4 ms·
The treaty germany imposed on france in the war of '70 was no less harsh either. Versailles really wasn't that harsh by the standards of the time, the germans
by masklinn 6y ago
The treaty germany imposed on france in the war of '70 was no less harsh either.
Versailles really wasn't that harsh by the standards of the time, the germans just got good propaganda out of it, for some reason.
- keldaris 6y agoAlthough the issue is complex, a very dominant part of the "some reason" was that the German army never really experienced an unequivocal final military defeat (although it was clear to the high command that the war could no longer be won, this was far from obvious to the population) and remained in effective control of Germany, allowing them to consciously disseminate propaganda for their own ends as well as taking full advantage of the ensuing popular unrest after the end of the war.
- vkou 6y agoTo be more specific - at the time the armistice was signed, no Entente soldier had yet a foot on German soil. The front-line was still running through Belgium. To the average German pundit, it was not at all clear that the war was lost.
- Spooky23 6y agoMaybe. But at that time, the population of Germany was malnourished and short of food, fuel and other commodities. Civilian death rates began to increase. So like our plague deniers today, some people probably deluded themselves into believing victory was near. But I’m sure most knew it wasn’t going well.
- vkou 6y agoGiven that the press was only allowed to publish positive propaganda about the state of the war effort, all of that could have be explained away as some temporary supply disruption.
- vondur 6y agoWell Napoleon had pretty much stomped up and down on the Prussians and Austria during the Wars Of the French Revolution and Napoleonic wars. I think part of the harshness of the treaty that ended the Franco-Prussian wars was a bit of revenge for the Germans.
- jychang 6y agoThat was 1812, though (plus the hundred days). There wasn’t any big German military defeat since the Congress of Vienna system until WWII, a period of over a century. Imagine the USA’s military ego, but instead of losing Vietnam in the 70s, you stomped France instead. The military arrogance was real.
- peteretep 6y ago> There wasn’t any big German military defeat That’s because there wasn’t a Germany for at least half of that period. And while Germany may not have lost any nearby land wars, their colonial empire was a bit of a joke compared to the other European powers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hutzlibu 6y agoParts of the "complex" is that there was a revolution going on, too. The monarchy was overthrown and the military command happily let the representants of the new democracy take responsibility of the "peace treaty". In the meaning of: "see, this is what democracy gives you. While the army is unbeaten in the field, those traitors give up to the enemy."
- billfruit 6y agoAnd in the Eastern front Germany occupied much territories that while the treaties was being negotiated they were left in control for time being over a large swathe of Russian/Ukrainian/Belorusian territories even though in-effect Germany was the loser of the conflict, is what I remember vaguely from a history I had read.
- john_miller 6y agoHow much reparations had the french to pay in 1870?
- keldaris 6y ago5 billion franks, the equivalent of hundreds of billions in today's currency (the exact amount is difficult to calculate for obvious reasons). It was significant enough to promptly cause an asset bubble in Germany when the French paid it with surprising alacrity, which then contributed to the spectacular crash of 1873 and ushered in an economic depression that lasted two decades (though many other causes contributed to the latter, of course - it was a worldwide crisis).
- Rgvh 6y ago1870: 1450 tons of gold Versaille: ~46000 tons of gold
- masklinn 6y ago> 5 billion franks, the equivalent of hundreds of billions in today's currency Due within 5 years too (france managed to pay it in advance as it included military occupation until the war indemnity was paid), as well as ceding a major industrial region.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoOne interesting thing I picked up from (I believe) the Third Reich Trilogy by Richard Evans was that while the repayments were harsh, enough international loans were made to Germany and unpaid once war broke out that the balance of cash flow was actually in Germany's favor. Reading that, it really struck me that perhaps we were still internalizing Nazi propaganda. Or at least that we seek simple narratives to explain everything even if they do a fairly poor job of covering the details.
- refurb 6y agoYup. My understanding was the US was financially supporting Germany so the reparations wouldn’t crush the entire economy. From what I’ve gathered, Germany’s “we’re not paying any more reparations” was more a political move that got Germans on the side of the govt than anything else.
- ithkuil 6y agoI'm confused. You have to pay me 100 bucks, but no worries, I'll loan you 80 bucks over 20 years to help your finances. You'll have to give me 240 bucks.
- refurb 6y agoI'm not that familiar with the details, but it would be more like: - You owe me $1B in reparations, with $10M payable each year for 100 years - You can only come up with $8M this year, so I loan you $2M - You then borrow from someone else to pay me back Kind of like a rolling credit that is more about cashflow than debt level. Countries like the US were worried that Germany would just run out of cash at some point.