords is that they'd be harder to brute force if the server has their password database stolen.