3 ms·
> and also because those hospitals get to write off the discounts as losses for tax purposes. If they're following accrual accounting, they earned income (at l
by toast0 6y ago
> and also because those hospitals get to write off the discounts as losses for tax purposes.
If they're following accrual accounting, they earned income (at list price) when they performed thr procedure. If later it turns out they accept less money for it, the discount should be subtracted from their taxable income to reconcile. Most business don't use cash accounting.
It's not rational to be excited to write off a discount; yes, it reduces your taxable income, but only because it reduced your actual income.
- thephyber 6y ago> It's not rational to be excited to write off a discount; yes, it reduces your taxable income, but only because it reduced your actual income. You seem to be approaching this from a purely accounting technicals perspective. My complaints have more to do with the massive distortions that make medical goods/services a very opaque market and creates the ability for profitable businesses to write off fake losses for tax advantages.
- toast0 6y ago> My complaints have more to do with the massive distortions that make medical goods/services a very opaque market I agree it's a mess. I didn't comment on that, because I agree with it. > creates the ability for profitable businesses to write off fake losses for tax advantages I disagree with this part. It's not a fake loss. It's reconciling projected (fake if you want) income with real income. Any business filing taxes with accrual accounting that invoices with full price and accepts a discounted price on payment (or sends to collections at a discount) is going to have the same thing: recognizing the full invoice as income, and then taking a deduction for the discount when settled. Why am I picking on this technical detail? For one, this is a technical forum (I'll show myself out). But importantly, a comment lamenting a real issue (opaque market) and normal accounting practices makes a confusing argument. Switching hospitals to cash accounting isn't going to make the market less opaque.