6 ms·
Sensing a bit of a trend here. Didn't another major player recently make the same switch?
by Havoc 6y ago
Sensing a bit of a trend here. Didn't another major player recently make the same switch?
- SaveTheRbtz 6y agoI think the best slice of who's migrating to Envoy can be observed via EnvoyCon talks[1][2]: * Lyft (of course) * Spotify * Stripe * Square * eBay * Yelp * Pinterest Plus the support from major cloud providers: Google, Microsoft, and Amazon. [1] https://envoyconna18.sched.com/ https://envoyconna18.sched.com/ [2] https://envoycon2019.sched.com/ https://envoycon2019.sched.com/
- stock_toaster 6y agoSo, seems like nginx is fine until your company reaches the "we are worth billions now" scale?
- user5994461 6y agonginx is never fine for load balancing, they put basic features like metrics behind the paid edition. It's not sane to operate in production. https://thehftguy.com/2016/10/03/haproxy-vs-nginx-why-you-should-never-use-nginx-for-load-balancing/ https://thehftguy.com/2016/10/03/haproxy-vs-nginx-why-you-sh...
- donavanm 6y agoI work for a billions company. Nginx is still fine. Youll need to be prepared to pay for better operations, management, visibility, and protocol support. You can either pay them or build it in house, but you will want to pay.
- user5994461 6y agoThey must all be GRPC users. Developers are pushing GRPC and protobuf pretty hard in companies. The next step down the road is to move to envoy as the load balancer. Otherwise these protocols don't work well over traditional HTTP infrastructure.
- jhgg 6y agodiscord is also on that list - although we have not spoken much about it yet!
- dmicher 6y agoIt may actually become a trend. For well known reasons: - Community - Nginx served us well for almost a decade. But it didn’t adapt to current development best-practices - Operationally Nginx was quite expensive to maintain - C++ - Observability and monitoring etc...
- freedomben 6y agoI'd add another reason: so many people only use nginx as a reverse proxy, and the proxy configuration feels duct-taped on sometimes. Envoy being written as a proxy first makes it a better interface IMHO.
- ci5er 6y agoIs C++ generally considered to be "better"? I've always looked at it (esp. with STL) as kind of a "Swiss-Army-Chainsaw" and you were going to shoot your eye out. Maybe that view is old and things are better - but I learned a while back that sending a young gun into a C++ application's code-base would lead to a world of pain) Maybe that learning is no longer accurate? What do you think?
- dmicher 6y agoWhen we are comparing C, Lua (Nginx) and C++ (Envoy). Yes C++ is better :).
- ci5er 6y agoHonest question: In what way? Platform wars are over-ish. We have the same compile targets. What they call "Undefined Behavior) is relegated to ... well ... platforms we are not supporting. C is fast - simple - easy(ish) to learn, and easy to "fuzz" in testing. I can't speak to LUA - but C++ looks like a mine-field (to me). Why do you declare that C++ is "better"? (Seriously interested - I don't even know enough these days to have a debate. I just gave up on the C++ hell-hole years (decades?) ago, and maybe should have kept up)
- 6y ago
- iampims 6y agoSlack announced they were going to switch.
- Thaxll 6y agoIt's a drop in the water compared to Nginx usage.
- nine_k 6y agoBecause most nginx usage is different? Of course, you can serve static assets using Envoy, and maybe even connect a fascgi app without very much hassle. But it's quite a bit less straightforward.
- SaveTheRbtz 6y agoThat is indeed true. But, I remember the time when we were rolling out nginx back in 2000's and exactly the same thing was said about Apache.
- stock_toaster 6y agoHAProxy is pretty popular too.
- Havoc 6y agoNot if the people switching is the cool crowd. Which is exactly what I think is happening here